Any rules about mentoring two teams? [Archive]

Vince lau

16-09-2005, 12:24

Are there any rules about mentoring two teams? *Note: both teams will not be in the same competition*

Team A will be doing VEX
Team B will be doing FRC

Team A will only need you once or twice a week and for the rest of the week you will help team B

Both teams know that your helping another team.

KathieK

16-09-2005, 12:35

I don't believe that is a problem (as long as you have time) because many mentors are working with an FRC team and an FLL team (or many FLL teams!)... However the mentor and students of the Vex team must be "new to FIRST"...

sburro

16-09-2005, 13:03

Are there any rules about mentoring two teams? *Note: both teams will not be in the same competition*

Team A will be doing VEX
Team B will be doing FRC

Team A will only need you once or twice a week and for the rest of the week you will help team B

Both teams know that your helping another team.

I do not believe there is any rule. In fact I actually believe it is encouraged.

Al Skierkiewicz

16-09-2005, 13:14

I work with multiple teams all the time. We mentor at least one rookie each year and I will help with any team that asks at any competition. Of course there is no rule, at least I don't think there is. Otherwise I'm in BIG trouble.

Rich Kressly

16-09-2005, 13:43

The "new to FIRST" rule is in place to encourage new participation in FIRST, however there are no FVC "mentor police". If you are doing a good thing for kids who weren't in FIRST before, then go do it! See if you can't drag a new inspiring adult into the mix too!!

-Good luck.

Barry Bonzack

16-09-2005, 13:46

I am an alumni of both FRC teams 1390 and 1604. I am now in college and helping mentor both teams. If helping high school students in my spare time is wrong, then I don't want to be right. :]

Matt Leese

17-09-2005, 01:58

Speaking as someone who mentored two teams last year (and I mentored both teams "full time"), I wouldn't recommend doing it. It takes a lot of time and a lot of work. I ended up lucky in the fact that only one of the teams had a large crunch time before the ship date (oddly enough, it was the non-rookie team that did). It also helped me personally that I had two different roles on the different teams (on the rookie team, more general engineering; on the non-rookie team, programming).

All in all, it's not something I'm likely to do again.

Matt

dk5sm5luigi

17-09-2005, 11:10

Are there any rules about mentoring two teams? *Note: both teams will not be in the same competition*

Team A will be doing VEX
Team B will be doing FRC

Team A will only need you once or twice a week and for the rest of the week you will help team B

Both teams know that your helping another team.

There are no rules about mentoring more than one team. However there is a rule in Vex (found at http://www.usfirst.org/vex/VexQA.htm)

Members of FVC teams registered for an FVC Pilot Program event are expected to be high-school-aged young people and adult mentors who are new to FIRST.
I am not sure how this affects you but it is an interesting rule FIRST has made.

dlavery

17-09-2005, 11:40

Members of FVC teams registered for an FVC Pilot Program event are expected to be high-school-aged young people and adult mentors who are new to FIRST.

Note that they say "expected," not "required."