Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=135518)

Boltman 07-03-2015 11:35

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
1114 (Fastest LF processor so far) + Fastest RC wall grabber (With HP load ability ideally) + Fastest RC+N topper

Sparkyshires 07-03-2015 14:26

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
1114, 148 and 610. 610 gets all the bins in autonomous, and the others make max stacks. That would be beyond OP.

BrennanB 07-03-2015 18:00

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by asid61 (Post 1454621)
1114 will hopefully add a 2-can auton, as it's quite simple and easy to add.

They have a can grabber.

Lil' Lavery 07-03-2015 18:46

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by artK (Post 1454675)
I would have to disagree with this claim. According to the Blue Alliance's charts, the average score for Championship elims approximately doubles the average elims scores during week 1 (The largest ratio between the two was about 2.5 in 2010).

This year, week 1 elims average scores were about 80. By the above estimate, the average elims scores at champs would be about 160. There is little doubt that we will see 200s on the scoreboards during elims at champs, but I would be hesitant to say that 200 will be fairly common.

This raises another interesting point. How will the increased quantity of elimination alliances/participants impact the average scores at Champs? Common sense says it would further dilute the talent, however this game is quite different.

asid61 07-03-2015 21:18

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrennanB (Post 1454824)
They have a can grabber.

I can see it. However, so far it looks pretty slow and has to be positioned manually due to their 3-tote auton.

magnets 07-03-2015 21:20

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by asid61 (Post 1454621)
I think that a 0.25 second 2-can grab by two robots will be very important on einstein. 4-can autons may not be able to compete in speed.

This seems to be an accepted fact from many users, but I'm not convinced. A single team which can grab 4 containers as quickly as any other grabber would be hugely desirable, so teams are going to make robots that can get 4 very quickly.

asid61 07-03-2015 21:34

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by magnets (Post 1454903)
This seems to be an accepted fact from many users, but I'm not convinced. A single team which can grab 4 containers as quickly as any other grabber would be hugely desirable, so teams are going to make robots that can get 4 very quickly.

I agree, a 4-can is better than a 2-can. The main issue is that you have to reach from the center of the field to the edges of it. This leaves you three options:
-Swing your arm out in autonomous
-Swing your arm out during the 60s setup time and retract them later
-Swing your arm out during setup an dnever retract it.
The first option is inherently slow; you would have to devote way too many resources to ensure that the 4-can grab is faster than the opponent's 2-can.
The second option is better, but the sheer weight of the assembly, plus the setup time could make it too slow or unreliable.
The last option can be light, as it does not need any type of retraction mechanism. However, it guarentees that you can't effectively play the game anymore.
I think it's possible, but it is much harder than just dropping two 72" rods down to grab if you want to match speed. And you would have to be faster than any two-can.

Lil' Lavery 07-03-2015 22:24

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
That post has an awful lot of assumptions in it. Assumptions that may not end up being true.

Gweiss96 08-03-2015 00:04

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
254, 148, 1114

asid61 08-03-2015 01:20

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lil' Lavery (Post 1454932)
That post has an awful lot of assumptions in it. Assumptions that may not end up being true.

Just what I've seen. If you have a good idea for a super-fast four can auton I would love to know.

Gregor 08-03-2015 10:44

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by asid61 (Post 1454900)
I can see it. However, so far it looks pretty slow and has to be positioned manually due to their 3-tote auton.

What if I told you they didn't run their 3 tote auto every match?

wilderbuchanan 08-03-2015 14:36

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
I wonder though, with Champs going from 4 to 8 divisions, will a "power house" alliance emerge if the best teams are spread out. I think this will make it so there will not be an obvious Einstein winner.

themccannman 08-03-2015 14:46

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by magnets (Post 1454903)
This seems to be an accepted fact from many users, but I'm not convinced. A single team which can grab 4 containers as quickly as any other grabber would be hugely desirable, so teams are going to make robots that can get 4 very quickly.

Inertia is a thing, 2 is always faster, and 1 is even faster than 2, but there's a very specific reason 1 isn't advantageous, I will leave this as an exercise to the reader.

I'm also very surprises no one has pointed out the most obvious alliance, 2056, 2056, and 2056 is clearly the most OP.

The other Gabe 08-03-2015 17:59

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
In my opinion, an alliance of 1114, 148 and 118 would create the most terrifyingly high scores possible. however, I feel like 148 would actually get in the way of the other two robots, being part of team tether. because of this, I would instead pick team 4488, whose ability to make 2 stacks of 6 with noodle in a container is comparable to these other teams, while taking up far less field space than some of the other great robots

Chris is me 08-03-2015 18:03

Re: Which 3 robots would form the most overpowered alliance?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by The other Gabe (Post 1455145)
In my opinion, an alliance of 1114, 148 and 118 would create the most terrifyingly high scores possible. however, I feel like 148 would actually get in the way of the other two robots, being part of team tether. because of this, I would instead pick team 4488, whose ability to make 2 stacks of 6 with noodle in a container is comparable to these other teams, while taking up far less field space than some of the other great robots

That's giving up an entire stack of totes and can, at least, compared to 148's best performances. If 148 sticks to the left edge of the field, the center and right sides of the field can be open for 1114 and 118 to play in. 148 doesn't need to move too much other than to their loader, can holder, and the goal, so I feel they can keep their tether manageable.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 18:21.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi