Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Robot in 3 days /72 hours (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=123810)

D.Allred 30-12-2013 12:43

Re: Robot in 3 days /72 hours
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Racer26 (Post 1318284)
I truly can't think of a better way to mitigate the problem of stifled design diversity that was apparent in 2013. Ri3D in 2013 did seem to limit the diversity we saw in designs at the competitions.

It seemed that this is because more outlandish designs were never tried, since a working design example was readily available.

I expect that 2014, with 5 (or possibly 6?) Ri3Ds to use as an example, what we'll see is increased diversity, but still a stifling of the really off the wall ideas.

I guess I just don't get these arguments. 2013 was by far the most diverse for robot design combinations since I began in 2009.

I also saw very few clones of the 2013 Ri3D robot design, unless you consider every wall pickup shooter / 10 point hanger a "clone." That was a successful strategy with or without Ri3D. Floor pick up and climbing above the 10 point level was a bit tricky.

I'm hoping Ri3D / Build Blitz improve the level and depth of competition in 2014. It's still too difficult to fill a 24 robot pick list at most regionals.

David

Abhishek R 30-12-2013 13:01

Re: Robot in 3 days /72 hours
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by D.Allred (Post 1318320)
I guess I just don't get these arguments. 2013 was by far the most diverse for robot design combinations since I began in 2009.

Agreed.

With all the different types of strategies you could approach the game with (cycler, vacuum, FCS, climb, etc.) I'd argue 2013 was the most diverse year. Just look at 2012, as recent as it gets, every robot had a similar turret-style shooter and a rolling ground pickup.

Many of the bots this year had a linear shooter. They also had a passive hanger. I think several of those teams could've figured that out by themselves anyway, most teams used a linear or occasional U-shaped shooter, and then hung for the easy 10 points.

I think this will definitely help inspire and raise the floor of FRC.

pavchag 01-01-2014 00:13

Re: Robot in 3 days /72 hours
 
Team O-RYON is happy to join the Robot in 3 Days effort! We have been planning this for only a week but we are ready!

We are very excited to try to inspire the robotics world and can't wait to start prototyping and building our robot in 3 days!

Follow us on twitter #TeamORYON and our live stream on "robot in 3 days" website and/or justin.tv (search for roll24productions) Follow us on Facebook (search Rice Robotics Club)

Check out our intro on robot in 3 days website as well!

MooreteP 01-01-2014 02:16

Re: Robot in 3 days /72 hours
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by techtiger1 (Post 1318286)
I really wish I was excited as you guys about all this robot in three days stuff. While I am of course going to analyze the robots that are produced, I really think there is going to be a lot of parity. Most of the games now are not diverse so there are only so many robots the average team can build. Sorry to be a buzz kill but that's how I see this whole thing ending up.

My current team has moved three times in the last three years.
The vagaries of a teams experience: build space, sponsorship, mentors, school year, fresh crop of students, field trips, board of education meetings, fundraising, community service, regular life..........

I am grateful to RI3D. You will provide valuable shortcuts to help my students build a more capable machine while still learning about engineering and project management.

4, maybe 5 robots? Thank you so much. You are an awesome resource.
Keep getting better.

Hallry 01-01-2014 16:46

Re: Robot in 3 days /72 hours
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pavchag (Post 1319055)
Team O-RYON is happy to join the Robot in 3 Days effort! We have been planning this for only a week but we are ready!

We are very excited to try to inspire the robotics world and can't wait to start prototyping and building our robot in 3 days!

Follow us on twitter #TeamORYON and our live stream on "robot in 3 days" website and/or justin.tv (search for roll24productions) Follow us on Facebook (search Rice Robotics Club)

Check out our intro on robot in 3 days website as well!

Here is the link to their introduction by Ri3D! Congrats and best of luck! :D https://www.youtube.com/watch?featur...&v=UbpLAZMU5co


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:50.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi