Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   CAD (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=168)
-   -   CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=131067)

HelloRobot 07-11-2014 18:36

CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Hello everyone!

I'm co-captain of a rookie team, and we are looking for CAD software to use this season to design our robot and parts. Our school is lucky enough to have MacBook Pros for every student, so, ideally, we want whatever CAD software we use to be able to run on Macs.

Right now, our team members can get Autodesk Inventor Pro from their website, but that does not run on Macs. We put Inventor Pro on a few Windows computers the school owns, but they sometimes take a while to load, so it's not really reliable. In addition, not a lot of our members have their own Windows PC to take to robotics meetings.

Bottom line is CAD software for Macs would be optimal for us. So, if anyone has any suggestions, we would greatly appreciate it! Thank you! :)

adammiller3122 07-11-2014 18:55

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
We use AutoCAD.

AustinSchuh 07-11-2014 19:05

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Sorry to break it to you, but most, if not all, pieces of mechanical CAD software run only on Windows. You might find some tools which run on a Mac or Linux, but all the good ones (Solidworks, Inventor, Pro/E, ...) only run on Windows. I don't personally know of any big projects designed in AutoCAD. The constraint based systems in Solidworks and crew let you do amazing things that you can't do in AutoCAD, or are much harder.

My recommendation would be to spend the time to figure out how to either dual-boot or run it in a VM. That way, when you graduate, you will already have some good experience with one of the industry standard tools that is directly applicable.

z_beeblebrox 07-11-2014 19:22

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
I dual boot Windows 7 on my 13" Retina MacBook Pro using the built-in utility Bootcamp and have had no problem with SolidWorks. If you can dual boot Windows, I'd strongly recommend it.

Michael Hill 07-11-2014 20:33

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AustinSchuh (Post 1407836)
Sorry to break it to you, but most, if not all, pieces of mechanical CAD software run only on Windows. You might find some tools which run on a Mac or Linux, but all the good ones (Solidworks, Inventor, Pro/E, ...) only run on Windows. I don't personally know of any big projects designed in AutoCAD. The constraint based systems in Solidworks and crew let you do amazing things that you can't do in AutoCAD, or are much harder.

My recommendation would be to spend the time to figure out how to either dual-boot or run it in a VM. That way, when you graduate, you will already have some good experience with one of the industry standard tools that is directly applicable.

Don't forget NX/UniGraphics. It runs on a Mac just fine. It's, of course, Apple's MCAD software of choice (judging from job postings)

sanddrag 07-11-2014 22:45

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Inventor Fusion is probably the best you'll be able to do Mac. My opinion, school should have bought PCs. Common mistake by schools. Anyhow, since past is past, now they can pay for it again, buy buying Windows to run on the Macs.

CodeWhisperer 06-01-2015 12:49

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
I think your team should 100% look into Autodesk Fusion 360 because it runs on both Mac and Windows computers. Additionally, it differs from typical CAD programs in that, while the client resides on your computer, all of the files, designs, drawings, etc. are kept in the cloud in your Autodesk account. What's more, you can invite team members to your project to collaborate on design. The toolkit is very reminiscent of Autodesk Inventor, with some added tools such as form (which allows you to make more organic-looking objects and is useful for sculpting or modeling) and even MILLING. That's right, if your team uses any type of CNC manufacturing, including 3D printing, all of the toolpathing can be done naively in Fusion.

The fact that it runs on Mac and PC is great for our team because we have some students with Mac computers at home but they are still able to contribute to the project due to the cloud-management nature of Fusion. 10/10 would recommend!

jgerstein 08-01-2015 10:02

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Thirding Fusion 360. Collaboration is easy, and I really like the built-in CAM tools. I've tested out the CAM at home on a Shapeoko, and it's easy to work with and does a good job.

seamushroom 01-02-2015 16:04

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Hey there! I wanted to point out that you still may be able to use windows only CAD software for free. Right now the windows 10 beta is still free (and will be till next fall). You can boot camp windows ten onto your mac book pro's and use some software like Solidworks or Autodesk Inventor. It's going to be extremely hard on the computers, especially with the rather large assemblies that you can end up having with robots, but it should be manageable, especially with tools like large assembly mode on SW. I'm not sure of your schools opinion on using Boot camp, but I think that they will understand the need to do it for the team if you ask.

--Seamus

Chris_Ely 01-02-2015 16:17

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by seamushroom (Post 1437024)
Hey there! I wanted to point out that you still may be able to use windows only CAD software for free. Right now the windows 10 beta is still free (and will be till next fall). You can boot camp windows ten onto your mac book pro's and use some software like Solidworks or Autodesk Inventor. It's going to be extremely hard on the computers, especially with the rather large assemblies that you can end up having with robots, but it should be manageable, especially with tools like large assembly mode on SW. I'm not sure of your schools opinion on using Boot camp, but I think that they will understand the need to do it for the team if you ask.

--Seamus

I would recommend that you don't use the Windows 10 Technical Preview. In may be free, but it is not even close to being a finished OS; it is more like an alpha than beta. Your CAD software might not work well, you might experience crashes, and general instability.

TheModMaster8 03-05-2015 23:40

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
You could try Google SketchUp.

cadandcookies 04-05-2015 00:19

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by TheModMaster8 (Post 1479752)
You could try Google SketchUp.

If you genuinely have no other option-- you don't have the expertise necessary to learn a real CAD program in time, your computers can only run that, or whatever, then this might be worth considering. But since you're just coming off a season, now is the perfect time to plan to use CAD for the coming season, including finding the resources to get a proper MCAD program. SketchUp is fine for quickly laying out ideas or space diagrams, but it doesn't play nice with anything. Start the job the right way with Creo or Solidworks or Inventor or Solid Edge (thought preferably one of the first two). You'll save yourselves the headache later.

BryceKarlins 06-05-2015 18:03

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by HelloRobot (Post 1407828)
Our school is lucky enough to have MacBook Pros for every student...

Doesn't sound like a very "RATCHET" team to me!:p

ouellet348 11-05-2015 14:20

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Your best bet is going to be running windows via bootcamp. No legitimate and easily accessible CAD software for FIRST use runs on a Mac natively yet.

xman206 11-05-2015 17:49

Re: CAD programs for Macs - Suggestions, anyone?
 
Try Autodesk Inventor


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 23:03.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi