Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Technical Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   Colson 101 (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=105101)

sdcantrell56 27-03-2012 13:04

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rich Kressly (Post 1150115)
Agreed on the cost if you're into those manufacturing techniques.

Absolutely. It's all about trade-offs. Their is very little in the world I hate as much as dealing with keys though so its a no brainer for us. Back when we ran colsons in 07 we went with the NPC ones though and they held up great.

JackS 27-03-2012 15:03

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 1150097)
I've heard rumors and claims over the year over the actual numbers and how high they are (for traction), but have yet to see anyone do real testing and post.

Anyone done it?

Art Dutra's results here.

JVN's data here.

This is our first year with colsons. We have 6x1.5" wheels and the robot is much harder to push laterally vs our 4x1" roughtop wheels from last year. We made simple press in plugs and didn't even knurl them.

JesseK 27-03-2012 15:48

Re: Colson 101
 
How would one go about cutting the diamond pattern in the tread like what Art posted?

Conceptually, I can think of a way to draw the pattern on the wheel and then use a mill -- but is there a more efficient way to do it?

Andrew Lawrence 27-03-2012 15:51

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JesseK (Post 1150215)
How would one go about cutting the diamond pattern in the tread like what Art posted?

Conceptually, I can think of a way to draw the pattern on the wheel and then use a mill -- but is there a more efficient way to do it?

Also, how deep should the pattern be?

Jared Russell 27-03-2012 15:59

Re: Colson 101
 
I would think a jig and a saw would do the trick.

JesseK 27-03-2012 16:20

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jared341 (Post 1150219)
I would think a jig and a saw would do the trick.

Ah, I can see how to do it very easily with a table saw. Good catch.

Siri 28-03-2012 19:46

Re: Colson 101
 
Where do you guys buy your Colsons? (Online shippers or storefront in the Philadelphia, PA area) The only distributor the Colson website identified in our area was a wholesaler and uninterested in selling us 4.

I've checked like Robotmarketplace and McMaster, but we're looking for Ecoformas not Performas; specifically 4"x1.25" Encore Ecoforma Flat Grey Tread - less bearing (E2.00004.476).

Brandon Holley 28-03-2012 20:36

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Siri (Post 1150887)
Where do you guys buy your Colsons? (Online shippers or storefront in the Philadelphia, PA area) The only distributor the Colson website identified in our area was a wholesaler and uninterested in selling us 4.

I've checked like Robotmarketplace and McMaster, but we're looking for Ecoformas not Performas; specifically 4"x1.25" Encore Ecoforma Flat Grey Tread - less bearing (E2.00004.476).

This is information I got directly from calling Colson earlier this season:

The Ecoforma and Performa lines of wheels are the same thing. The Performas are marketed in NAFTA while the Ecoformas are for other regions.

The reason I wanted the Ecoformas specifically is probably the same as you, weight. When speaking to this customer service agent she told me they are the same wheel, and the information on the website regarding the weight of the Ecoformas may be incorrect.

-Brando

AlexH 28-03-2012 20:36

Re: Colson 101
 
any reason for not going with performas? occasionally colsons pop up on https://www.surpluscenter.com/

grainger sells off brand colsons (albion brand). the durometer is the same as a colson performa.

most of the time I buy my colsons from robot marketplace, but i've bought some off surplus center too.

edit: you could also look into using two of the orange banebots wheels on the same axle. it's a 40a durometer wheel so it should get more grip than a 65a durometer colson. i wouldn't recommend the 30a green banebots wheels, they wear down like crazy. also don't worry about the hole on the banebots wheels not being centered. it wears down to a usable "roundness" after some use...

R.C. 28-03-2012 21:14

Re: Colson 101
 
Robot Marketplace sells them:

http://www.robotmarketplace.com/prod...on_wheels.html

WCP is going to have 1/2" Hex Plugs for these in the next month or two. Along with a keyed version of the plug for robot marketplace/their battle bots line.

-RC

AdamHeard 29-03-2012 00:58

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JackS (Post 1150182)
Art Dutra's results here.

JVN's data here.

This is our first year with colsons. We have 6x1.5" wheels and the robot is much harder to push laterally vs our 4x1" roughtop wheels from last year. We made simple press in plugs and didn't even knurl them.

Neither of these are really useful information. To make a comparison one must perform the same test on colson wheels, traction wheels, and other other wheels one wishes to compare.

Merely throwing out CoF isn't enough.

sanddrag 29-03-2012 02:02

Re: Colson 101
 
Linco Caster in South El Monte, California has them and has been pleasant to deal with in the past.

waialua359 29-03-2012 03:11

Re: Colson 101
 
After reading this entire thread, I am now convinced that we will in all probability, use Colsons next year.

sdcantrell56 29-03-2012 09:10

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by waialua359 (Post 1151046)
After reading this entire thread, I am now convinced that we will in all probability, use Colsons next year.

Glenn,

Feel free to stop by and check them out on our robot at Lonestar.

Siri 29-03-2012 10:49

Re: Colson 101
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brandon Holley (Post 1150897)
This is information I got directly from calling Colson earlier this season:

The Ecoforma and Performa lines of wheels are the same thing. The Performas are marketed in NAFTA while the Ecoformas are for other regions.

The reason I wanted the Ecoformas specifically is probably the same as you, weight. When speaking to this customer service agent she told me they are the same wheel, and the information on the website regarding the weight of the Ecoformas may be incorrect.

-Brando

Wow, thanks. We were looking for the weight. I think the Ecoforma weight may be correct though, because Robotmarketplace Performas are 4oz/ea. I think we're getting one to play around with; we'll see.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:40.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi