Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   2012 Bill of Materials (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=100650)

Dancin103 19-01-2012 18:21

2012 Bill of Materials
 
We are having a bit of trouble finding the guidelines and template for this years bill of materials. If someone could point us in the right direction that would be great. Thanks and happy building! :)

Cassie

Joe Ross 19-01-2012 18:45

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
I have not seen the BOM template, yet. However, per <T09>, you are not required to turn in the BOM (only show), and are only recommended to use the template.

Dancin103 20-01-2012 08:24

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Thanks Joe!

Cass

Jared Russell 20-01-2012 08:28

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Does this mean we can go back to doing our BOM on a napkin at the last minute?

/sarcasm

rsisk 20-01-2012 09:01

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jared341 (Post 1109648)
Does this mean we can go back to doing our BOM on a napkin at the last minute?

No, please don't :eek:

This coming from a guy who sits at the inspector's table and has to look at those BOMs.

I sure hope the standard BOM template makes a return.

Joe Ross 20-01-2012 09:11

Quote:

Originally Posted by rsisk (Post 1109662)

This coming from a guy who sits at the inspector's table and has to look at those BOMs.


Given that the BOMs aren't turned in this year, I the the guy who sits at the inspectors table and collects BOMs is out of a job.

RoboMom 20-01-2012 12:10

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Ross (Post 1109669)
Given that the BOMs aren't turned in this year, I the the guy who sits at the inspectors table and collects BOMs is out of a job.

I'm pretty sure the guy (or gal) who sits at the inspectors table and has in the past collected the BOM's, will still be pretty busy. ;)

Al Skierkiewicz 20-01-2012 14:27

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jared341 (Post 1109648)
Does this mean we can go back to doing our BOM on a napkin at the last minute?

/sarcasm

Jared,
What do you think my answer to that might be, hmmm?

I will check into the link for the BOM but the template has not changed for many years. Be sure to account for everything and you may have a printed copy or a readable copy on a laptop for your inspector during inspection.

rsisk 20-01-2012 15:34

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Joe and Jenny,

I'm not worried about being kept busy and out of trouble at a regional :D

I thought that FIRST mined those BOMs for statistics on what is used, which is why they collected them.

RoboMom 20-01-2012 15:39

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rsisk (Post 1109850)

I thought that FIRST mined those BOMs for statistics on what is used, which is why they collected them.

I'm also guessing that they mined a lot of viruses.

Duke461 06-02-2012 16:08

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Bringing this thread back so that i don't have to start a new one....
Anyone found the 2012 BOM Template yet?
Thanks,
-Duke

mbram 06-02-2012 19:08

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
The template isn't out yet, however does anybody know what time it's supposed to come out?

Al Skierkiewicz 07-02-2012 07:34

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Please be patient. The BOM will be available momentarily.

Tuba4 07-02-2012 10:55

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Ross (Post 1109247)
I have not seen the BOM template, yet. However, per <T09>, you are not required to turn in the BOM (only show), and are only recommended to use the template.

That is an interesting twist. Last year we had to provide it on a flash drive didn't we?

Mark McLeod 07-02-2012 11:07

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tuba4 (Post 1121642)
That is an interesting twist. Last year we had to provide it on a flash drive didn't we?

Yea, and thumb drive viruses spread like wildfire through events.

Dumper FTW 435 09-02-2012 07:59

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
It's released. Look at section 5 under game manual:

http://www.usfirst.org/roboticsprogr...ated-documents

Duke461 09-02-2012 15:00

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Ok, so is anyone else having problems acquiring the file? I download the .zip file, but there isn't any excel file to be found. If someone has been able to get a hold of it, could they please post below with it as an attachment?
Thanks,
-Duke

Al Skierkiewicz 09-02-2012 15:08

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Duke,
The file in the link above is an .xlsx file, not a zip file. If you have a previous version of Microsoft Office, you need to have an update that can convert the file to your version of Office. If you haven't kept up with the revisions to Office then let me know. I will see if I can get a backwards compatible version posted.

Cal578 09-02-2012 16:05

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duke461 (Post 1123157)
I download the .zip file, but there isn't any excel file to be found.

Maybe you accidentally clicked the link "Robot Quick Build Information" instead of the correct one, "Inspection Bill-of-Materials (BOM) Template". When I clicked on the BOM link, I got the .xlsx file as expected.

They've simplified it this year. Now there's only one tab (not counting the readme tab), as opposed to last year's separate tabs for KOP and Non-KOP. Does that mean they only want to see non-KOP items listed? Or should we include KOP items also, with a price of $0?

Cal578 09-02-2012 16:23

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
I'm going to partly answer my own question.:cool: The "Read Me" tab of the template says:
Quote:

All parts required by The Robot Section 4 should be entered into the BOM. ... Any item that was included in the Rookie KOP but not the Veteran KOP should be considered a KOP item and indicated on the BOM.
It looks to me like we should include all parts, and KOP items get a price of $0. Does anyone interpret that differently?

Duke461 09-02-2012 17:11

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
I figured it out. The link downloads as 2012_Inspection_BOM_Template.xlsx.zip
I simply told it to open with microsoft excel instead of trying to unzip and extract, and it worked. Thanks for the input though, guys.

wilsonmw04 10-02-2012 13:37

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duke461 (Post 1123253)
I figured it out. The link downloads as 2012_Inspection_BOM_Template.xlsx.zip
I simply told it to open with microsoft excel instead of trying to unzip and extract, and it worked. Thanks for the input though, guys.


Confirmed:

it Downloads as "2012_Inspection_BOM_Template.zip"

I had to rename the file and change the extention to .xlsx and it works perfectly.

cgmv123 10-02-2012 18:58

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
xlsx (and docx and pptx) files are contained in a zip file. If you change the extension of those files to zip, you can see all the underlying XML that stores your documents, spreadsheets and presentations.

Jim Wilks 20-02-2012 18:11

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cal578 (Post 1123220)
It looks to me like we should include all parts, and KOP items get a price of $0. Does anyone interpret that differently?

Is this the consensus?

rsegrest 20-02-2012 18:27

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Yes, KOP parts (why does that sound redundant :D )list at $0.00. That's how it worked last year.

Jim Wilks 20-02-2012 19:15

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rsegrest (Post 1131146)
Yes, KOP parts (why does that sound redundant :D )list at $0.00. That's how it worked last year.

The reason I question this is that the template has as it's main heading "Non-Kit of Parts Inspection Bill of Materials"

Al Skierkiewicz 21-02-2012 07:32

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Jim,
The title is a holdover from last year which had a sheet for KOP already filled out for you. This year there is so many parts available through KOP, First Choice, ARA, voucher and rookie KOP is was very difficult to get everything listed for you. If it makes it easier, simply copy the sheet and enter a KOP sheet with $0.00 entries. The Robot rules Sec. 4.1.3 tells all for this item. Your list also assists inspectors when looking for parts on your robot. This year you can also simply have a laptop (preferred) or your Classmate showing the BOM or you can have it printed out as in the past. We will not be collecting the data this year but you will need to display the BOM at all events.

wilsonmw04 21-02-2012 13:36

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
So are KOP items required on the BOM?

How do we deal with parts from pervious KOP's like the Banner Photoeyes from last year?

Al Skierkiewicz 21-02-2012 13:48

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
[R13]
The total cost of all non-KOP items shall not exceed $3,500.00 USD. All costs are to be determined as explained in
Section 4.1.3: Budget Constraints.
The following items are excluded from the total cost calculation:
A. items listed on any KOP Checklist (qty is limited to the total listed in the most recent checklist),
B. items obtained via a Product Donation Voucher included in the KOP,
C. items ever distributed to the team via FIRST Choice,
D. any non-functional decorations,
E. individual fasteners, adhesives, or lubricants that are less than $1.00 each,
F. spare parts, and
G. parts of the Operator Console.

Steven Donow 21-02-2012 13:50

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Skierkiewicz (Post 1131754)
[R13]
The total cost of all non-KOP items shall not exceed $3,500.00 USD. All costs are to be determined as explained in
Section 4.1.3: Budget Constraints.
The following items are excluded from the total cost calculation:
A. items listed on any KOP Checklist (qty is limited to the total listed in the most recent checklist),
B. items obtained via a Product Donation Voucher included in the KOP,
C. items ever distributed to the team via FIRST Choice,
D. any non-functional decorations,
E. individual fasteners, adhesives, or lubricants that are less than $1.00 each,
F. spare parts, and
G. parts of the Operator Console.

The question with that is, is it the most recent checklist, ie. this years, or the most recent with THAT item? And for Banebots, would we deduct the motors that were given last year or the 30 dollars given this year?

Alex.q 25-02-2012 10:29

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Skierkiewicz (Post 1131754)
[R13]
The total cost of all non-KOP items shall not exceed $3,500.00 USD. All costs are to be determined as explained in
Section 4.1.3: Budget Constraints.
The following items are excluded from the total cost calculation:
A. items listed on any KOP Checklist (qty is limited to the total listed in the most recent checklist),
B. items obtained via a Product Donation Voucher included in the KOP,
C. items ever distributed to the team via FIRST Choice,
D. any non-functional decorations,
E. individual fasteners, adhesives, or lubricants that are less than $1.00 each,
F. spare parts, and
G. parts of the Operator Console.

I am confused about the part I underlined. Specifically, I am trying to account for some Igus parts, and I can't even find a list of what was included other than "Igus Bag" with "various" parts, and this is not very helpful. I think, but am not sure, that we used more bearings than were in the KOP this year, but 1. I can't find a list so I don't know; 2. If they do include different year's KOP parts, how do I account for them (2 entries, one with the recent KOP quantity and the rest at some Price?); 3. Some of the parts on Igus, such as the rods, do not have a price on the website and you have to ask for a quote. Does it have to be this difficult?

