Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Electrical (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=53)
-   -   Radio and CIM motors (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=113595)

jnelly 15-02-2013 21:20

Radio and CIM motors
 
If we place our radio only about a half inch from a CIM motor will we have issues with magnetic interference?

cgmv123 15-02-2013 21:34

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Don't put it that close if you can help it. Especially after the FMS issues last year, you are strongly advised to put it up high, not near a motor, and not behind any pieces of metal.

DonRotolo 15-02-2013 22:15

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Not magnetic interference, but metal has this way of not letting radio waves through it. The antennas need to be not near metal. Find somewhere else if you can, like on a piece of something not-metal and flat, up higher on the robot, and mount it with velcro.

lior9999 16-02-2013 00:38

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
My team is mounting our wireless bridge inside of our electrical box at the bottom base of the robot (it's a rather tall machine). Do you think this could be an issue/cause us to have poor coms?

Alan Anderson 16-02-2013 02:24

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lior9999 (Post 1234193)
My team is mounting our wireless bridge inside of our electrical box at the bottom base of the robot (it's a rather tall machine). Do you think this could be an issue/cause us to have poor coms?

In a word: yes.

My advice is to keep it as high and exposed as you can without compromising the functionality of your 'bot and without risking having its wires snagged by other robots.

DonRotolo 16-02-2013 10:53

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lior9999 (Post 1234193)
My team is mounting our wireless bridge inside of our electrical box at the bottom base of the robot (it's a rather tall machine). Do you think this could be an issue/cause us to have poor coms?

Unless you have a non-metallic box and components (e.g., wires), yes.

Find some random space up high on the machine and velcro it there.
In past years we have lexan "sides" we use to display sponsor logos, we velcro it on the inside of one of those.

jmiller18 17-02-2013 02:12

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
A simple sheet of aluminum, even as thin as aluminum foil, wrapped around the cim will lower the emi to negligible amount

DonRotolo 17-02-2013 12:15

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jmiller18 (Post 1234840)
A simple sheet of aluminum, even as thin as aluminum foil, wrapped around the cim will lower the emi to negligible amount

Electrical, yes, but this has no effect upon magnetic, since aluminum is not a conductor of magnetism.

jmiller18 17-02-2013 20:19

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DonRotolo (Post 1234973)
Electrical, yes, but this has no effect upon magnetic, since aluminum is not a conductor of magnetism.

Ok then just go to your local osh or hardware store and pick up some dryer tubing, which is as close to steel foil you can get and rap it around ur cims

Kevin Sevcik 17-02-2013 20:24

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jmiller18 (Post 1235244)
Ok then just go to your local osh or hardware store and pick up some dryer tubing, which is as close to steel foil you can get and rap it around ur cims

Which will be entirely saturated by the large magnetic field of the CIM because it's so thin. Notice how thick the flux rings are on the BaneBots motors.

All of that is beside the point, however, because a CIM is still a big hunk of metal that is going to block radio from the field. Save yourself a headache and just put the radio somewhere away from metal and motors where it'll get good reception.

Al Skierkiewicz 21-02-2013 07:06

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
While the CIMs are mostly steel the RFI from the brush assy. still will be emitted from the motor through the end bells and the wiring. Twisting the motor wires and making them short runs to the speed controllers helps a little.
The radio has two antennae, one on each side of the box. These are required for the 802.11 standard, they are not either/or (diversity). To insure maximum connectivity and throughput, your radio should be mounted away from surrounding metal of any kind and higher up in your robot. When metal is in close proximity to the sides of the radio, the antennae become detuned and output power is affected. When metal is close to the top, the same occurs. What you are trying to achieve is that the radio can 'see' the field antenna while you drive.

jmiller18 27-02-2013 20:24

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DonRotolo (Post 1234973)
Electrical, yes, but this has no effect upon magnetic, since aluminum is not a conductor of magnetism.

also the routers use dipole antenna which use the electric field, not the magnetic, so that's all you need to block

Al Skierkiewicz 27-02-2013 21:27

Re: Radio and CIM motors
 
The radio actually uses PIFA antennae, vertically polarized to the plane of the bottom of the AP. The circuit board is the ground plane.
Antenna actually have both electric and magnetic fields, but they are 90 degrees apart. Most discussions center around the magnetic field so the electric field lives in obscurity.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi