Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   VexPro still out of stock? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=129364)

Richard Wallace 07-05-2014 13:10

VexPro still out of stock?
 
Sorry for raising this topic again -- I really like prototyping with VexPro parts, whether for FRC robots or for other projects.

One of those projects needs some 1/2" hex shaft and bearings. Can someone from VexPro or therobotspace or WCP please advise when these will be back in stock?

I would like to plan ... :)

Thanks,

Jimmy Nichols 07-05-2014 13:15

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Not to steer you away from VexPro, but Andymark has those items in stock.

weberr 07-05-2014 13:18

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
You can get hex stock from Speedymetals.com

cadandcookies 07-05-2014 13:27

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jimmy Nichols (Post 1383506)
Not to steer you away from VexPro, but Andymark has those items in stock.

... But they aren't anodized black for performance! :P

geomapguy 07-05-2014 13:37

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by weberr (Post 1383507)
You can get hex stock from Speedymetals.com

what's the best variant to get from there???

Chris Endres 07-05-2014 13:45

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
You can also get hex stock from McMaster Carr. It is a little smaller on each side (-.002~). We used it this year and it works great and is honestly what we are going to use for now on. It does easily interact/work with VexPro/Andymark hex objects: hubs, collars, etc.

MechEng83 07-05-2014 13:54

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris Endres (Post 1383528)
You can also get hex stock from McMaster Carr. It is a little smaller on each side (-.002~). We used it this year and it works great and is honestly what we are going to use for now on. It does easily interact/work with VexPro/Andymark hex objects: hubs, collars, etc.

Our experience was less than excellent using the 6061 1/2" hex from McMaster this year. It was as much as 0.005" over in some places, making it nearly impossible to install into the hex bearings and some of the hex collars. We did find the 2024 aluminum hex to be slightly undersized and work perfectly for us. It's significantly more expensive, but we didn't mind the extra strength it provided.

Jimmy Nichols 07-05-2014 14:43

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MechEng83 (Post 1383531)
Our experience was less than excellent using the 6061 1/2" hex from McMaster this year. It was as much as 0.005" over in some places, making it nearly impossible to install into the hex bearings and some of the hex collars. We did find the 2024 aluminum hex to be slightly undersized and work perfectly for us. It's significantly more expensive, but we didn't mind the extra strength it provided.

We also used the 2024 High Strength AL from McMaster and had no issues with it fitting the AM Hex collars or bearings.

We ordered it in a 5 foot stick to save some cost.

Grant Cox 07-05-2014 16:33

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Richard Wallace (Post 1383504)
One of those projects needs some 1/2" hex shaft and bearings. Can someone from VexPro or therobotspace or WCP please advise when these will be back in stock?

Unfortunately, both the 1/2" Hex Shaft and associated 1/2" Hex Bearings will not be back in stock until late summer, potentially early fall. I would keep an eye out when they come back, though.. we're constantly reviewing product applications in FRC and beyond, finding ways to make our products even more useful for teams.

For what it's worth, Aren's replacement 1/2" hex shaft of choice comes from OnlineMetals.com. Of course, this recommendation comes with the expected disclaimer - not officially endorsed by VEXpro, not guaranteed to be 100% compatible, etc.

Chris Endres 07-05-2014 18:02

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MechEng83 (Post 1383531)
Our experience was less than excellent using the 6061 1/2" hex from McMaster this year. It was as much as 0.005" over in some places, making it nearly impossible to install into the hex bearings and some of the hex collars. We did find the 2024 aluminum hex to be slightly undersized and work perfectly for us. It's significantly more expensive, but we didn't mind the extra strength it provided.

We used the steel, not the aluminum, forgot to mention that.

ehochstein 07-05-2014 19:05

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Grant Cox (Post 1383586)
For what it's worth, Aren's replacement 1/2" hex shaft of choice comes from OnlineMetals.com. Of course, this recommendation comes with the expected disclaimer - not officially endorsed by VEXpro, not guaranteed to be 100% compatible, etc.

Andymark sells it for much cheaper than onlinemetals.com. $20 for six feet and $5 for a foot.

ThunderousPrime 07-05-2014 19:13

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by MechEng83 (Post 1383531)
Our experience was less than excellent using the 6061 1/2" hex from McMaster this year. It was as much as 0.005" over in some places, making it nearly impossible to install into the hex bearings and some of the hex collars. We did find the 2024 aluminum hex to be slightly undersized and work perfectly for us. It's significantly more expensive, but we didn't mind the extra strength it provided.

I spoke with 846 team members who also explicitly recommended Vexpro Hex stock over McMaster Carr. They said that the tolerances were off/not precise enough as well.

Racer26 08-05-2014 14:42

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
IIRC, the fitment issues are because the McMaster stuff is toleranced to +/- 0.005", while the VexPro stuff is toleranced to -0.005/+0.000.

MechEng83 08-05-2014 14:55

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Racer26 (Post 1383848)
IIRC, the fitment issues are because the McMaster stuff is toleranced to +/- 0.005", while the VexPro stuff is toleranced to -0.005/+0.000.

Yes. I completely agree that having something with a +0.000 tolerance would be better. That doesn't get my robot built if I'm on a deadline. You take what's available and modify as necessary to achieve your objective. McMaster is generally always available.

Mk.32 08-05-2014 15:00

Re: VexPro still out of stock?
 
You could always machine your own ;)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 10:24.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi