Log in

View Full Version : Defense back in 2016?


ChuckDickerson
05-01-2016, 16:59
So do you think defense will be back this year or do you think the GDC set a precedent last year by removing active robot to robot defense?

notmattlythgoe
05-01-2016, 17:00
So do you think defense will be back this year or do you think the GDC set a precedent last year by removing active robot to robot defense?

Well, bumpers are back this year, so I'm assuming there will be at least some form of robot-robot interaction.

JoshWilson
05-01-2016, 17:07
I don't think they would call it Stronghold if there wasn't some form of defending, so I'm going to say most definitely yes.

Edxu
05-01-2016, 17:38
I don't think they would call it Stronghold if there wasn't some form of defending, so I'm going to say most definitely yes.

This.

Also, I feel like the general feedback for 2013/2014 competitions was much better than that of Recycle Rush, though it's true that for RR, teams could create much more ambitious and creative designs that weren't limited by durability.

2014's Robot-Robot Interaction rules were a bit harsh, and I can quote at least 3 people saying "Week 1 was demolition derby", but I think that if they took 2014's robot interaction rules and made them a bit more specific, defense could be great this year.

jamesmcip
05-01-2016, 17:54
I think that defense will be back for sure, especially as the game hint seemed to be strongly hinting of a CTF style game. I am somewhat inclined to believe (and hope!) that 2015 was more of an oddball year in terms of the lack of defense and alliance interaction. But hey, we will know in about 3 days, 16 hours, and 33 minutes!

GeeTwo
05-01-2016, 19:06
Bumpers. Yes.

Bob Potts
05-01-2016, 21:22
While I don't want to teach Battle bots, I DO love me some good defense!

YES YES YES... please

dudefise
05-01-2016, 21:32
Yeah. I don't think many particularly liked the whole no-defense thing, even among offensive teams.

Without defense, there isn't much way for upsets to occur except a mistake by the favorite. Matches become a foregone conclusion.

JoshWilson
05-01-2016, 22:06
Without defense, there isn't much way for upsets to occur except a mistake by the favorite. Matches become a foregone conclusion.
This is so true, and easily the best reason for defense to be reimplemented, aside from making gameplay more exciting.

Christopher149
05-01-2016, 23:09
though it's true that for RR

I know what you mean, but RR could stand for Recycle Rush, Rebound Rumble, or even Rug Rage.

Monochron
06-01-2016, 00:07
Well, bumpers are back this year, so I'm assuming there will be at least some form of robot-robot interaction.

</thread>

Robosparks2926
07-01-2016, 18:59
I think that defense will be back for sure, especially as the game hint seemed to be strongly hinting of a CTF style game. I am somewhat inclined to believe (and hope!) that 2015 was more of an oddball year in terms of the lack of defense and alliance interaction. But hey, we will know in about 3 days, 16 hours, and 33 minutes!
possible

Edxu
07-01-2016, 19:26
I know what you mean, but RR could stand for Recycle Rush, Rebound Rumble, or even Rug Rage.

I guess so.

Maybe one day it'll be Rest Relaxation...

InspectorGadget1073
07-01-2016, 19:36
I guess so.

Maybe one day it'll be Rest Relaxation...

Never. Never in FRC history has this been considered.

GeeTwo
07-01-2016, 22:39
I guess so.

Maybe one day it'll be Rest Relaxation...

I'd sooner expect:

Railroad Rampage
Railgun Revenge
Ricochet Robot
Reciprocating Rhinoceroses
Rolling Rubble
Rhombus Ramble
Rambunctious Rockets, or even
River Rapids

before Rest Relaxation.

dirtbikerxz
07-01-2016, 22:48
I'd sooner expect:

Railroad Rampage
Railgun Revenge
Ricochet Robot
Reciprocating Rhinoceroses
Rolling Rubble
Rhombus Ramble
Rambunctious Rockets, or even
River Rapids

before Rest Relaxation.

Yesss, railgun rampage.

the illuminate
09-01-2016, 10:21
The main idea being tossed around is capture the flag and that is bound to have some robot interaction. :yikes: ::ouch:: ::rtm:: :] :cool: It is also believed that there will be a period where the lights will go out and the robots will drive in the dark. Whether it is in autonomous or manual is to be seen.[URL="https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FVLdJdoKK2E"]