Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Technical Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   WCD vs Standard (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=108076)

Adam Freeman 12-10-2012 11:49

Re: WCD vs Standard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pat Fairbank (Post 1190170)
I wouldn't say that weight is the top factor in 254's choice of using a cantilevered drive year after year. It probably only comes in fourth after ease of maintenance, robustness, and aesthetics (you wouldn't believe how many design decisions come down to aesthetics).


I can't say for sure, but my notes say that I weighed our competition chassis (0.06" sheet AL) at 8lbs, before we started assembling any of the components on to it.

Weight is a factor in our decision to use this type of drivetrain...but, it's probably #3 on the list. #1 would be resources available (in-shop waterjet) and ease of construction (no welding) and #2 would be robustness.

Our design is a nightmare for ease of maintenance. Changing wheels or drivetrain components is not something we could do easily/quickly.

Chris is me 12-10-2012 12:20

Re: WCD vs Standard
 
I think the main reason anyone does any type of drivetrain the way they do is because they have access to resources that make their design optimal. A sheet metal chassis can be done excellently. So can a welded tube chassis. Rather than sketch an exact copy of the best, drive design should play to the resources your team has. What use is a drive that's 5 pounds lighter of it takes you 2 weeks longer to build it?

We use a Poof inspired but *highly* derivative drivetrain that plays into our resources and goes together relatively quickly. It's light enough. It's definitely strong enough. Probably overbuilt. And it works because it uses what we have and what we were able to get in an offseason.

The way the Poofs do it, when you get down to the details of their bearing blocks, custom wheels, etc. takes a lot of resources that not a lot of teams have as readily available as 254 has worked hard to have. Play to your strengths.

Walter Deitzler 12-10-2012 16:10

Re: WCD vs Standard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris is me (Post 1190241)
I think the main reason anyone does any type of drivetrain the way they do is because they have access to resources that make their design optimal. A sheet metal chassis can be done excellently. So can a welded tube chassis. Rather than sketch an exact copy of the best, drive design should play to the resources your team has. What use is a drive that's 5 pounds lighter of it takes you 2 weeks longer to build it?

We use a Poof inspired but *highly* derivative drivetrain that plays into our resources and goes together relatively quickly. It's light enough. It's definitely strong enough. Probably overbuilt. And it works because it uses what we have and what we were able to get in an offseason.

The way the Poofs do it, when you get down to the details of their bearing blocks, custom wheels, etc. takes a lot of resources that not a lot of teams have as readily available as 254 has worked hard to have. Play to your strengths.

That makes sense, most of my parts will probably be bought from andymark. But I would still like to know how many teams mount these bearing blocks, and allow them to slide, then lock them into place when they are done with them. Thanks!

Cory 12-10-2012 18:09

Re: WCD vs Standard
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LedLover96 (Post 1190269)
That makes sense, most of my parts will probably be bought from andymark. But I would still like to know how many teams mount these bearing blocks, and allow them to slide, then lock them into place when they are done with them. Thanks!

Pat's post explains how we do it. The combination of his post, the picture of our frame rail he linked, and Gray Adam's cross section view of their 3d model should be a perfect explanation of how it works.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:35.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi