Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Canadian supremacy (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=117866)

Koko Ed 20-07-2013 20:12

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nemo (Post 1283599)
Canada succeeds for all of the usual reasons, plus they have Tim Horton's doughnuts, whereas in the U.S. we mostly don't.

They're building a Tim Horton's in down the street from my apartment. Expect Rochester FIRST to dominate in the near future....

nuttle 20-07-2013 20:27

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Whatever it is, congratulations to all of these teams and a really nice job by everyone who has contributed to this success. It is more than just the winning too, which is very good to see. Here's hoping our neighbors to the North have to work even harder to keep it going in the future, and also that all teams can be inspired by their example.

George C 20-07-2013 20:53

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ErvinI (Post 1283617)
Out of the top tier of Ontario teams, only 1310 benefited from a wild card. 1241 and 1334 both won EI's (with 1334 also winning the Western Canadian Regional), while 4039 got in from the waitlist, I believe.

Our win in Calgary gave another team the chance to go using that wildcard. They chose not to go.

cad321 20-07-2013 21:19

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pault (Post 1283611)
In Canada, because of 1114 and 2056, if you want to win a regional, you are going to have to aim higher than most powerhouse teams. Because of that, they are ending up with more and more teams trying to go above and beyond with floor pickups, 30pt climbs, etc. And the ones who opt to just cycle are going to try their very hardest to create a worthy cycler.

Exactly! This year 2386 bit off more than we could chew by doing almost everything, a 30pt climber, shooter and as always a great defense bot. We did this trying to be equal to or surpass the powerhouse teams. We could have succeeded if VEX had provided us with a critical dimension but that's beside the point.

Between Canada FIRST, amazing powerhouse teams and the WildCards Ontario teams have a great opportunity to go far in competition.

jamierose 20-07-2013 22:21

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
At the Waterloo regional, I heard from Karthik that zero Canadian FRC teams bought Mecanum wheels this year. Maybe that has something to do with it? :rolleyes:

Honestly, though, I think much of Canada's success comes from how much the teams work with each other. For example, 610 worked with teams such as 1241, 907, and 1310 throughout the season to practice and work on the robots. We also held a quick-build on kickoff day with several teams. I know that 1114 and 2056 also work with other teams in some way (or at least that's what I gathered from what Karthik said during the finals at GTR West in 2012). With some very good teams in Ontario and the high level of cooperation, this makes Ontario an example of successful CoopertitionŽ.

gr8dragon 20-07-2013 22:29

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
The teachers strike was really damaging to FIRST in Canada by removing a lot of veteran teams from regionals. The amazing part about the strike in my opinion though, is the fact that alumni/students/mentors, from teams that couldn't run this season, went on to help other teams. Personally I had the wonderful opportunity to work with team 1241 this year as a result. I think that in this way people have a chance to share how different teams run the season differently and take the best from here and there and put it together to be better overall. I imagine that if these people go back to their original teams next year, then they bring back all of this knowledge and can help their original teams do even better. In line with that is also that in Canada teams are starting to retain more and more alumni as mentors. I think that as a result their respective teams are getting better year after year. The alumni/mentor force is growing in Canada and is something I think that will help every team.

One thing I think that a lot of people may not know about Canadian regionals and teams is that, despite the rivalries all the teams don't forget to help each other out. At championships we cheer for each other, we share parts and we really do work like a community. To avoid sounding cliche, the fact that we can compete so much and compete the right way means that we can truly take the time to appreciate each others skills and be inspired by one another.

I would like to thank 1241 and any other teams that let members of "rival" teams join in their ranks. I am sure everyone else who had the chance had just as amazing an experience as I. It was truly humbling to be accepted into teams and be offered a job and be trusted to do what you do best.

As J -No said in his post big thank you to Canada FIRST for helping teams settle in during the strike period.

AdamHeard 20-07-2013 22:44

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gr8dragon (Post 1283635)
The teachers strike was really damaging to FIRST in Canada by removing a lot of veteran teams from regionals. The amazing part about the strike in my opinion though, is the fact that alumni/students/mentors, from teams that couldn't run this season, went on to help other teams. Personally I had the wonderful opportunity to work with team 1241 this year as a result. I think that in this way people have a chance to share how different teams run the season differently and take the best from here and there and put it together to be better overall. I imagine that if these people go back to their original teams next year, then they bring back all of this knowledge and can help their original teams do even better. In line with that is also that in Canada teams are starting to retain more and more alumni as mentors. I think that as a result their respective teams are getting better year after year. The alumni/mentor force is growing in Canada and is something I think that will help every team.

One thing I think that a lot of people may not know about Canadian regionals and teams is that, despite the rivalries all the teams don't forget to help each other out. At championships we cheer for each other, we share parts and we really do work like a community. To avoid sounding cliche, the fact that we can compete so much and compete the right way means that we can truly take the time to appreciate each others skills and be inspired by one another.

I would like to thank 1241 and any other teams that let members of "rival" teams join in their ranks. I am sure everyone else who had the chance had just as amazing an experience as I. It was truly humbling to be accepted into teams and be offered a job and be trusted to do what you do best.

As J -No said in his post big thank you to Canada FIRST for helping teams settle in during the strike period.

Aside from 188, what Canadian teams were not able to compete due to the strike? Curious how many were affected to that severity.

Gabrielle62 20-07-2013 23:23

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Being a Canadian team has definitely come with a great amount of pride this past year. From expanding FIRST into Alberta with a new regional, to world champions and IRI winners, I think it's safe to say we've all gotten a taste of what it's like to win up here.

As 2994 worked (and continues) to try to expand FIRST in Ottawa this year by starting up some rookie teams. Once we all competed and we were getting ready to hit the road, we asked them what the experience was like, and what they were going to aiming for in the upcoming year. They all agreed they wanted to work to prove themselves, and rise to the level of the "powerhouse" teams they got the chance to see.

So I thank all the "powerhouse" teams like 1114, 2056, 610, and 1241, for inspiring Canada, along with other teams around the world.

Feroz1325 21-07-2013 00:21

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 1283637)
Aside from 188, what Canadian teams were not able to compete due to the strike? Curious how many were affected to that severity.

All of these veteran teams from Ontario did not compete in FRC in 2013 but competed in 2012, whether it was due to the teachers strike or other factors I'm not sure.

Teams (total: 16)
188, 843, 919, 1009, 1053, 1219, 1221, 1246, 1404, 1514, 1535, 1605, 1835, 2076, 2198, 3739

George C 21-07-2013 07:37

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Feroz1325 (Post 1283646)
All of these veteran teams from Ontario did not compete in FRC in 2013 but competed in 2012, whether it was due to the teachers strike or other factors I'm not sure.

Teams (total: 16)
188, 843, 919, 1009, 1053, 1219, 1221, 1246, 1404, 1514, 1535, 1605, 1835, 2076, 2198, 3739

We were very fortunate to be able to give a home to 2 Grade 12 students from a team that didn't compete this year although it wasn't because of teachers' withdrawal of voluntary extra curricular services - there was no strike. That team stopped operating in September. One of those students is the lead designer of our very effective climbing system.

This has been our best season to date and yes, it had a lot to do with that job action. When we weren't able to operate at the school, Sheridan College took us in and gave us free use of their excellent shop. 1241 and 1325 also made use of the facility. We went from 1 small CNC mill and one lathe to at least 30 lathes and mills plus CNC equipment. We also went from 7 to 17 active mentors and no teachers were involved. This was because we worked from 5 to 9 plus Saturdays and people who work could get there. Alumni and parents of alumni also helped out. We even saved money because we didn't have to pay caretaker time as is required if want to work in the school on a weekend. The Oakville Yacht Squadron also gave us free use of their (mostly unheated) facility from January to April so that we could set up a pyramid. 1325 used it as well.

Because of shared difficulties many of the Ontario teams have formed stronger inter-team ties. The team mentor system also works to bring teams closer together. In Ontario for the past three years, rookie teams are assigned a mentor team to assist them in their first year. This usually develops into a very strong lasting relationship. The competition is fierce in Ontario. Come check it out next season at one or more of the 4 regionals.

Lil' Lavery 21-07-2013 12:57

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
While Canadian teams are always incredibly competitive, 2013 was an incredibly strong season for Canadian teams. What remains to be seen is if 2014 will be at the same level. 2012 was an incredible season for MAR teams (25 winning the championship, 341 being arguably the best team in the world, and MAR teams winning several outside regionals), the performance of the region regressed in 2013. It will be interesting to see if Ontario really has replaced Michigan as the elite region in FRC, or if it was simply a incredible year from a good region.

Cory 21-07-2013 16:00

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lil' Lavery (Post 1283682)
While Canadian teams are always incredibly competitive, 2013 was an incredibly strong season for Canadian teams. What remains to be seen is if 2014 will be at the same level. 2012 was an incredible season for MAR teams (25 winning the championship, 341 being arguably the best team in the world, and MAR teams winning several outside regionals), the performance of the region regressed in 2013. It will be interesting to see if Ontario really has replaced Michigan as the elite region in FRC, or if it was simply a incredible year from a good region.

It was a lot easier to be really good this year, in particular relative to the performance to the powerhouse teams, than it ever has been before.

XaulZan11 21-07-2013 16:37

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lil' Lavery (Post 1283682)
While Canadian teams are always incredibly competitive, 2013 was an incredibly strong season for Canadian teams. What remains to be seen is if 2014 will be at the same level. 2012 was an incredible season for MAR teams (25 winning the championship, 341 being arguably the best team in the world, and MAR teams winning several outside regionals), the performance of the region regressed in 2013. It will be interesting to see if Ontario really has replaced Michigan as the elite region in FRC, or if it was simply a incredible year from a good region.

This was my thought as well. Many teams in Canada had 'career years'. I recall similar discussions in 2009 when Michigan had 4 of the 6 teams in the finals of Einstein. While Michigan has remained very strong, they haven't matched the success they had in '09.

cad321 21-07-2013 16:42

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cory (Post 1283704)
It was a lot easier to be really good this year, in particular relative to the performance to the powerhouse teams, than it ever has been before.

I too saw this. In previous years when I saw teams go up against teams like 1114 and 2056, it was clear that the other alliance had no chance (unless they were facing another powerhouse). This year there was a clear possibility in some matches where it looked as if the other alliance might actually be able to defeat the powerhouses.

Perhaps this is another indicator that this was one of the toughest games that the game design committee has given us yet.

David Brinza 21-07-2013 17:49

Re: Canadian supremacy
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LedLover96 (Post 1283593)
Canada reigned supreme on an international level this year.
<snip>
What makes them so good?

Canadian Bacon? :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 17:42.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi