Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   "Best" Pit Scouting Questions (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=127650)

pabeekm 09-03-2014 18:53

"Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
This thread is in honor of all those impressively irrelevant or hilariously phrased pit scouting questions we've heard at competition. Please post any you've heard or would love to ask. Have fun with this! :)

Examples:
"How many linear feet of zip ties are on your robot?"
"Is it boy or a girl?"
"If you were to compare your robot to an unladen swallow, would it be African or European?"


Props to my teammate Chase for coming up with the idea for this thread.

FrankJ 09-03-2014 19:02

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
What is the weight of your code?

How many bits do you use?

How many wheels is your mechanum drive?

Whippet 09-03-2014 19:03

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
"On a scale of 1 to 10, how good do your bumpers look?"

xXhunter47Xx 09-03-2014 19:07

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
not really a "best" question, but rather a little embarrassing.
Them: "Did you use Windriver or Netbeans for coding?"
Me: "We used Labview"
Them: "...oh"

ehfeinberg 09-03-2014 19:08

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whippet (Post 1356017)
"On a scale of 1 to 10, how good do your bumpers look?"

This is a serious question... We have it on our pit scouting question sheet.

joelg236 09-03-2014 19:14

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ehfeinberg (Post 1356021)
This is a serious question... We have it on our pit scouting question sheet.

I hope you don't ask them. haha

SoftwareBug2.0 09-03-2014 19:27

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whippet (Post 1356017)
"On a scale of 1 to 10, how good do your bumpers look?"

I enjoy some of the "stupid" questions. For example, the only correct answer for that one is "11". Similarly, someone from a different team came and asked me how many seconds ago our drive team had left the pit. My answer was 347 and a half. He said ok, took about two steps and then stopped as he realized what had happened.

Similarly, I love the questions that you can answer factually but you know that when you do it's going to screw up their data processing. For example, there's lots of non-exhaustive multiple choice: "does your robot use traction wheels or mecanum?" For us the correct answer is "no". Similarly, I like questions where the answers might become skewed so much that the average won't mean anything. If you ask how far robots can shoot you'll get one robot like ours that will go like 100 feet, and if you average that with a bunch of other robots that shoot between 10 and 20 feet your average will end up being above the distance that all but one of the robots shoot.

ehfeinberg 09-03-2014 19:28

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by joelg236 (Post 1356023)
I hope you don't ask them. haha

Oh true. Sorry, I misread the OP's question.

Duncan Macdonald 09-03-2014 19:31

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
"How many wheels are on your robot?"
"7"

Shooter wheels are wheels too

mrnoble 09-03-2014 19:42

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Duncan Macdonald (Post 1356034)
"How many wheels are on your robot?"
"7"

Shooter wheels are wheels too

Then, 14?

Keegbot 09-03-2014 19:43

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
"On a scale from 1 to 10, how much aloha does your team show?"

mrnoble 09-03-2014 19:44

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
"What's the most points your robot can possibly score?"

I've always loved to see how my students answer that one.

GBK 09-03-2014 19:46

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Before bag day we were at a local practice field playing catch with another teams robot. We tossed the ball back and forth across the truss, catching it. and throwing it back. With our permission the team used one of these volleys in their revile video. This weekend at a competition one of their students doing pit scouting asked us several questions. His last question was: If we threw a ball over the truss do you think your robot could catch it. I just smiled and asked him if he had seen their revile video.

Christopher149 09-03-2014 20:01

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

How many motors are on your robot?
Same with the wheels, I think the intent was in the drivetrain. I think it was for last year, so ... 10?

Quote:

What type of drivetrain do you have?
-mecanum
How many wheels do you have?
-um, four??
Well, unless you have some other multiple of 4, I guess.

Quote:

How fast does your robot go?
Now, this is a serious question, but it goes anywhere from "I don't know", "pretty fast", to making up a number since we haven't measured it.

nlj007 09-03-2014 20:01

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
"What is the gear ratio of your drivetrain?"
Our answer
"Umm something like a Million to One..."
*scouter writes down our answer*

brandon.cottrell 09-03-2014 22:37

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
One of our scouts asked a team: "On a scale of 1-5 how is your driving capability?"

Their answer was 10.

Stay classy 987.

DampRobot 09-03-2014 22:41

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whippet (Post 1356017)
"On a scale of 1 to 10, how good do your bumpers look?"

The quality of a teams robot is often much more closely correlated to the quality of their bumpers than most people would guess. While asking a team this wouldn't do much good, this is actually not such a bad stat to have.

We often give our drivetrain speed in knots to pit scouts.

Canon reeves 09-03-2014 22:42

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Scout: is there anything else you would like to add?
Me: yes, they have an extremely attractive driver
Scout: surprised then laughs
Me: no seriously, write that down

cadandcookies 09-03-2014 22:57

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DampRobot (Post 1356170)
The quality of a teams robot is often much more closely correlated to the quality of their bumpers than most people would guess. While asking a team this wouldn't do much good, this is actually not such a bad stat to have.

We often give our drivetrain speed in knots to pit scouts.

Come by out pits and you'll get it in a variety of colorful units-- fractions of a space shuttle's top speed (1/2000), the speed that a stalk of bamboo grows by (329,184), or if we're feeling nice, miles per hour (~10mph).

rkbot 09-03-2014 23:26

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Questions i have seen this year are
the classic "What team number are you?" fools look at the sign
This year "Can your robot pick up?" Nooo... That big box with the wheels on top is just there to look good you dummy, get you stuff right or just ask to look at the robot to make your own observations before asking stupid questions.
I get the what team number one atleasy twice every regional and i avoid answering questions because i am usually in the back of the pit working on the robot.

Rynocorn 10-03-2014 00:07

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
I always try to make my teammates answer questions instead of me so if they ever ask me something that they don't know I just always say 7. Sometimes I pause and pretend to think or just instantly say it, but it's always 7. The best is when someone asks about the drive motors, dimensions, or height - it really throws them for a loop :)

xXhunter47Xx 10-03-2014 00:32

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rkbot (Post 1356205)
Questions i have seen this year are
the classic "What team number are you?" fools look at the sign
This year "Can your robot pick up?" Nooo... That big box with the wheels on top is just there to look good you dummy, get you stuff right or just ask to look at the robot to make your own observations before asking stupid questions.
I get the what team number one atleasy twice every regional and i avoid answering questions because i am usually in the back of the pit working on the robot.

That doesn't sound very GP. there were many instances where I've told scouts about the intake and they still ask if we can load.
Sometimes they forget, or it's just a habit they got into. You'll have to deal with stupid questions in the "real" world as well, not just at FRC, so you might as well get used to being polite about it.
I remember the most ridiculous one was "how good looking was your robot?"
I wanted to reply "devilishly handsome like me" but the drivers were there and us being friends, I'd know they'd probably say "don't insult the robot like that, it's not that ugly".

Sparky3D 10-03-2014 00:51

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mrnoble (Post 1356044)
"What's the most points your robot can possibly score?"

I've always loved to see how my students answer that one.

I got asked that one on Thursday during our regional (week 1). We hadn't even had our first practice match yet. I told them 1200 :yikes: . They looked confused and walked away. Honestly, how are you supposed to answer a question like, especially when matches haven't even started :confused: ? Which reminds me, I should really look over our pit scouting sheet and make sure we don't have anything like that on there.

PAR_WIG1350 10-03-2014 01:10

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
This isn't really a scouting question, but at the 2010 championship, while serving as safety captain, another safety captain was interrogating teams (it was supposed to 'promote' safety) and I was asked if our team kept an AED (automated external defibrillator) with our first aid kit.

atucker4072 10-03-2014 01:14

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
We've gotten asked every year how many wheels are on your drive train. They are also looking right at it when they ask this. I can't wait to see the questions we get asked this year due to the game.

If you are looking for serious ones definitely the robots speed(s) is a good one to ask. You can ask the consistency of the shots they make but most everyone will say something higher because yeah they think they are that good. It could help if you asked how many events the drive team has been in and it could give you an idea of their drive team could possibly do.

safiq10 10-03-2014 03:11

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Not really FRC but In FTC I was asked in FTC does our robot hang? But someone said lift instead of hang. I did get a few laughs!:yikes:
Them: Does your it lift?
Me: Ya 125 lbs! (begins flexing) Ohh and the robot also lifts.

minidave910 10-03-2014 07:28

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Personally I believe any question that isn't of strategic importance falls into this category. I have never once stopped while making a pick list, consulted the data, and said "No, we can't pick them. They only have six wheels in their drive train."

Jmulderig 10-03-2014 10:53

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
How about "answers" to pit scouting questions...Im sure we all have that member or two that we dread beign asked anything about the robot.

q:"Is your robot mainly offense or defense"?
A: Defense (our robot was a climber_Thats all it did climb to the top)

dipmeinaluminum 10-03-2014 11:46

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Can your robot hang on the Truss for 30pts?

Conor Ryan 10-03-2014 11:50

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Question: What language do you use? (In reference to programming)
Answer: English.

jwfoss 10-03-2014 11:51

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
We tell our scouts to fill out everything on the sheet they can without asking questions, then ask for clarification and information about auto modes etc.

If I had a dollar for every time I heard "How many wheels do you have?"...

jmcrawford45 10-03-2014 12:26

Question: Can your robot score in the low goal?
Everyone's Answer: Yes
Question: Can your robot get assist points?
Everyone's Answer: Yes

rkbot 10-03-2014 13:24

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by xXhunter47Xx (Post 1356249)
That doesn't sound very GP. there were many instances where I've told scouts about the intake and they still ask if we can load.
Sometimes they forget, or it's just a habit they got into. You'll have to deal with stupid questions in the "real" world as well, not just at FRC, so you might as well get used to being polite about it.
I remember the most ridiculous one was "how good looking was your robot?"
I wanted to reply "devilishly handsome like me" but the drivers were there and us being friends, I'd know they'd probably say "don't insult the robot like that, it's not that ugly".

Lol i always answer politely, but I sigh and shake my head when they leave.

xXhunter47Xx 10-03-2014 13:51

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by rkbot (Post 1356555)
Lol i always answer politely, but I sigh and shake my head when they leave.

Oh okay I feel your pain haha

Mason987 10-03-2014 14:38

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brandon1266 (Post 1356168)
One of our scouts asked a team: "On a scale of 1-5 how is your driving capability?"

Their answer was 10.

Stay classy 987.

To be fair, your scouts asked the driver himself. I tried to inform them but I was too busy laughing at how natural the response was. :p

samfruth 10-03-2014 16:56

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jmcrawford45 (Post 1356494)
Question: Can your robot score in the low goal?
Everyone's Answer: Yes
Question: Can your robot get assist points?
Everyone's Answer: Yes

My answer: NOO

Lydia Yeckley 10-03-2014 17:12

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Do you have a drive train?

*looks sternly at me, i look at robot*

No, we don't.

*scribbles down answer*

RobotDoktor 10-03-2014 20:43

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
A funny category that got onto our scouting list in regards to drive team was "craziness", as in how aggressively they drive (our main driver gets a 10 out of 10).

Some fun answers to common questions:
"We have 68 wheels on our drivetrain. That is to say, we have four 6" mecanums and four traction wheels."

"Our drivetrain goes 120MPH scaled to a 2013 Corvette."

"We can score a lot."

"The LEDs are to make it look good and go faster. Mostly to go faster."

colin340 11-03-2014 10:32

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
what type of bear is best?

kk052 11-03-2014 13:31

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
In a little more serous note, how do you answere how many moters your drivetrain has to someone who doesn't know what a swerve drive is? Because technically 8 but only 4 propel the robot.

neshera 11-03-2014 13:42

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GBK (Post 1356045)
... "their revile video."

Thankfully, this is only rarely true ;)

atucker4072 11-03-2014 14:04

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by colin340 (Post 1357264)
what type of bear is best?

Black Bear.

Sparky3D 11-03-2014 14:09

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by colin340 (Post 1357264)
what type of bear is best?

I vote for pandas, although some people don't consider them bears. :D

neshera 11-03-2014 14:43

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by colin340 (Post 1357264)
what type of bear is best?

Guiness on tap.

Oh wait, bear....

Max Boord 11-03-2014 15:17

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
The best responses ive ever seen:

1902 (exploding bacon) gave us all of there info in bacon strips.

I tried to ask 987 about fundraising. "one of our mentors got really lucky and there has been no need for us to fund raise ever since"

challenging 1065 (moose) about a weight violation.

asking:
1538 for milk
1058 for PVC cement
1902 for grease
33 for honey
67 for a soldering iron

Dentyne_Ice97 11-03-2014 16:28

Re: "Best" Pit Scouting Questions
 
here are some pretty funny ones we were asked:

"Can your robot 360 no-scope?"
"Does your robot run off of the new Mage system? I heard it's magical"


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 21:29.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi