Chief Delphi - Most Chairman's wins

Page 3 of 4

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)

- General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)

- - Most Chairman's wins (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=105153)

Renee Becker-Blau

01-04-2012 20:35

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Fultz (Post 1151062)

One of our students put together this file for 2012 RCA's, through week 4.

We will update it next week and then again after week 6.

It has tabs for Regional, FiM and MAR events.

Please list any corrections and we will keep the file accurate.

This is a fantastic file, will it be posted in this thread with the updates or in another location?

Renee

Chris Fultz

01-04-2012 20:38

Re: Most Chairman's wins

1 Attachment(s)

Here is the week 5 update including the events that ended 4-1.

Please advise of any errors or omissions.

Jacob Paikoff

01-04-2012 22:40

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Fultz (Post 1152555)

Here is the week 5 update including the events that ended 4-1.

Please advise of any errors or omissions.

Chris, great file, thanks for doing this.

I found one error: You forgot 2004 Colorado Chairman's for 79

Chris Fultz

02-04-2012 07:05

Re: Most Chairman's wins

we will make that change.

Chris Fultz

03-04-2012 10:13

Re: Most Chairman's wins

1 Attachment(s)

Updated with the Team 79 listing corrected.

Libby K

03-04-2012 10:33

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by waialua359 (Post 1150590)

Personally, I think it should stay at 1 at CMP.
However, I have heard of talks that that may possibly change.

If a team is that great year in and year out, whether they get it this year, or the next, or the next.....they eventually will.

There is about 2 or 3 teams at most, that have a realistic shot at it.............and they know who they are!:)

More that one Championship Chairman's? I don't know where you heard that, but I very highly doubt that would happen. The point of CCA is that you are the best. Not the 'eh, somewhere in this group right here.' You're the best, and you are that year's Hall of Fame inductee. I think it should stay that way.

Kpchem

03-04-2012 11:18

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by Libby K (Post 1153437)

More that one Championship Chairman's? I don't know where you heard that, but I very highly doubt that would happen...

FRC Game Manual Section 6.4.1

"Hall of Fame members; i.e., teams that have already earned the Chairman’s Award, are ineligible to resubmit for consideration for five (5) years. Teams that earned the Chairman’s Award at the Championship prior to 2007 are eligible to participate in 2011. Teams that earned the Chairman’s Award in 2007-2011 are ineligible."

My interpretation of this is that, because teams who won CCA prior to 2007 and eligible to submit for RCA this year, they would also be eligible for CCA again if they were selected for that honor.

Siri	03-04-2012 11:47

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kpchem (Post 1153456)

FRC Game Manual Section 6.4.1

"Hall of Fame members; i.e., teams that have already earned the Chairman’s Award, are ineligible to resubmit for consideration for five (5) years. Teams that earned the Chairman’s Award at the Championship prior to 2007 are eligible to participate in 2011. Teams that earned the Chairman’s Award in 2007-2011 are ineligible."

By interpretation of this is that, because teams who won CCA prior to 2007 and eligible to submit for RCA this year, they would also be eligible for CCA again if they were selected for that honor.

She means one winner selected per year. (right?) I have to agree. You are the one for that year. Though then again, that's probably not really congruous with reality. I guess it's possible.

EricH

03-04-2012 11:56

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by Siri (Post 1153466)

She means one winner selected per year. (right?) I have to agree. You are the one for that year. Though then again, that's probably not really congruous with reality. I guess it's possible.

Yep, that's what I read.

There IS one team that has two CCAs, back when that was the only one awarded. They're also a sustaining team: 191, the X-Cats.

Libby K

03-04-2012 12:46

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by Kpchem (Post 1153456)

FRC Game Manual Section 6.4.1

"Hall of Fame members; i.e., teams that have already earned the Chairman’s Award, are ineligible to resubmit for consideration for five (5) years. Teams that earned the Chairman’s Award at the Championship prior to 2007 are eligible to participate in 2011. Teams that earned the Chairman’s Award in 2007-2011 are ineligible."

By interpretation of this is that, because teams who won CCA prior to 2007 and eligible to submit for RCA this year, they would also be eligible for CCA again if they were selected for that honor.

I'm sorry - I was interpreting Glenn's comment as 'they would give out more than one Championship Chairman's Award per year , not that you can win CCA more than once...

Kpchem

03-04-2012 12:50

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Oh, okay. In that case yes, I would agree with you, only one team should win the CCA per year. Sorry for the confusion on that...

Chris Fultz

08-04-2012 22:21

Re: Most Chairman's wins

1 Attachment(s)

Here is the updated file after week 6 regionals.

We will do another update after the FiM and MAR Championships next weekend and merge all of the teams that will present at CHP.

tommy0019

09-04-2012 14:39

Re: Most Chairman's wins

I have a question? does anyone every get tried of seeing the same teams win the chairmans award over and over at the same regional? I have nothing against the teams that are receiving the awards, because they are GREAT teams and do even better jobs spreading FIRST. It just seems to me it discourages other teams from trying to standout. I know regionals have plenty of other good teams that never seem to get recognized.

Akash Rastogi

09-04-2012 14:40

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by tommy0019 (Post 1155909)

The Chairman's award is not about being "good enough", it is about being the best. Rewarding someone for being good enough is not the message we want to send our students. If a team is truly better than another, then it is the job of the team to convey that and prove to the judges that it is true.

jblay

09-04-2012 14:59

Re: Most Chairman's wins

Quote:

Originally Posted by tommy0019 (Post 1155909)

I get tired of the regionals that don't give the award to a team because they won the year before. That is really against the spirit of the award and it is frustrating to the students who work so hard to spread FIRST and do not get the recognition that they have earned. We used to submit at a regional like that but do not anymore for that very reason. The result has been 3 straight chairman's awards since we switched.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 22:43.

Page 3 of 4

Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page