Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Kit & Additional Hardware (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=55)
-   -   FIRST Choice (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=109489)

Gregor 12-11-2012 13:39

FIRST Choice
 
FIRST Choice is now available at http://www.andymark.com/FIRST-Choice...show=80&page=1

Some things that stand out:
Talons: (Legal maybe?)
IR stuff: similar to 2008?
Eccentric Bearing: what could this be used for, other than some kind of game object?
I/O module:???
New window motors: what differences are there?
Snow blower motor: new

Phyrxes 12-11-2012 13:48

Re: FIRST Choice
 
2013 Manual not withstanding in the past FIRST choice has been synonymous with included in the KOP.

New motors, likely to be three motor controllers to pick from, and a whole slew of new toys.

Anybody else have an Overdrive flashback when they saw the remote?

ttldomination 12-11-2012 13:50

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Phyrxes (Post 1193745)
Anybody else have an Overdrive flashback when they saw the remote?

More like a nightmare, but yes.

- Sunny G.

MattC9 12-11-2012 13:57

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Ring light- retro reflective tape (?)
IR remote- some sort of IR receiver on robot (?)
Photo switch- lines on field to follow(?)

cRIO- YESSSSS
Classmate- YESSSS

There are defiantly a few items on there that are worth a game theory. Also I can not be more excited to see the cRIO and classmates on there for this year, well done FIRST choice, well done...

JohnChristensen 12-11-2012 13:58

Re: FIRST Choice
 
I am looking for the post, but I believe it was stated that anything on FIRST Choice will be 2013 FRC Legal. Looks like Talons are going to be allowed.

Rangel(kf7fdb) 12-11-2012 14:07

Re: FIRST Choice
 
The most interesting thing to me is the gaming graphics card. Could there be something in the game that requires a lot of graphics processing on the robot or are they just making it available to help teams who want to cad?

AdamHeard 12-11-2012 14:13

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Rangel(kf7fdb) (Post 1193751)
The most interesting thing to me is the gaming graphics card. Could there be something in the game that requires a lot of graphics processing on the robot or are they just making it available to help teams who want to cad?

Nvidia has been handing similar cards out at a few regionals over the years, I think this must just be an extension of that.

We have 2-3 gtx 480's from them.

Travis Hoffman 12-11-2012 14:15

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gregor (Post 1193742)
FIRST Choice is now available at http://www.andymark.com/FIRST-Choice...show=80&page=1

Talons: (Legal maybe?)

Talons ARE FIRST legal, per an email just received from AndyMark. $59 base price - quantity discounts available.

http://www.andymark.com/Talon-p/am-2195.htm

Tom Line 12-11-2012 14:16

Re: FIRST Choice
 
And I just went to look at them, and they're $59! Talk about competition being healthy.

ehochstein 12-11-2012 14:17

Re: FIRST Choice
 
IR transmitter
Infrared Thermometer
New motors?! =O
3D Print Job voucher? Awesome!
Laser distance meter for your robot? Are they changing the laser rules?
cRIO as a part of FIRST Choice?!?!

This is awesome!

AdamHeard 12-11-2012 14:17

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tom Line (Post 1193754)
And I just went to look at them, and they're $59! Talk about competition being healthy.

Or $54 if you buy 4 at a time.

Tom Line 12-11-2012 14:19

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Hmmmm. I wonder if there is an even bigger discount for 20 :D

Regarding the IR remote control - please please tell me that's not coming back...

CalTran 12-11-2012 14:20

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Travis Hoffman (Post 1193753)
Talons ARE FIRST legal, per an email just received from AndyMark. $59 base price - quantity discounts available.

http://www.andymark.com/Talon-p/am-2195.htm

And we just bought 12 of them. Sorry IFI, we were about to buy 10 but this was an offer we just couldn't refuse...

Taylor 12-11-2012 14:30

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Wiifi (Post 1193755)
Laser distance meter for your robot? Are they changing the laser rules?

