Chief Delphi - Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)

- Technical Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=22)

- - Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=132306)

TheZorcane

07-01-2015 05:13

Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

Hey all :)
Our team considering omni wheels for this year. We saw that andymark sales them for $100 ( http://www.andymark.com/product-p/am-0432.htm ) while vex sales them for only $25 ( http://www.vexrobotics.com/vexpro/mo...ni-wheels.html ).

Does anyone know why the prices are so different? Do vex-wheels break or have any other problem?

Thanks ahead!
The Spikes #2212

RockedShots

07-01-2015 07:21

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

The andymark wheels are sold in sets of four. The price is actually really close

Mike Marandola

07-01-2015 07:37

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

Quote:

Originally Posted by RockedShots (Post 1423421)

The andymark wheels are sold in sets of four. The price is actually really close

It's only one wheel. Take a look at the included hardware list.

JesseK

07-01-2015 07:59

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

AndyMark is Aluminum, VEX is Plastic. There are big differences in the load rating.

Quote:

Originally Posted by VEX Pro

Load Rating: Conservatively rated for use on 200 lb robots

- I read this to be 50lbs per wheel set since it is worded in terms of an entire robot which typically has 4 wheels on the ground.

Quote:

Originally Posted by AndyMark

Load Capacity: 120 Pounds (rollers don't spin past this weight)

Therefore it really depends on weight distribution - if the side which will carry 4 totes at once has the omni wheels, you're probably better of with the AndyMark wheels.

Paul Copioli

07-01-2015 08:04

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

Quote:

Originally Posted by JesseK (Post 1423433)

Therefore it really depends on weight distribution - if the side which will carry 4 totes at once has the omni wheels, you're probably better of with the AndyMark wheels.

This is not true.

The VEXpro omni wheels will handle this load with no problem.

JesseK

07-01-2015 08:14

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Copioli (Post 1423435)

This is not true.

The VEXpro omni wheels with handle this load with no problem.

I guess I don't understand why the VEX Pro omni wheel load rating doesn't have an outright number then? We're trying to make this very decision, and the omni rollers not rolling isn't an option with our planned setup.

RandomStyuff

07-01-2015 18:50

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

Paul (or anyone else at VEX),
Do you have ratings for a single omni wheel? It says on the website that they are rated for usage on a 200 lbs robot. How many wheels would that be spread on?

For other teams, have you had failures with VEX Pro Omni wheels? If so, can you post pictures or descriptions of the failure and if you have any, a theory to what caused it?

Jared

07-01-2015 21:16

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

Quote:

Originally Posted by Paul Copioli (Post 1423435)

This is not true.

The VEXpro omni wheels will handle this load with no problem.

This is a slightly unrelated question, but how would the 6" vex pro traction handle being directly under a full stack of totes (about 50-60 lbs per wheel)? Is this pushing the limits of what the wheel can hold?

Chief Hedgehog

07-01-2015 21:28

Re: Vex vs Andymark Omni wheels

We have used both in the past with no discernible differences. We will be using VEX this year.

All times are GMT -5. The time now is 14:03.