Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   3D Printing A Wheel (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=123426)

T^2 19-12-2013 21:53

3D Printing A Wheel
 
1678 is doing a test run of a full-size 3D-printed wheel; you can see it at http://www.twitch.tv/frc1678. We're using the MakerBot Replicator 2 we got through Donors Choose.

We tried this last night, but the filament snapped, and somehow part of it had gotten wrapped around the drive gear. In addition, more filament was clogged up in the nozzle head. Took me about 2 hours to fix. I hope this one goes better.

coalhot 19-12-2013 22:04

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
PLA wheel? Interesting. Also, how large is the wheel? Looks like a 4"

avanboekel 19-12-2013 22:07

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
What % infill are you using?

IVAN 19-12-2013 22:10

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
2429 just got a replicator 2 as well make sure to have your filament cable loose and unconstrained. also have you changed any of the heating settings?

dtengineering 19-12-2013 22:15

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
I saw the head move for about five seconds and then an ad popped up... turned it off at that point.

Jason

T^2 19-12-2013 22:20

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by coalhot (Post 1314816)
PLA wheel? Interesting. Also, how large is the wheel? Looks like a 4"

Yes, yes it is, and yes.

Quote:

Originally Posted by avanboekel (Post 1314818)
What % infill are you using?

100%.

Quote:

Originally Posted by IVAN (Post 1314819)
2429 just got a replicator 2 as well make sure to have your filament cable loose and unconstrained. also have you changed any of the heating settings?

That may have been the problem. We'd printed stuff before, but I switched colors for this piece. I tried a few heat settings, but the default 230C seems to stick best.

Quote:

Originally Posted by dtengineering (Post 1314821)
I saw the head move for about five seconds and then an ad popped up... turned it off at that point.

Jason

Sorry, blame twitch. Try using Adblock?

DampRobot 19-12-2013 22:28

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
I'm interested that you decided to 3d print wheels at all. Is this just a test, to see what kind of quality you get? If you're seriously considering using 3d printed wheels next year, could you talk a bit about the thought that went into the decision?

T^2 19-12-2013 22:37

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DampRobot (Post 1314825)
I'm interested that you decided to 3d print wheels at all. Is this just a test, to see what kind of quality you get? If you're seriously considering using 3d printed wheels next year, could you talk a bit about the thought that went into the decision?

Yes, it's a test. We think it's quite possible (based off the advice of one of our mentors, who has built many 3D printers) that an extruded PLA wheel will be strong enough to endure the rigors of FRC. Our hope is to be able to cut down on manpower and machining time. We use 2-inch wide wheels with 971's tread attachment style, which take our sponsors several weeks to machine out of aluminum. In the build season, this is unacceptable, so we're trying to print them instead (using a modified design, obviously). A 1/4 scale model held my weight without cracking. If you want, I can post renders of both designs.

IVAN 19-12-2013 22:39

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
what resolution did you use fine,low,standard ? also have you tried putting down the big blue piece of tape that comes with it?

T^2 19-12-2013 22:53

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IVAN (Post 1314829)
what resolution did you use fine,low,standard ? also have you tried putting down the big blue piece of tape that comes with it?

High resolution, using tape.

Calvin Hartley 19-12-2013 22:58

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
When will this model (likely) be done? Will you be making more to test an actual drive train, or just the one wheel? Either way, I am interested in seeing results.

MichaelBick 19-12-2013 22:58

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by T^2 (Post 1314828)
Yes, it's a test. We think it's quite possible (based off the advice of one of our mentors, who has built many 3D printers) that an extruded PLA wheel will be strong enough to endure the rigors of FRC. Our hope is to be able to cut down on manpower and machining time. We use 2-inch wide wheels with 971's tread attachment style, which take our sponsors several weeks to machine out of aluminum. In the build season, this is unacceptable, so we're trying to print them instead (using a modified design, obviously). A 1/4 scale model held my weight without cracking. If you want, I can post renders of both designs.

What is your problem with Vex traction wheels, other than the attatchment method?

IVAN 19-12-2013 23:11

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
are you printing the wheel solid ?

T^2 19-12-2013 23:14

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Calvin Hartley (Post 1314843)
When will this model (likely) be done? Will you be making more to test an actual drive train, or just the one wheel? Either way, I am interested in seeing results.

Tomorrow evening, and we'll test this one before deciding if we want to make more.

Quote:

Originally Posted by MichaelBick (Post 1314844)
What is your problem with Vex traction wheels, other than the attatchment method?

The attachment method.

Quote:

Originally Posted by IVAN (Post 1314847)
are you printing the wheel solid ?

Yes.

IVAN 19-12-2013 23:33

Re: 3D Printing A Wheel
 
o.o why not polyurethane casting and using hollowed version out of wheel to use as a negative because printing four or six of those wheels (at least) is going to be expensive

my math has it at 5 cents per gram if your using makerbot pla and 1.5 cents using an amazon competitor


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 04:49.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi