Pirates vs Ninjas (poll now included!)

[Master Spoon]

I got to thinking one day (a rare occurrence mind you) and thought what are cooler pirates or ninjas. Pirates have ships and they loot and plunder and ninja just sounds cool. I can,t pick one tell me what you think. :D

[looneylin]

We had this debate at CTY and I say ninja all the way b/c they're awesome and they throw stuff! Although they do attack from behind, they wear black n black is always in fashion. In plus, they have mad kung-fu fighting skills whereas Pirates just say "YARRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR!!!!!!!!!!!!!! I'M A PIRATE!!!!" lol :D

[JoeXIII'007]

Ninjas all the way.

http://www.wizards.com/global/images/magic/bok/higure_the_still_wind.jpg

Source: gatherer.wizards.com (Wizards of the Coast; Magic: The Gathering)

[Adam Richards]

Pirate Ninjas.

[Jeffmudhs]

There are many perks to being both:

Pirate

Has a ship
Has a parrot
could be a captain
has a musket
Plunders!
says "yar"


Ninja

Has an awesome outfit
Has a cool sword
Can throw stuff
is super sneaky (great for when your late to class
Could possibly know how to kill you in one tap
has a super long really gorey family history


It is quite indeterminate to choose either. Do I smell a 'You might be a ninja if..." or a "You might be a pirate if..." thread?

And it would be so difficult to finish this post without to further emphasize the idea of pirate ninja's introduced by adam richards. so thanks to google I present:
http://www.dantrujillo.com/blog/image_pirates_vs_ninjas.jpg

[Chriszuma]

Ninjas, no question! (by the way, don't take the credit for coming up with this question, it's been a raging online debate for years).

Can a pirate slice your head off from a hundred yards away?
Can a pirate impale you without you even knowing you've been spotted?

Additionally:
Shuriken are way cooler than parrots.
A Katana is way cooler than a pistol.
Ninjas can use makeshift weapons like piano wire.
It takes a lot of pirates to take over a ship. It would take a single ninja.

[Jill1022]

Well my friends and I have had this debate several times. I think it all depends on whether you would want to be threatened by natural disasters like a storms on the sea or real people like sheriffs and bounty hunters.

Also, since females were not in good positions (no respect, rape, ect) it would be easier to hide my gender as a cowboy than it would being a pirate (smaller living space, crowded).

Wait? Have I been rambling on and on about cowboys and pirates? NEVER MIND!

Pirates are cool in the cool rugged nifty way, but Ninjas were way more hardcore.

Has anyone ever read the Ultimate Power (http://www.realultimatepower.net/) book / website about ninjas?

[CourtneyB]

Pirates!!! cuz they have cool swords and they say arrr! and stuff.

[Brad Lanpher]

Dude pirates are so much cooler because they pillage and plunder, also they can commender ships.

You should make this a poll.

[nukemknight]

I'd have to say pirates - they can go fishing anytime they want!

(You should make this a poll...)

[santosh]

Pirates are better. Ninjas have no mode of transportation, and pirates have cannons. Could a ninja live with his leg chopped off?
NO. Pirates go and stick somewood on their leg and call it good.

[TheShadow]

Clearly ninjas come out on top, due to their ability to hide in plain sight. The pirates think that the ninjas are just new deckhands, and then BAM, shuriken to the face.

[Mike]

Alligators are better than all of them!

[SteveO]

Ninjas, that are pirates :) I do feel slightly embarrassed posting this as a college student...

[Josh Hambright]

This arguement has actualy come up on 461 before, and i solved it by declaring myself a Ninja Pirate. Thus being the ultimate warrior.

Now the better arguement is Transformer Vs. Transformers...but that arguement is actualy a trick because everyone knows that they are seperate universes and even if they were in the same universe, they wouldn't battle cuz they are both out to fight evil....a DUHH!

but yah, pirate ninjas all the way.

[Justin_302]

har har har.....no arguement here

PIRATES RULE

[Joe Matt]

Ninjas. Hands down.

N > P

[Jeff Rodriguez]

The local radio station (106.9 WCC, the best radio station) had a contest between the two this year at Halloween. But, I had to go somewhere, so I don't know what the results were.
I vote for pillaging ninjas,

[Enterprize]

The best solution is: the ninjas poorly disguised as pirates. They were in a short story i wrote, and they were like awesome. Even though their disguises didn't fool ANYBODY. >.>

[Eugenia Gabrielov]

I'm gonna have to say Piraninjas myself. They're the lovechildren of Pirates and Ninjas, and they pillage burn and destory all in the name of honor.

Even more preferably, I'd say Pyraninjas such as Trogdor win this.

[1086Programmer]

Pirates. :points to Surname: The Pirate Mistress. What do you expect? oO?

Why Pirates are Better than Ninjas

1. Pirates have ships. You can threaten people with seasickness.
2. Pirate men wear jewelry, and men +rings (anywhere appropriate)= hot.
3. Pirates wear sexy clothes. I would know.
4. Orlando Bloom + Johnny Depp.
5. Yar is the best word ever.
6. You can run around in stripes and people won't assume you're a convict.

int happiness;
int pirate;

Pirates = Happiness;

[Chase]

It depends on the situation, in a sword fight either one could win, as both have a lot of experience with a sword. However the ninja would most likely win in hand to hand combat, as many pirates only have one.

[Goober!!!]

How about a CRAZY Pirate that changes into a Ninja some how??? :D :D :D

[Katie Reynolds]

4. Orlando Bloom + Johnny Depp. No kidding! - Too bad all pirates aren't that hot! ;)

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v427/firstae2004/JackandWill.jpg

My vote is for Pirates.

[wilshire]

Ninjas. I mean who could beat a flaming ninja going 300 mph.
And lest not forget the best Ninjas of them all. The teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles.
http://www.rmlicensing.com/ENG/Ninja/ninja1.gif

[kayla13]

Ninjas all the way buit a pirate ninja would be cooler.. can we have a poll?

[Chase]

It was requested that there be a poll on this subject. Which do you think is cooler?

[Adam Richards]

You forgot pirate ninjas. :(

[Chase]

Well everyone would vote for pirate ninjas...

[Mike]

You forgot the "Mike" option.


Duh.

[Kyle Love]

I am straight ninja-pirate-chase-mike-kyle-afied lol

[Ashley C]

You did forget the Mike option. It is the only right answer:p

But since it wasnt there, I picked Ninja -- they are mysterious, sly, can do flips and cool other stuff... and this kid I used to be in love with had this "ninja group" with his friends.

Plus, pirates are like on ships with all men for months at a time -- dirty, hairy, gross. But, they do find lots of gold.

Ninjas are sweet tho.

[MrToast]

Definitely ninja.
Some sample logic:
Batman = ninja
Batman > Pirate
Therefore,
Ninja > Pirate

Q.E.D.

:D Dave

[Freddy Schurr]

i think that ninjas are cool, they can fight and wear cool clothing

pirates are old

[Vince lau]

i want to be a ninja, i alredy know how to kill ppl with a single strike

[Katie Reynolds]

Heads up:

The "Pirate vs Ninjas" thread and "Poll: Pirates vs Ninjas" thread have been merged to created "Pirates vs. Ninjas (poll now included!)" thread. :)

[Loki1989]

dude ninjas all the way no question about it cause the ninja would sneek up an dsnap the pirates neck

[Rohith Surampudi]

oh comon, whens the last time youve seen a ninja go face to face in battle, if you ask me they are kind of cowardly...i mean do Ninja's get Parrots on their shoulders :p

[Kristian Calhoun]

http://r1.fodey.com/14606e0a35ccd4305868f63f9e047dc0d.1.gif (http://tools.fodey.com/generators/animated/ninjatext.asp)

heh. :p
Make your own here. (http://tools.fodey.com/generators/animated/ninjatext.asp)

[Dylan]

Pirates! (specifically Captain Jack Sparrow :D )

[Eugenia Gabrielov]

Well Ninjas don't usually pillage do they?

I hear pillaging is the fun part!

[InfernoX14]

I had a huge discussion/arguement about ninjas vs pirates with one of my friends.

I was in favor of the ninjas. Give me anything you got about pirates, I'll 1 up it with ninja info.

[Morgan Gillespie]

YEARGH They don't call me Cap'n Steve because I dress up in tight black underwear!
Thing is Pirates and Ninjas will never meet. Unless its a water elemental ninja, they hate water, its the night gown they wear, it shrinks in water... YEARGH. VOTE OR BE PILLAGED!

Plus being a web pirate is cool, being a web ninja is creepy. E-Stalkers...

[Hiteak]

Always favored Pirates. They eye patch is a big plus, they can help you with eye safety .Those parrots can really help you memorize new rules when the game comes out by repeating them in your ear. Ransacking is always fun. Plus they don't have talk like a Ninja Day do they? Pirates do! Yarr

[Morgan Gillespie]

Nor do they have a song for Talk Like A Ninja Day, pirates have a song for Talk Like A Pirate Day...
Talk Like A Pirate Day Song (http://www.tomsmithonline.com/freestuff/oddio/TLAPD-Streaming064.mp3)
^Save Target As
Ah I forgot about the eye patches which reminds me of a quote
...Beer and darts... keeping the eye patch industry alive
Just remember only 98 days, 02:39:11 till Talk Like A Pirate Day!

[artdutra04]

Definitely pirates. ;)

After all, just watch any Indiana Jones movie, and then watch Pirates of the Caribbean. One man (Indiana) can easily knock out an infinite number of ninjas, while no matter how many people try to kill a pirate (like Jack Sparrow) he always gets away.

[anna~marie]

I want a samurai choice... *pout* :p

[DevilChild]

I would have to say pirates. Pirates are freaking awesome!! And NOT just the Pirates of the Caribbean kind; I mean the real, plundering, YAR pirates of yesteryear. Pirates made twisting the truth an art form! And I don't mean lying, I mean taking exactly what was said, following it to the minutest detail, and STILL getting exactly what they want while managing to ruin your day. Also, true pirates would never sneak up on someone and stab them in the back. If ninjas preach honor, why would they do that?

[Triple B]

PIRATES

Mike D

[Nica F.]

NINJAS of course!



yeeeep ; may i state that i am also the best female robotics ninja ever? =]

[Loki1989]

Rob Zombie goes for ninja's because they have both legs, arms, and better teeth. and that ninjas can probably kick a pirates butt