Also, with different models of FP motors, if the one model was in one years KOP, and a different model was in a different KOP, do I account for the price of both, one, or neither?:confused:

Al Skierkiewicz 26-02-2012 14:28

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Alex,
I read it as any KOP item is excluded from cost calculations. If you used Igus parts that were not part of a KOP then those need to be priced and added to the calculation. If you do not have a KOP checklist for a particular year, let me know, I might have it in my archive or you might find it on the FIRST archive or another website that has been archiving things for FRC.

sanddrag 26-02-2012 15:40

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Forgive me if this has already come up, but are we required to use the FIRST-provided format, or can we make our own spreadsheet from scratch provided it has all the same information, in a slightly different layout?

Al Skierkiewicz 27-02-2012 07:58

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Sandy,
Teams are encouraged to use the BOM Template posted on the FIRST website. Please
note that while BOMs must be shown to Inspectors, FRC teams are not required to
submit their BOMs to the Inspectors.

You may use your own design but it may add time to your inspection process as the inspector looks over a spreadsheet unknown to them.

akoscielski3 27-02-2012 20:45

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
I just finished my teams BOM and found the total cost to be rather high (compared to last year). It is pretty darn close to the limit. Is anybody else finding this out?

theNerd 28-02-2012 15:44

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
My Team got a bit behind and we are just now doing our BOM(by the way yes our bot is already bagged and tagged so this is going to be quite a task). Last year FRC provided a template that included a listing of all the KOP items on one shee and another for non-KOP items. Is there a format like that for this year?, or is there only a base template and I'll have to include the KOP items we used by hand.
Thanks.

Siri 28-02-2012 18:46

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by theNerd (Post 1136245)
My Team got a bit behind and we are just now doing our BOM(by the way yes our bot is already bagged and tagged so this is going to be quite a task). Last year FRC provided a template that included a listing of all the KOP items on one shee and another for non-KOP items. Is there a format like that for this year?, or is there only a base template and I'll have to include the KOP items we used by hand.
Thanks.

Due I think to the shear number of "KOP" items this year (larger FIRST choice, more vouchers like ARA), the GDC has returned to the older base template. You'll just list all components and write the source as "KOP" and cost as $0 for all items counted in the Kit. The template is here (direct download) on the competition manual page. Good luck! I wrapped up at almost row 300 if I recall correctly. Remember the rules about what's in the KOP and the other exemptions from the total cost calculation.

caffel 08-03-2012 11:25

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
;) As far as my brand new copy goes, the zip file on the USFIRST website does not contain any .xls files at all.
C:\Documents and Settings\Stereo Optical\My Documents\2012 game\2012_Inspection_BOM_Template_Rev_A.
Myabe there is some sense to the folders with xml files, but they don't seem to work together on my EXCEL 2010 nor open office.

I wonder what they were thinking ?

Was it the same user experience experts who posted vital contest info for High School users on YouTube ?

RufflesRidge 08-03-2012 11:34

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by caffel (Post 1141021)
;) As far as my brand new copy goes, the zip file on the USFIRST website does not contain any .xls files at all.
C:\Documents and Settings\Stereo Optical\My Documents\2012 game\2012_Inspection_BOM_Template_Rev_A.
Myabe there is some sense to the folders with xml files, but they don't seem to work together on my EXCEL 2010 nor open office.

I wonder what they were thinking ?

Was it the same user experience experts who posted vital contest info for High School users on YouTube ?

The posted file is a .xlsx file not a .zip file (though the new office formats ending in 'x' are technically zip files).

See here:
http://forums.usfirst.org/showthread...ight=materials

MrForbes 08-03-2012 11:49

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by caffel (Post 1141021)
;) As far as my brand new copy goes, the zip file on the USFIRST website does not contain any .xls files at all.

Where is the .zip file?

I just used the .xlsx file found in the link in the 5. Tournament section, near the bottom of this page.

http://www.usfirst.org/roboticsprogr...ated-documents


Although I don't quite understand why it's in .xlsx, and I saved it as a .xls file so we could work with it more easily (we're a bit behind in our spreadsheet software).

Nemo 08-03-2012 11:52

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
2 Attachment(s)
I find the official BOM template to be somewhat annoying to work with for two reasons: 1) The small, blank columns require me to hit a few extra arrow keys each time I enter a part, and they prevent me from effectively using shortcuts like shift-right, which adds up when I'm entering a hundred parts; 2) I always have to add more rows to some of the subsystems and then repair the formatting and subtotals afterwards.

So I used a very simple BOM format instead (blank example attached). It was faster and easier. I added a grand total at the bottom when I was finished.

Attachment 12254
Edit: Excel 2003 version:
Attachment 12255

wilsonmw04 08-03-2012 11:53

Re: 2012 Bill of Materials
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wilsonmw04 (Post 1123773)
Confirmed:

it Downloads as "2012_Inspection_BOM_Template.zip"

I had to rename the file and change the extention to .xlsx and it works perfectly.

Please see above :)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:59.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi