Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Extra Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   pic: 6 week swerve (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=133277)

lukedude43 21-01-2015 13:53

pic: 6 week swerve
 

Andrew Lawrence 21-01-2015 14:14

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Looks nice. How much pre-season testing have you done?

orangemoore 21-01-2015 14:27

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew Lawrence (Post 1431602)
Looks nice. How much pre-season testing have you done?

If you read what it says it sounds very much like they have no experience.

lukedude43 21-01-2015 14:28

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
None, programmer made some swerve code for fun and I had been toying around with the idea in the offseason but everything was started fresh on everything when the season started

Andrew Lawrence 21-01-2015 14:35

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Out of curiosity (if you don't mind me asking) - what was the thought process behind deciding to choose swerve for the first time in-season this year?

Spoiler for I want everyone moving this season:
Do you wanna build a swerve drive?
That doesn’t move at all
I know that tank drive is a bore
But you won’t score
Stuck up against the wall
It’s best to test pre-season
But you did not
So please ask your-self why!
Do you need to build a swerve drive?
It’s not too late to not do swerve drive.
(please just drive...)

AustinH 21-01-2015 14:36

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
I wonder if the game this year is at all conducive to taking these sorts of risks. We've been able to spare some individual team members for tackling quite a few of these "don't try this during build season" projects. For some reason, it seems like a more favorable risk/reward scenario compared to previous years in case we don't end up checking off all the boxes.

Looking forward to seeing how this turns out for you guys!

Christopher149 21-01-2015 14:41

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew Lawrence (Post 1431620)
Out of curiosity (if you don't mind me asking) - what was the thought process behind deciding to choose swerve for the first time in-season this year?

Spoiler for I want everyone moving this season:
Do you wanna build a swerve drive?
That doesn’t move at all
I know that tank drive is a bore
But you won’t score
Stuck up against the wall
It’s best to test pre-season
But you did not
So please ask your-self why!
Do you need to build a swerve drive?
It’s not too late to not do swerve drive.
(please just drive...)

Sorry, but I can't resist:

Spoiler for more lyrics:

Luke, please, I know you're in there
People are asking how the drive has been
They say do tank drive
And I'm trying to
The design is right here for you
Let's just change it...
We only have this one 'bot
Just this one season
What are we going to do?
Do you wanna build a swerve drive?

lukedude43 21-01-2015 14:48

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew Lawrence (Post 1431620)
Out of curiosity (if you don't mind me asking) - what was the thought process behind deciding to choose swerve for the first time in-season this year?

Spoiler for I want everyone moving this season:
Do you wanna build a swerve drive?
That doesn’t move at all
I know that tank drive is a bore
But you won’t score
Stuck up against the wall
It’s best to test pre-season
But you did not
So please ask your-self why!
Do you need to build a swerve drive?
It’s not too late to not do swerve drive.
(please just drive...)

Like a lot of other people we thought omnidirectional drive would be useful, swerve was best for our method of dropping off stacks of totes, and we honestly just thought it would be fun.

Navid Shafa 21-01-2015 14:55

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Christopher149 (Post 1431626)
Sorry, but I can't resist:

Spoiler for more lyrics:

Luke, please, I know you're in there
People are asking how the drive has been
They say do tank drive
And I'm trying to
The design is right here for you
Let's just change it...
We only have this one 'bot
Just this one season
What are we going to do?
Do you wanna build a swerve drive?


*Looks good Luke, we've got 4030 on our Fantasy FIRST alliance so I'm really hoping you pull it off ;)

lukedude43 21-01-2015 14:55

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Christopher149 (Post 1431626)
Sorry, but I can't resist:

Spoiler for more lyrics:

Luke, please, I know you're in there
People are asking how the drive has been
They say do tank drive
And I'm trying to
The design is right here for you
Let's just change it...
We only have this one 'bot
Just this one season
What are we going to do?
Do you wanna build a swerve drive?

Haha this is beautiful

Something important I forgot to mention is that we have a set day in week 4 where we will consider if we have actually made it to a point where we think our swerve gives us any benefit over a traditional tank drive. When subsystem integration is fully cadded it will include a fully fledged tank drive configuration so if we decide to ditch swerve we should be able to have a running tank a few days later.

asid61 21-01-2015 15:49

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
If that bottom is a single piece, you will want to add a radius on the inner edges on the top.
How thick is the bottom plate? It looks pretty thin right now.
How are you constrianing the bevel gears on that shaft? How are you constraining the other gears?
Your top plates are too thin. It looks like it's 1/8" at most. Make it 1/4" to be really safe.
I LOL'd at that gear on the top. I assume that's a versakey gear with 3/8" hex bore like I ised on my drill press verson.
You need some thrust bearings on the module to support the vertical loads. This year more than ever it's going to be turning under a lot of load.

All things considered I would not do a swerve drive fresh out of the box. Please consider buying something like a premade team 221 revolution module and just belting some motors to it.

lukedude43 21-01-2015 16:14

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by asid61 (Post 1431677)
If that bottom is a single piece, you will want to add a radius on the inner edges on the top.
How thick is the bottom plate? It looks pretty thin right now.
How are you constrianing the bevel gears on that shaft? How are you constraining the other gears?
Your top plates are too thin. It looks like it's 1/8" at most. Make it 1/4" to be really safe.
I LOL'd at that gear on the top. I assume that's a versakey gear with 3/8" hex bore like I ised on my drill press verson.
You need some thrust bearings on the module to support the vertical loads. This year more than ever it's going to be turning under a lot of load.

All things considered I would not do a swerve drive fresh out of the box. Please consider buying something like a premade team 221 revolution module and just belting some motors to it.

Probably should have posted cad cause it would clear up a lot of your questions/considerations but my naming on some parts is embarrassingly bad (I blame sleep deprivation) but this should definitely help http://imgur.com/QfTX6i1

The bottom is being milled out of a single piece of 4x6x.25" 6061 channel

the plates are .125, but this is designed to use the chassis to beef up the outer edges and the gray squares are actually bearing blocks holding 1" ID 2"OD bearings. these are bolted straight through, counterbored on the top bearing block, with nut clearance on the bottom. We think this should be fine for preventing the plates from warping.

I didnt see your drill press swerve but yea it's a 3/8 bore 44 tooth versakey gear. Great minds think alike (and fools seldom differ)

there is a 1" ID thrust bearing and accompanying washers in there.

nathannfm 21-01-2015 23:29

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Put your module into the CAD of the field right at the transition between the carpet and the scoring platform. Rotate the module as it would if the steering motor was rotating it, will that low ground clearance gear run into the ramp in any orientation? Looks to me like it will.

lukedude43 22-01-2015 02:33

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nathannfm (Post 1431936)
Put your module into the CAD of the field right at the transition between the carpet and the scoring platform. Rotate the module as it would if the steering motor was rotating it, will that low ground clearance gear run into the ramp in any orientation? Looks to me like it will.

Thank you for pointing that out, just updated to fix it http://imgur.com/eowq8F1

asid61 22-01-2015 02:36

Re: pic: 6 week swerve
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nathannfm (Post 1431936)
Put your module into the CAD of the field right at the transition between the carpet and the scoring platform. Rotate the module as it would if the steering motor was rotating it, will that low ground clearance gear run into the ramp in any orientation? Looks to me like it will.

As long as the wheel is bigger than the gear, it should be hard for it to crash unless the whole robot tips.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 11:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi