Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Rumor Mill (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=15)
-   -   Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=122141)

Zaque 23-11-2013 01:28

Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Hi all,
I seem to recall hearing somewhere that the Talons and/or the roboRIO are waterproof. This sounds far fetched to me, but I wanted to hear from the community for confirmation.

Thanks,
Zaque

SenorZ 23-11-2013 01:33

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
I heard they aren't.
But I may have made that up, too.

Mr V 23-11-2013 02:04

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
From what we've seen so far about the rRIO it would not be water proof.

The talon's case is not sealed so it is unlikely it would be water proof either.

Anupam Goli 23-11-2013 06:30

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
I suppose if the roboRio was waterproof, that would give the game away....


I'll show myself out.

Zaque 23-11-2013 09:49

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Anupam Goli (Post 1304819)
I suppose if the roboRio was waterproof, that would give the game away....

My thoughts exactly.

Al Skierkiewicz 23-11-2013 10:17

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
The Crio is not waterproof. The seal kit that was available was intended to keep debris from working it's way into the internals but still was not waterproof. The Talon seems to be sealed but I have not heard it speced for immersion. The outside power connections and PWM would not meet 'waterproof' definitions.

MrForbes 23-11-2013 10:48

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
If you mean "waterproof" as in you can operate them underwater, without putting them in a waterproof compartment, NO, they are not waterproof.

They are slightly water resistant, meaning that they probably will still work if you accidentally splash a little bit of water on them.

yash101 23-11-2013 11:32

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
wouldn't they would be waterproof in 100% distilled water or mineral oil? :D

Caleb Sykes 23-11-2013 21:10

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by yash101 (Post 1304880)
wouldn't they would be waterproof in 100% distilled water or mineral oil? :D

This is brilliant!!!

Everyone spends so much time imagining water games. Before that ever happens though, FRC will probably incorporate some non-conductive liquid.

Some options:
de-ionized water
mineral oil
vegetable oil
milk
melted wax
syrup

Pratik Kunapuli 23-11-2013 21:46

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
If the 2015 game is played in a swimming pool of milk, we would be fools not to call the control system the oRIO.

Walter Deitzler 23-11-2013 21:51

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by inkling16 (Post 1305057)
This is brilliant!!!

Everyone spends so much time imagining water games. Before that ever happens though, FRC will probably incorporate some non-conductive liquid.
...
syrup

Slow down here, don't want to give the Canadians too much of an advantage...

DampRobot 23-11-2013 22:13

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by LedLover96 (Post 1305060)
Slow down here, don't want to give the Canadians too much of an advantage...

Naw, I hear their strategic syrup reserve was stolen a while ago.

BBray_T1296 23-11-2013 22:15

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pratik341 (Post 1305059)
If the 2015 game is played in a swimming pool of milk, we would be fools not to call the control system the oRIO.

Very funny, very funny.

in case you missed the joke


The problem is that most of these substances become contaminated easily. Yes, of course in DI water there would be no shorting, but imagine 2 days later after everyone's greasy gearboxes have churned through the water for eighty-something matches. It would not stay pure for long.

Also, I think a compressor would have a physics-related malfunction while running in any kind of liquid immersion.

Gregor 24-11-2013 00:32

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BBray_T1296 (Post 1305073)
Also, I think a compressor would have a physics-related malfunction while running in any kind of liquid immersion.

You're forgetting the simple mantra of successful robots.

Problem physics?

BBray_T1296 24-11-2013 02:59

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gregor (Post 1305110)
You're forgetting the simple mantra of successful robots.

Problem physics?

OHH GOD NOOO!!! Never link to this post EVER again!!!

yash101 24-11-2013 10:59

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Kind of a random post:
So, does that mean that I can cool my overclocked quadcopter motors by submersing then in milk? The motors are two black pieces stacked atop a white core, making it an oreo. That's a flying snack! :D

Anyways, a use of nonconductive liquids would to passively cool motor controllers internally! ;)

Has anyone tried using melted iron as a liquid? The robot would probably last long like that! :D

Anyways, back on topic, just use de-ionized water as water!

MrForbes 24-11-2013 11:59

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Yash, make sure your team signs up for NURC. They changed the schedule, game will be announced around New Years, and will take place in October. You'll learn more about water and electronics than you ever wanted to know ;)

gluxon 24-11-2013 12:08

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Pratik341 (Post 1305059)
If the 2015 game is played in a swimming pool of milk, we would be fools not to call the control system the oRIO.

That was pretty great. XD

FrankJ 24-11-2013 14:32

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Computers used to be submerged in DI water for cooling. You could probably do the same for a Talon. Doesn't make them water proof in the conventional sense. Any water the robot is likely to be exposed to will be conductive enough to short exposed electronics.

Joe Ross 24-11-2013 15:05

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Here's a waterproof Victor 884: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=holY7IjXwl0

yash101 24-11-2013 23:23

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MrForbes (Post 1305200)
Yash, make sure your team signs up for NURC. They changed the schedule, game will be announced around New Years, and will take place in October. You'll learn more about water and electronics than you ever wanted to know ;)

I will query my coach and find out if he is interested. Do you have a link to their homepage?
https://google.com/search?q=nurc returns a lot of different underwater robotics/research facilities/other stuff, so it is hard to find out which one you are talking about! :D

MrForbes 24-11-2013 23:35

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
https://sites.google.com/site/nation...waterrobotics/

should do it

yash101 24-11-2013 23:44

Re: Talons/roboRIO - Waterproof?
 
Cool! I shall query my robotics mentor if he will allow it. However, my only concern is the amount of time we waste. We haven't succeeded in anything big this year, yet! I do not think our team has enough time or motivation to do this! :(

However, me being optimistic, I'm sure that we will join, even if it isn't this year :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:58.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi