Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

In the 2015 timed autonomous tutorial, found here: https://decibel.ni.com/content/docs/DOC-26295 NI uses wait loops to instruct the drive motors. My mentor who worked with me during build season is no longer coming to meetings, but he instructed me to NEVER use these because they're CPU hogs. The thought is giving me anxiety.

Is this the correct way? Is there an alternative?

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

They can be CPU hogs if used incorrectly.
The Wait call inside each one throttles the loop down and avoids sucking the life out of the CPU. So never use a While loop without a Wait.

So that example works as long as you make sure to use Waits.

There are several alternative styles that avoid the use of loops altogether, but Waits are still required to get your timing down.
Here is one alternative using a Flat Sequence Structure: http://www.team358.org/files/program...php#Autonomous

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

Well my question would be is what if your moving a motor and you want to stop it at a limit switch, how would you go about doing so without a while loop?

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

Loops are used/required a couple of places, such as Robot Main and Periodic Tasks.vi
User programs loop to keep working and checking for driver packets, changes of robot state (Disabled/Enabled/Teleop/Autonomous), etc.

If you have to check constantly to see if a limit switch is reached then a loop can be used (just always throttle it with a Wait). If the operation is commonly used both for Teleop and for Autonomous, then a loop in Periodic Tasks might be a better location for it.

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

Attach the limit switch to your motor controller. The motor controller firmware will stop the motor.

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

How would you go about putting the limit switch to the motor controller. I'm not exactly sure what you mean

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

I think...our limit switches are in DIO 6 and 7 on out bot. So instead plug it in to the motor controller? I think it would be on a breakout board like this for the Talon SRX: http://www.chiefdelphi.com/media/img...ee71979d_l.jpg

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

For the talon srx and jaguar you are able to use a limit switch and put embedded code to stop the motor when the limit switch is pressed. If you do not possess these motor controllers. You probably want to use a condition in your while loop to state that if the limit switch is pressed to stop the loop.

Re: Timing Autonomous with While Loops?
 

Talon SRX User's Guide; see pages 19 & 20:
http://www.crosstheroadelectronics.c...7s%20Guide.pdf

Jaguar Getting Started Guide; see pages 7 9 10 13 14 22
http://team358.org/files/electrical/MDL-BDC24_GSG.pdf