A few years of stress is worth a lifetime of opportunity. - omegasis25 [more]
 Chief Delphi Moment of inertia and turning performance
 User Name Remember Me? Password
 CD-Media CD-Spy
 portal register members calendar search Today's Posts Mark Forums Read FAQ rules

#1
04-01-2012, 09:39 PM
 icyplanetnhc The infamous Haoch AKA: Haochuan FRC #0846 (The Funky Monkeys) Team Role: Alumni Join Date: Jun 2010 Rookie Year: 2009 Location: San Jose, California Posts: 7
Moment of inertia and turning performance

Smooth turning has been a challenge for our robot this year. We noticed that unlike our 6-wheel tank drivetrain, several teams have been able to create 6WD with butter-smooth turning. We recognized that our off-center CG degraded our turning abilities. However, I feel that there should be another cause that adds to the "jumpiness" of our turns. My prime suspect is the moment of inertia, both about the turning axis and the middle wheels. Suppose that you have a robot with a fairly well-centered CG. Will large or small moment of inertia about the turning axis result in smoother turning performance?
__________________
"Do the math, save the world." - Mark Leon
FRC #846 -- 2009-2011

Last edited by icyplanetnhc : 04-02-2012 at 05:27 PM.
#2
04-01-2012, 09:51 PM
 Peck worse then failing: proving murphy FRC #1619 (Up-A-Creek Robotics) and FTC # 4633) Team Role: College Student Join Date: Mar 2012 Rookie Year: 2007 Location: Colorado Posts: 237
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

The moment of inertia for the robot is a complex system. (Assuming from here a simple normal system) A low moment of inertia results in a lower rotational momentum and therefor a greater ability to start and stop turning. A high moment of inertia results in a higher rotational momentum and therefor a greater desire to keep turning at the same rate.

If you only want to have a consistent, smooth turn, a high moment of inertia is what you want BUT at the cost of responsiveness and control.

also keep in mind that your CG is only ideally placed when centered if your robot turns exactly around the CG.

Finally: the choppy turning may be because of your programing or your power transfer method.
__________________
Cad, Electrical, Machining, Debugging (old school), PR, Distraction elimination

TEAM 1619
__UP-A-Creek Robotics__
It ain't done till it's over-done

Last edited by Peck : 04-01-2012 at 09:58 PM.
#3
04-01-2012, 09:51 PM
 MrForbes Registered User AKA: Jim FRC #1726 (N.E.R.D.S.) Team Role: Mentor Join Date: Feb 2006 Rookie Year: 2006 Location: Sierra Vista AZ Posts: 5,899
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Usually it's a matter of traction vs. center wheel drop. If you have a bit too much traction, or not enough center wheel drop, then it's kind of hard to turn.
__________________
Jim
#4
04-01-2012, 09:51 PM
 Ether systems engineer (retired) no team Join Date: Nov 2009 Rookie Year: 1969 Location: US Posts: 7,790
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Quote:
 Originally Posted by icyplanetnhc Suppose that you have a robot with a fairly well-centered CG. Will large or small moment of inertia about the turning axis result in smoother turning performance?
My guess is moment of inertia plays a very minor role.

The biggest factors affecting turning for a drop-center 6WD are

- amount of drop of the center wheels

- wheel tread material

- type of flooring

- wheelbase/trackwidth ratio

- location of center of mass

#5
04-01-2012, 09:52 PM
 Alan Anderson Software Architect FRC #0045 (TechnoKats) Team Role: Mentor Join Date: Feb 2004 Rookie Year: 2004 Location: Kokomo, Indiana Posts: 9,061
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

For wheels having similar traction, wheelbase length is the primary factor in how easily a robot turns. The two typical ways to eliminate bouncy turns on a 6-wheel drivebase are to 1) get the center of mass directly over slightly-lowered center wheels, and 2) use omniwheels at the corners to remove friction in the sideways direction.

Last edited by Alan Anderson : 04-02-2012 at 08:39 AM. Reason: specify 6-wheel drivebase
#6
04-01-2012, 10:09 PM
 Andrew Lawrence Posts: n/a
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

No lie. At last year's inspection, we weighed in a tiny bit over the weight limit. Me, wanting to tidy the robot, trimmed all the ends of the zipties we used and, miraculously, we weighed in exactly at 120 pounds!