I doubt circular saws are legal* for the robot, but they're on FIRST Choice.

*maybe if you filed down sharp parts to R0.125 ...

Nate Laverdure 12-11-2012 14:33

Re: FIRST Choice
 
I see a ratcheting subtheme. And braided steel cable. Winch game?

Gary Dillard 12-11-2012 14:40

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Travis Hoffman (Post 1193753)
Talons ARE FIRST legal, per an email just received from AndyMark. $59 base price - quantity discounts available.

http://www.andymark.com/Talon-p/am-2195.htm

Emails from AndyMark are considered an official communication from FIRST? Could you point me toward that ruling?

I would infer rather that they are legal because they are in FIRST Choice, not because of the AndyMark email.

maddoctor90 12-11-2012 14:44

Re: FIRST Choice
 
FIRST really needs to come out with an official statement on which motor controllers will be legal and soon!

vhcook 12-11-2012 14:45

Re: FIRST Choice
 
What are jaw couplings used for? (I've linked one of the many on the list.) I'm normally more electrical/programming than mechanical, and this is a new part for me.

maddoctor90 12-11-2012 14:48

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vhcook (Post 1193763)
What are jaw couplings used for? (I've linked one of the many on the list.) I'm normally more electrical/programming than mechanical, and this is a new part for me.

Two jaw couplings go together with a rubber piece in the middle to create on shaft coupler with some advantages over just a solid connection. Here is some information from the manufacturer of the ones we have used in the past.

http://www.lovejoy-inc.com/products/...couplings.aspx

Gary Dillard 12-11-2012 14:48

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by vhcook (Post 1193763)
What are jaw couplings used for? (I've linked one of the many on the list.) I'm normally more electrical/programming than mechanical, and this is a new part for me.

They're used to connect 2 coaxial shafts together (one driven, the other the driver). They generally isolate shock between the components and can handle some amount of mis-alignment between the axes.

jason701802 12-11-2012 14:55

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Considering this post on FRC blog (the last bullet point), I'd consider the Talon a legal controller for the 2013 season

MrBasse 12-11-2012 15:14

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Or you could look at the subject of the First Choice email sent out today...

FIRST Choice Viewing Now Open/Talons FIRST Legal

Mark McLeod 12-11-2012 15:21

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MrBasse (Post 1193769)
Or you could look at the subject of the First Choice email sent out today...

FIRST Choice Viewing Now Open/Talons FIRST Legal

Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary Dillard (Post 1193761)
Emails from AndyMark are considered an official communication from FIRST? Could you point me toward that ruling?

I would infer rather that they are legal because they are in FIRST Choice, not because of the AndyMark email.

Circular postings?

F22Rapture 12-11-2012 16:05

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 1193752)
Nvidia has been handing similar cards out at a few regionals over the years, I think this must just be an extension of that.

We have 2-3 gtx 480's from them.

And which regionals might that be? :D

jason701802 12-11-2012 16:20

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by F22Rapture (Post 1193784)
And which regionals might that be? :D

We got one at both Portland and Seattle a few years ago. As far as I know, they only did it that year.

Camren 12-11-2012 16:24

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nate Laverdure (Post 1193760)
I see a ratcheting subtheme. And braided steel cable. Winch game?

maybe that is what the new bearings our for. Idea what if you had to winch yourself off the ground for endgame.

dcarr 12-11-2012 16:27

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jason701802 (Post 1193785)
We got one at both Portland and Seattle a few years ago. As far as I know, they only did it that year.

We got a GTX 480 at LA in 2011.

DampRobot 12-11-2012 16:30

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Camren (Post 1193788)
maybe that is what the new bearings our for. Idea what if you had to winch yourself off the ground for endgame.

The bearings with the groove around the outside, which come in eccentric and concentric varieties, are for the linear rail also avalible in FIRST Choice. It's leads me to think elevator game, rather than winch game.

