Log in

View Full Version : The SAM Thread

tcjinaz
03-02-2014, 22:31
OK, I was excoriated for this suggestion in 2012, but was proven correct that it was possible and, apparently, reasonable. Can (and may) a robot interfere with a ball in flight by shooting a ball at it?

I'll give you the reality that there are only 10 seconds (generally) when more that two balls in play, so the strategic value of ack-ack is greatly reduced over Rebound Rumble. Is it worth interferrng?

Tim
Andrew Lawrence
03-02-2014, 22:57
Is it possible? Yes. Is it worth attempting? No.
cmrnpizzo14
04-02-2014, 08:42
Check with PFreivald and 1551, they might have an interesting take on this ;)
JamesCH95
04-02-2014, 09:42
Best-case its a net-sum-zero strategy, so if it fits into your game plan it might be useful.

I cannot figure out how it would be genuinely useful though.
Al Skierkiewicz
04-02-2014, 09:45
Dodgeball immediately jumped to mind.
Andrew Schreiber
04-02-2014, 10:24
Best-case its a net-sum-zero strategy, so if it fits into your game plan it might be useful.

I cannot figure out how it would be genuinely useful though.

Coming out ahead in auton and locking the score. Ranking suicide in quals but could be a useful strategy if you know you've got them in auton but they can cycle faster.
JamesCH95
04-02-2014, 10:29
Coming out ahead in auton and locking the score. Ranking suicide in quals but could be a useful strategy if you know you've got them in auton but they can cycle faster.

I suppose so. I guess I was assuming that if you were consistently winning auton (i.e. reliable high-goal shooting) that you would always wind up with better cycle scores.

Do you really think trying to hit a ball out of the air with another ball would be better than a 2 or 3 robot defensive blockade?
Andrew Schreiber
04-02-2014, 10:32
I suppose so. I guess I was assuming that if you were consistently winning auton (i.e. reliable high-goal shooting) that you would always wind up with better cycle scores.

Do you really think trying to hit a ball out of the air with another ball would be better than a 2 or 3 robot defensive blockade?

Not at all. Hitting a quickly moving target is NOT a trivial problem in the least.

You did ask for a case when it would make sense, not a case in which I would do it. :P
JamesCH95
04-02-2014, 10:46
Not at all. Hitting a quickly moving target is NOT a trivial problem in the least.

You did ask for a case when it would make sense, not a case in which I would do it. :P

Touche good sir!