We used a lot of zip ties that year....
#7
04-01-2012, 10:13 PM
 Gregor Lizard Prince AKA: Gregor Browning no team Team Role: College Student Join Date: Jan 2012 Rookie Year: 2012 Location: Kingston, Ontario, Canada Posts: 2,400
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Quote:
 Originally Posted by SuperNerd256 No lie. At last year's inspection, we weighed in a tiny bit over the weight limit. Me, wanting to tidy the robot, trimmed all the ends of the zipties we used and, miraculously, we weighed in exactly at 120 pounds! We used a lot of zip ties that year....
Wrong thread maybe Andrew?

Lol at your story anyway
__________________
What are nationals? Sounds like a fun American party, can we Canadians come?
“For me, insanity is super sanity. The normal is psychotic. Normal means lack of imagination, lack of creativity.” -Jean Dubuffet
"Insanity is doing the same thing over and over again and expecting different results." -Albert Einstein
FLL 2011-2015 Glen Ames Robotics-Student, Mentor
FRC 2012-2013 Team 907-Scouting Lead, Strategy Lead, Human Player, Driver
FRC 2014-2015 Team 1310-Mechanical, Electrical, Drive Captain
FRC 2011-xxxx Volunteer
How I came to be a FIRSTer
<Since 2011
#8
04-02-2012, 01:22 AM
 Brandon_L Still orange on the inside AKA: Brandon Liatys no team Join Date: Jan 2008 Rookie Year: 2007 Location: Newark, NJ Posts: 1,188
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Quote:
 Originally Posted by squirrel Usually it's a matter of traction vs. center wheel drop. If you have a bit too much traction, or not enough center wheel drop, then it's kind of hard to turn.
Last year we had problems with our 6 wheel kitbot drive. The center wheel wasn't dropped enough, so pretty much all 6 wheels were on the ground. It was extremely jumpy and hard to turn. We solved this in the offseason by switching to the grip wheels in the rear, powered, removing the middle wheels all together, and throwing free spinning omnis on the front. Worked great. And we learned our lesson, this year we have an 8wd that drives like a beast.
__________________
FRC 2495 - Hamilton West Robotics [2007-2014]
FRC 3929 - Atomic Dragons [2012-2013]

Glad to be back & going green in 2017!
#9
04-02-2012, 01:47 AM
 BJT uh, should that be smoking? AKA: Ben Thorsgard FRC #0876 (Thunder Robotics) Team Role: Mentor Join Date: Mar 2007 Rookie Year: 2005 Location: Northwood ND Posts: 246
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

We usually do a 6wd with a 1/8 inch drop center and roughtop tread on all wheels. Our robots always turn smooth as silk but this years robot didn't turn well at all. I think our weight was too centered over the middle wheels. we were able to bolt a 7 pound weight to the back of the robot which completely cured it. With a 1/8 drop center those front wheels are really close to the carpet and I think you need to keep them from grabbing as much as possible for smooth turning.
#10
04-02-2012, 10:26 AM
 Andy A. Getting old FRC #0095 Team Role: Coach Join Date: Jun 2001 Rookie Year: 2001 Location: New Hampshire Posts: 1,010
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

The prime suspect for a 'jumpy' 6 wheel drivetrain would be a combination of traction materials and CG in relation to the center wheels. Also, it's possible for a small center drop to be overwhelmed by the frame flexing enough to allow the corners wheels to see more weight then is ideal.

However there are instances where turning problems can be related to control setup or PID loop tuning, and not just hardware. Are you using a PID loop on your drive train? Are you using one joystick drive? Two? A gamepad? Simple mistakes in the axis mixing or PID terms can result in really wonky turning behavior.

It can also be helpful, though not at all necessary, to use Jaguars on drive motors. They have slightly better performance that can help improve turning at low speeds. The victor/jaguar thing is still a touchy subject, I know, but this is one thing the jags really do have going for them.
#11
04-02-2012, 10:59 AM
 BJC Simplicity is Complicated! AKA: Bryan Culver FRC #0033 (The Killer Bees) Team Role: Alumni Join Date: Jan 2010 Rookie Year: 2009 Location: Kettering/Greenville Posts: 702
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Our team has done a lot of personal testing and evaluation on the top teams in the league and we have found that the CoG and tortional stiffness is generally what sets their robot's drivetrain apart from most others.

CoG, contrary to popular belief we have found that setting the CoG far to one side on a 6wd is best. A 6wd performs best when it is actually a 4wd with 2 extra wheels. Placing the CoG in the middle generally results in the turning point of the robot changing in the middle of the turn as the robot accelerates/decelerates and the outer wheels alernating touching the ground. This is especially important because a 6wd does not turn about the middle wheels but rather between the middle wheels and whichever pair of outer wheels happens to be touching the ground. So by limiting rocking as much as possible performace greatly increases.

Tortional stiffness is absolutely critical to a good 6wd. In 2008 we discovered that without a very stiff chassis the opposite outer wheels will touch down essentially creating a long wheelbase while turning. This will also seriously limits turning.

Edit: I forgot to add, an 8wd has mathmatically much better turning characteristics than a 6wd provided the wheels are properly spaced.

But don't take my word for it, if you don't believe me run some experiments.
Regards, Bryan
__________________
robot robot robot? Robot. Robot? Robot!
-----------------Team 33------------------

Last edited by BJC : 04-02-2012 at 11:08 AM.
#12
04-02-2012, 11:28 AM
 Nathan Streeter FIRST Fan(atic) FRC #1519 (Mechanical MAYHEM) Team Role: Mentor Join Date: Feb 2008 Rookie Year: 2006 Location: Merrimack, NH Posts: 649
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

From watching a few of your matches on youtube, the symptoms (rocking "hops" when turning, with size of rock roughly proportional to speed of turn) seem very much like those of a drivetrain with too much resistance to turning, the result of having too much traction at the corners of a drivebase with a long wheelbase and narrow track.

Some ways to reduce this issue:
- Reduce traction at corners by:
* Making corner tires less grippy (slick wheels, or something less extreme)
* Making corner tires move sideways easily (90 degree omnis)
* Reducing weight on corners (increasing "rocker" and/or stiffening frame so that sag doesn't eliminate "rocker")
* Reducing weight on corner wheels by centering weight over center wheels
- Shorten wheelbase and/or widen track to get a footprint more advantageous for turning

I wouldn't recommend a rocker greater than 1/8"... If putting the center wheels 1/8" lower isn't sufficient, look at your frame sag. Then consider the lateral grippiness of your corner tires and where your CoG is.

Note that you don't want the robot to turn without any resistance, as it'd be nearly uncontrollable; however, you don't want so much resistance that you're hopping at even fairly low-speed turns... Some teams prefer just using omnis at the corners, while others prefer using rocker, or a more advantageous wheelbase/track ratio. Personally, I prefer a combination of the rocker, CoG, and wheelbase/track ratio to provide a drive base that goes straight naturally but still turns well and won't be spun around by a defender.
__________________
"If you want to build a ship, don't drum up men to gather wood, divide the work, or give orders. Instead, teach them to yearn for the vast and endless sea." - Antoine de Saint-Exupery
"The fight is won or lost far away from witnesses - behind the lines, in the gym, and out there on the road, long before I dance under those lights." - Muhammad Ali
"Simplicity is the ultimate sophistication." - Leonardo da Vinci

Student: 2006-2010 (#1519)
Mentor: 2011-Present (#1519)

#13
04-02-2012, 11:28 AM
 Brandon Holley Chase perfection. Catch excellence. AKA: Let's bring CD back to the way it used to be FRC #0125 (NU-TRONs, Team #11 Alumni (GO MORT)) Team Role: Engineer Join Date: Jan 2004 Rookie Year: 2001 Location: Boston, MA Posts: 2,550
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Building on what Bryan said...

CoG is a very overlooked thing in 6WD/8WD design. Its important to really consider where the approximate CoG of your robot will be as its being designed. This becomes especially true as you begin to build taller structures on top of your drive system. Weight higher up will tend to amplify the issues you are seeing with turning performance.

-Brando
__________________
MORT (Team 11) '01-'05 :
-2005 New Jersey Regional Chairman's Award Winners
-2013 MORT Hall of Fame Inductee

NUTRONs (Team 125) '05-???
2007 Boston Regional Winners
2008 & 2009 Boston Regional Driving Tomorrow's Technology Award
2010 Boston Regional Creativity Award
2011 Bayou Regional Finalists, Innovation in Control Award, Boston Regional Finalists, Industrial Design Award
2012 New York City Regional Winners, Boston Regional Finalists, IRI Mentor of the Year
2013 Orlando Regional Finalists, Industrial Design Award, Boston Regional Winners, Pine Tree Regional Finalists
2014 Rhode Island District Winners, Excellence in Engineering Award, Northeastern University District Winners, Industrial Design Award, Pine Tree District Chairman's Award, Pine Tree District Winners
2015 South Florida Regional Chairman's Award, NU District Winners, NEDCMP Industrial Design Award, Hopper Division Finalists, Hopper/Newton Gracious Professionalism Award
#14
04-02-2012, 11:44 AM
 Jared Russell FRC Alumnus and Former Mentor FRC #0254 (The Cheesy Poofs), FRC #0341 (Miss Daisy) Team Role: Engineer Join Date: Nov 2002 Rookie Year: 2001 Location: San Francisco, CA Posts: 3,008
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Torsional stiffness and a low CoG are absolutely critical to smooth turning in a dropped-center, skid steer drivetrain.
#15
04-02-2012, 11:57 AM
 Ether systems engineer (retired) no team Join Date: Nov 2009 Rookie Year: 1969 Location: US Posts: 7,790
Re: Moment of inertia and turning performance

Quote:
 Originally Posted by Nathan Streeter Note that you don't want the robot to turn without any resistance, as it'd be nearly uncontrollable;
Segways turn without any* resistance.

A 6WD with omnis at all four corners is like a Segway with training wheels.

*well, for all practical purposes

 Thread Tools Display Modes Rate This Thread Linear Mode Rate This Thread: 5 : Excellent 4 : Good 3 : Average 2 : Bad 1 : Terrible

 Posting Rules You may not post new threads You may not post replies You may not post attachments You may not edit your posts vB code is On Smilies are On [IMG] code is On HTML code is Off
 Forum Jump User Control Panel Private Messages Subscriptions Who's Online Search Forums Forums Home Announcements     User Announcements FIRST     General Forum         FIRST E-Mail Blast Archive     Rumor Mill     Career     Robot Showcase Technical     Technical Discussion     Robotics Education and Curriculum     Motors     Electrical         CAN     Programming         NI LabVIEW         C/C++         Java         Python     Control System         FRC Control System         Sensors     Pneumatics     Kit & Additional Hardware     CAD         Inventor         SolidWorks         Pro ENGINEER / Creo     IT / Communications         3D Animation and Competition         Website Design/Showcase         Videography and Photography         Computer Graphics     National Instruments LabVIEW and Data Acquisition         LabView and Data Acquisition Competition     Awards         Chairman's Award     Rules/Strategy         Scouting         You Make The Call     Team Organization         Fundraising         Starting New Teams         Finding A Team         College Teams     Championship Event     Regional Competitions     District Events     Off-Season Events     Thanks and/or Congrats     FRC Game Design     OCCRA         OCCRA Q&A         OCCRA Programming Other     Unsung FIRST Heroes     Chit-Chat         Games/Trivia             Fantasy FIRST     Car Nack's Corner     College & University Education     Dean Kamen's Inventions     FIRST-related Organizations         Western Region Robotics Forum         Robot Chicks Union (RCU)         Southern California Regional Robotics Forum         FIRST Interactive Rural SupporT         FIRST Scouting Network         FloridaFIRST         FIRSTwiki         The Blue Alliance             Video Archives     FIRST Historians     FIRST In the News...     FIRST Lego League         Lego Mindstorm Discussion     FIRST Tech Challenge     VEX         VEX Robotics Competition         VEX IQ     Televised Robotics     Math and Science         NASA Discussion ChiefDelphi.com Website     CD Forum Support     Extra Discussion Old Forum Archives     1999     2000     2001

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:15 PM.

The Chief Delphi Forums are sponsored by Innovation First International, Inc.

 -- English (12 hour) -- English (24 hour) Contact Us - Chief Delphi - Rules - Archive - Top