Then again, we saw the same linear slides in the 2012 FIRST Choice, so take these indicators with a grain of salt. Besides some interesting indicators (IR remote anyone?), I would be very reluctant to deduce anything from this list other than that the Talon will be legal next year.

Gary Dillard 12-11-2012 16:51

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by F22Rapture (Post 1193784)
And which regionals might that be? :D

Smoky Mountain in 2011

MARS_James 12-11-2012 16:55

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by F22Rapture (Post 1193784)
And which regionals might that be? :D

Orlando in 2010 and 2011

We got one both times

SarahBeth 12-11-2012 17:21

Re: FIRST Choice
 
The snow blower motor made me raise my eyebrow. So did the sonar sensor and the laser distance meter.

So we're either moving snow or playing Battleship.

Got it. :D ::rtm::

Gregor 12-11-2012 17:37

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by SarahBeth (Post 1193812)
The snow blower motor made me raise my eyebrow. So did the sonar sensor and the laser distance meter.

So we're either moving snow or playing Battleship.

Got it. :D ::rtm::

or both :rolleyes:

IndySam 12-11-2012 17:57

Re: FIRST Choice
 
The eccentric grooved wheels, regular grooved wheels and guide track were in last years First Choice. They are nothing new.

Lot of things are Granger just clearing out old stock like the crank ratchet and steel cable.

So don't read to much into anything in First Choice game wise.



Focus on the lots cool stuff like the new Clippard tanks, new style compressors, new couplers, and talons. Great work by the KOP team.

DampRobot 12-11-2012 18:14

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IndySam (Post 1193819)
Focus on the lots cool stuff like the new Clippard tanks, new style compressors, new couplers, and talons. Great work by the KOP team.

I thought the Clippard tank was back from last year, and that the compressor was the same that was legal starting in 2011. Did I miss something? Does the compressor have a larger cubic feet per minute rating?

IndySam 12-11-2012 18:20

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DampRobot (Post 1193820)
I thought the Clippard tank was back from last year, and that the compressor was the same that was legal starting in 2011. Did I miss something? Does the compressor have a larger cubic feet per minute rating?

The new plastic tank is what I was referring too and the compressor is the same as the last two years but was never available in First Choice.

FrankJ 12-11-2012 18:33

Re: FIRST Choice
 
circular saw? Battle bots? We don't need no stinking bumpers!!!

CalTran 12-11-2012 19:07

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by FrankJ (Post 1193823)
circular saw? Battle bots? We don't need no stinking bumpers!!!

http://www.usfirst.org/roboticsprogr.../blog-09-18-12
Quote:

Pool Noodles

Buy them, if you don’t have them already, for your 2013 bumpers.

Travis Hoffman 12-11-2012 19:21

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary Dillard (Post 1193761)
Emails from AndyMark are considered an official communication from FIRST? Could you point me toward that ruling?

I would infer rather that they are legal because they are in FIRST Choice, not because of the AndyMark email.

Andy Baker not wanting to cheese off a significant portion of his customer base by lying to us is good enough of a reason for me to believe him. :cool:

maddoctor90 12-11-2012 21:19

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Travis Hoffman (Post 1193833)
Andy Baker not wanting to cheese off a significant portion of his customer base by lying to us is good enough of a reason for me to believe him. :cool:

I would agree that there is plenty of evidence that the Talons will be legal. What I don't get is why FIRST won't be more direct on these things so all teams (especially rookie ones who who may not be aware of all the channels of communication) have an equal opportunity and understanding.

z_beeblebrox 12-11-2012 21:36

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Why are the graphics cards available?

Jibsy 12-11-2012 21:40

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by maddoctor90 (Post 1193762)
FIRST really needs to come out with an official statement on which motor controllers will be legal and soon!

"It’s safe to assume that if you see a robot component in FIRST Choice when it opens for “window shopping” on November 12th, it will be legal for teams to use in the 2013 season. Please don’t go all ‘lawyer’ on me with this one. Use good judgment. If you see a plasma cutter available in FIRST Choice, you should not think you’ll be able to put it on your robot. (Spoiler: There will be no plasma cutters available in FIRST Choice). "

http://www.usfirst.org/roboticsprogr.../blog-11-02-12

You can be sure that Talons, Jags, and Victors will all be legal!

MagiChau 12-11-2012 22:09

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by z_beeblebrox (Post 1193850)
Why are the graphics cards available?

Animation and CAD software are resource intensive especially with rendering the graphics. High performance cards run hundreds of dollars to buy brand new. I am guessing the value in credits from Andymark in actual money would cost less than buying it at retail price.

I assume NVIDIA decided to not only give gfx cards to help teams at regionals they show up at but to all teams through FIRST Choice. I don't know if they offered cards for a generous discounted price so take it as just a possible speculation.

Kevin Selavko 13-11-2012 03:35

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MagiChau (Post 1193856)
Animation and CAD software are resource intensive especially with rendering the graphics. High performance cards run hundreds of dollars to buy brand new. I am guessing the value in credits from Andymark in actual money would cost less than buying it at retail price.

I assume NVIDIA decided to not only give gfx cards to help teams at regionals they show up at but to all teams through FIRST Choice. I don't know if they offered cards for a generous discounted price so take it as just a possible speculation.

Not discounted, free! They donated them, I assume that is so if you like the card you may buy one for yourself, but ours is still nicely wrapped up because we haven't had the time to build a compatible computer :p (In close to two years!)

David Doerr 13-11-2012 11:15

Re: FIRST Choice
 
I wonder if the items that can now be seen on FIRST Choice will not be in the KOP - joysticks, classmate, camera, batteries, window motors, pneumatics components ... ?

I was not on a team last year and I didn't see the 2012 FIRST Choice. How did it work last year?

Jon Stratis 13-11-2012 11:51

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Some items might be included in the KoP, others might not. For example, last year everyone got 1 battery (rookies got a second one) in the KoP, but you could order more on FIRST Choice. However, the compressor wasn't included in the KoP, but you could get it on FIRST Choice.

The best information we have right now is last year's KoP. With it, you can get an idea of what we might be getting this year, however it could all change!

IKE 13-11-2012 15:38

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Thanks to this, Johnny 5 decided to throw some smack talk at the FRC 2013 robots:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdCf5cicrYU

Gary Dillard 13-11-2012 15:59

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by David Doerr (Post 1193917)
I wonder if the items that can now be seen on FIRST Choice will not be in the KOP - joysticks, classmate, camera, batteries, window motors, pneumatics components ... ?

I was not on a team last year and I didn't see the 2012 FIRST Choice. How did it work last year?

Last year each team was given some amount of credits (I don't even remember how many) and you could select different quantities of things within limits (you could only get a maximum of 2 batteries, for example). We got to preview the items similar to this year, but we didn't find out how many credits we would get or how many credits each item would be until ordering went live. I think the quantities available were revealed at the same time The more popular (biggest bargain) items went VERY quickly, and once they're gone they're gone (sounds like that will be the same this year. Here's what we ended up with:

2 of : Battery (fc12-21)
2 of : Encoders, 2 pack (fc12-66)
2 of : Foam Basketball (fc12-58)
1 of : iglide Sliding Slewing Ring Bearing (fc12-52)
2 of : Limit switch, roller lever actuated (fc12-48)
2 of : Van Door Motor (fc12-72)

maddoctor90 13-11-2012 16:08

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IKE (Post 1193953)
Thanks to this, Johnny 5 decided to throw some smack talk at the FRC 2013 robots:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdCf5cicrYU

I think of the same thing every time a snow blower motor is mentioned.

whcirobotics 13-11-2012 19:01

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IKE (Post 1193953)
Thanks to this, Johnny 5 decided to throw some smack talk at the FRC 2013 robots:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdCf5cicrYU

What a great addition to the KOP, a window motor that has a real output shaft to mate things too. No more funny adaptors, cool.

cj3958 13-11-2012 20:26

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Why is there an eight slot cRIO?

Alex.q 14-11-2012 14:34

Re: FIRST Choice
 
This is probably a dumb question, but all the FIRST Choice items say they are out of stock. This isn't actually true is it?

bardd 14-11-2012 14:38

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alex.q (Post 1194067)
This is probably a dumb question, but all the FIRST Choice items say they are out of stock. This isn't actually true is it?

That's because you're not allowed to order them... Once FIRST Choice opens for orders it'll be sorted out. Some products would probably be Out of Stock again within an hour though :P

Kevin Selavko 15-11-2012 16:00

Re: FIRST Choice
 
What is the job of the 3M Link Connector?

Alan Anderson 15-11-2012 16:19

Re: FIRST Choice
 
The 3M Link Connector is...a connector. It lets you connect and disconnect wires. It's sort of like a tiny version of the Anderson battery connector, for 18 gauge wires. One of the models handles two wires, the other handles four. I think it's intended for ribbon cable style cabling.

Kevin Selavko 15-11-2012 18:15

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Sorry I meant what they connect to, so they are just to connect to each other for easy wire unplugs?

Mark McLeod 15-11-2012 19:07

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gary Dillard (Post 1193955)
Last year each team was given some amount of credits (I don't even remember how many) ...

Each team got 100 credits last year.
Apparently it's the same this year: YOUR TEAM GETS 100 FIRST CHOICE CREDITS!

To refresh our memories here's last year's menu listing the credits for each item. Bear in mind that the values may change this year, and several items are new.

Chris_Ely 15-11-2012 19:48

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark McLeod (Post 1194271)
Each team got 100 credits last year.
Apparently it's the same this year: YOUR TEAM GETS 100 FIRST CHOICE CREDITS!

Sorry, but the top of the page says:
Quote:

FIRST Choice 2012 is closed. We are currently testing for 2013, please disregard any information found here, as it's probably incorrect.
We probably won't know the credit value until ordering opens.

DominickC 15-11-2012 19:48

Re: FIRST Choice
 
What's the advantage of the 3M wire connectors versus an Anderson Powerpole?

RufflesRidge 15-11-2012 20:34

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark McLeod (Post 1194271)
Each team got 100 credits last year.
Apparently it's the same this year: YOUR TEAM GETS 100 FIRST CHOICE CREDITS!

From the top of the page you linked to:

Quote:

FIRST Choice 2012 is closed. We are currently testing for 2013, please disregard any information found here, as it's probably incorrect.

Mark McLeod 15-11-2012 20:46

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Yea, missed that. Even without that message I'd suspect things would change for the actual opening day.

Alan Anderson 16-11-2012 01:20

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DominickC (Post 1194276)
What's the advantage of the 3M wire connectors versus an Anderson Powerpole?

The 3M Links are IDC (insulation displacement) connectors. You put unstripped 18 gauge wire into them and they pierce the insulation and make contact with the conductor. So you don't need to strip the wires, and you don't need to crimp terminals onto them.

Powerpoles, on the other hand, handle larger wire and a lot more current.

dellagd 16-11-2012 12:27

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IKE (Post 1193953)
Thanks to this, Johnny 5 decided to throw some smack talk at the FRC 2013 robots:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wdCf5cicrYU

No Disassemble! No Disassemble!

Sorry, I had to, saying that the programming team said that all the time in last build season.

inkspell4 16-11-2012 22:50

According to the FRC Blog Talons are legal as well as IFI Victor 188 (I think this the number)

Jon Stratis 17-11-2012 23:06

Re: FIRST Choice
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by inkspell4 (Post 1194439)
According to the FRC Blog Talons are legal as well as IFI Victor 188 (I think this the number)

Almost... Victor 888


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:30.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi