Log in

View Full Version : timing of re-contact


Gary Dillard
11-01-2008, 09:56
If my robot vaults over the overpass while possessing the ball and I never lose contact with it, when do I need to re-contact it? Do I have to let go before I hit the ground, let it bounce and pick it back up, or can I land and then drop it and re-contact it?

GaryVoshol
11-01-2008, 10:02
You're vaulting the robot over the overpass? I'd like to see that! No, on second thought, I wouldn't want to. I'd need more than eye protection to protect from all the flying shrapnel.

Matt C
11-01-2008, 10:23
I think if you could jump over the overpass reliably and consistantly, they would give you double points just for the heck of it.

But I too would be doing a "duck and cover" move to avoid the flying parts.

Elgin Clock
11-01-2008, 10:31
If my robot vaults over the overpass...

You're vaulting the robot over the overpass? I'd like to see that!


As would I!

Gary, if your team does end up doing this, expect me to at least visit you during The Champs. @ Atlanta, or make my way to the FL regional somehow! :D

Keep us posted!

ALIBI
11-01-2008, 10:43
Wouldn't it be kind of hard to keep your standard bumpers within the bumper zone? I would love to see you do it! I suppose some type of climbing robot could do it as long as you didn't grab the overpass and just layed across it.

EDIT: To answer your question, probably doing it after you land as long as it is before the trackball goes over the opposing alliances finish line. Could maybe be the same action since you can not possess the trackball when you do that either.

Jon Stratis
11-01-2008, 10:44
I think the generally accepted interpretation of the rules for hurdling would tell you to release the ball while still in the air, and make sure it hits the ground before you re-contact it. The only possible point of dispute with that might be the rule about remaining in contact with the ball while crossing the finish line gives you no points, so you might have to release it before you cross the line...

GaryVoshol
11-01-2008, 12:29
the rule about remaining in contact with the ball while crossing the finish line gives you no points, so you might have to release it before you cross the line...That rule doesn't apply to hurdling - see Update 1

ALIBI
11-01-2008, 13:16
If you are concerned about giving up possession of the TrackBall, why not have your robot pass the TB over the overpass and pull it back? From the Q and A:

"A robot may break all contact with the Trackball as it passes over the Overpass. Likewise, a robot may be in contact with the Trackball when it passes over the Overpass. Either would be considered a valid Hurdle."

I can think of four or five ways to do this (or something similar). Of course, since the kids have only decided on their drivetrain at this point, I must keep those ideas to myself for now.

EricH
11-01-2008, 14:10
If my robot vaults over the overpass while possessing the ball and I never lose contact with it, when do I need to re-contact it? Do I have to let go before I hit the ground, let it bounce and pick it back up, or can I land and then drop it and re-contact it?
If you vault over with the robot, I'm calling <S01>!

Elgin Clock
11-01-2008, 14:14
If you vault over with the robot, I'm calling <S01>!

Party pooper. :(
Remind me not to go to an event you Ref. :p ;) :rolleyes:

EricH
11-01-2008, 14:25
Party pooper. :(
Remind me not to go to an event you Ref. :p ;) :rolleyes:
You're safe for this year at least. The last event I reffed was FVC L.A. 2006.

artdutra04
11-01-2008, 14:28
I can easily think ways of hurdling the trackball - without losing contact with it - that don't involve hurdling the entire robot. (In fact, it was one of the ideas I had right after the kickoff... :p)

IbleedPink233
13-01-2008, 13:25
Hurdling without losing contact of the ball would probably be slower (a more precise operation almost inherently) and in a game like this, slower is probably worse. Not to mention it violates the rules. Our team has discussed this and we have come to the conclusion that the intent of the rule is to give your allies (and opponents) a chance to get the Trackball and play the game. After all, no one likes a ball-hog.

Gary Dillard
13-01-2008, 15:53
Drat. I was hoping the Pink team would be one of the teams willing to catch us on the way down. My original plan was to collaborate with SPAM and Swampthing and have them modify their ramps from last year for takeoff and landing, but I'm open to other opportunities.

IbleedPink233
13-01-2008, 16:15
Drat. I was hoping the Pink team would be one of the teams willing to catch us on the way down. My original plan was to collaborate with SPAM and Swampthing and have them modify their ramps from last year for takeoff and landing, but I'm open to other opportunities.
Pink loves the ramps of SPAM and Swamp Thing, too (Florida regional and Nationals - good times). Now that I think about it, it would definitely be pretty epic to make them into a extreme course for us to drive around the track on. I'll have to convince my team members - we were looking forward to not needing any ground clearance. . .
I don't know how keen that my team would be on being the bot that breaks the fall of another. Maybe I'll bring it up at our top secret design/prototyping meeting tomorrow.

cobrawanabe1699
13-01-2008, 16:30
Get the fire extiguishers ready!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
:O :O : :O :O
Sounds like a real barn-burner o a plan you got there... GOOD LUCK

PC-Dad
19-01-2008, 14:09
You should see the prototyping Gary has been doing with those jet pack things you see guys flying around stadiums during halftime. We're still working on the weight aspect, though... :yikes: