Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Video of 1114 (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=135572)

Joe G. 10-03-2015 20:40

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Kevin Sevcik (Post 1456233)
Well 18 frames is about how long a gravity drop from 78" should take, so I guess I must've missed some of the slower acceleration at the beginning. And/or it's not dropping a full 78".

It definitely doesn't drop the full 78". The claw's resting point is well above the height of a single tote -- the RC gets pushed upwards in the claw by the totes below it.

Aidan H. 10-03-2015 21:12

Re: Video of 1114
 
After some digging, I was able to actually get a pretty good understanding of their passive (-ish) lift. It seems like there is no vertical actuation of the tall lift at all that is only for the bin holder (it can go up by itself). It looks like there is actually some surgical tubing passively pulling the bin holder down (easily seen at ~30 sec in video), so that it can't "bounce" off the top of the stack while one is being made or when the stack is jiggling around. Also, when 1114 grabs a can, they have to first lift it to the height of 1 tote, which is actually done with the use of their normal "tote lifters" pushing their can grabber up while it is holding a can (at ~25 sec, little spinner is rotating to confirm the "tote lift" being run). It is not clear, at least from the video I can find, how the can grabber is kept at the 1 tote height after being lifted there, but there is a chance that there is a passive 1-way latch mechanism that locks it to (/above) that 1 tote height when the bin grabber is closed (dual use mechanism, can clamp on bins, and engage lift latch). The can grabber can drop all the way to the bottom and miss the latch because the can grabber is always open when it drops to the bottom, and (I presume) was designed to miss the locking level when the grabber was in the open state.
This is all just speculation as to what might be at work behind that beautiful red powdercoat, and it will probably be thoroughly explained when they post their robot poster for SideSwipe.

I am absolutely astounded by the complexity and simplicity that went into this robot, and the level of foresight that was paid to how this game would play out. Intaking fast and being able to sturdily handle a full stack seemed to have been top priorities for 1114, and they were definitely able to achieve them.

Here's the video that I referenced up there (Quarters 8): 2015 - Greater Toronto Central Regional - Quarter Final - 8
(watch in HD for a better view)

mman1506 10-03-2015 21:20

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Aidan H. (Post 1456241)
It looks like there is actually some surgical tubing passively pulling the bin holder down (easily seen at ~30 sec in video), so that it can't "bounce" off the top of the stack while one is being made or when the stack is jiggling around

That is just spiral pneumatic tubing that connects to the pneumatic actuator on the bin grabber.

Aidan H. 10-03-2015 21:34

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by mman1506 (Post 1456243)
That is just spiral pneumatic tubing that connects to the pneumatic actuator on the bin grabber.

It actually seems like it might have been some surgical tubing that was tied on at a later time in the competition, as it seems to be absent at ~37 sec in this video (Qual 30), but was there in at least their 2nd quarter final (QF8 at ~30 sec).
If it isn't spiral pneumatic tubing, I don't know where their pneumatics would be run through as I can't spot them (yet).

Mike Marandola 10-03-2015 21:50

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Aidan H. (Post 1456252)
It actually seems like it might have been some surgical tubing that was tied on at a later time in the competition, as it seems to be absent at ~37 sec in this video (Qual 30), but was there in at least their 2nd quarter final (QF8 at ~30 sec).
If it isn't spiral pneumatic tubing, I don't know where their pneumatics would be run through as I can't spot them (yet).



I am pretty sure what you believe to be surgical tubing is actually the spiral air tubing. If there was surgical tubing stretched that distance, it would drop much faster. I think the cylinder is visible in the picture as well.

FIRST_Parent 10-03-2015 21:58

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bochek (Post 1456202)


Thanks Bochek for these video's. Much appreciated. :) :)

Aidan H. 10-03-2015 22:02

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mike Marandola (Post 1456261)
I am pretty sure what you believe to be surgical tubing is actually the spiral tubing. If there was surgical tubing stretched that distance, it would drop much faster. I think the cylinder is visible in the picture as well.

Yeah, you're right. Sorry about that. I guess the video just is pretty hard to see clearly enough.
On that note, does anyone have some close-up photos of any mechanisms?
Though in the future, I wouldn't be surprised to see something like a constant force spring pulling the lift down, as it definitely seems advantageous to have downward pressure on the stack (but gravity is probably enough). It also might just not matter; it's working perfectly as it is.

118418 10-03-2015 22:08

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Aidan H. (Post 1456241)
After some digging, I was able to actually get a pretty good understanding of their passive (-ish) lift. It seems like there is no vertical actuation of the tall lift at all that is only for the bin holder (it can go up by itself). It looks like there is actually some surgical tubing passively pulling the bin holder down (easily seen at ~30 sec in video), so that it can't "bounce" off the top of the stack while one is being made or when the stack is jiggling around. Also, when 1114 grabs a can, they have to first lift it to the height of 1 tote, which is actually done with the use of their normal "tote lifters" pushing their can grabber up while it is holding a can (at ~25 sec, little spinner is rotating to confirm the "tote lift" being run). It is not clear, at least from the video I can find, how the can grabber is kept at the 1 tote height after being lifted there, but there is a chance that there is a passive 1-way latch mechanism that locks it to (/above) that 1 tote height when the bin grabber is closed (dual use mechanism, can clamp on bins, and engage lift latch). The can grabber can drop all the way to the bottom and miss the latch because the can grabber is always open when it drops to the bottom, and (I presume) was designed to miss the locking level when the grabber was in the open state.
This is all just speculation as to what might be at work behind that beautiful red powdercoat, and it will probably be thoroughly explained when they post their robot poster for SideSwipe.

I am absolutely astounded by the complexity and simplicity that went into this robot, and the level of foresight that was paid to how this game would play out. Intaking fast and being able to sturdily handle a full stack seemed to have been top priorities for 1114, and they were definitely able to achieve them.

Here's the video that I referenced up there (Quarters 8): 2015 - Greater Toronto Central Regional - Quarter Final - 8
(watch in HD for a better view)

For the RC flip, it looks like they have a low arm (2"-4" high from the ground) that comes out and pushes on (or holds) the lower rim of the RC bottom, while the intake wheels pull the RC in. This creates a torque for the RC to rotate up. Look at ~63 sec of the game clock. The low push arm that comes out is not colored.

Tyler2517 10-03-2015 22:13

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 118418 (Post 1456271)
For the RC flip, it looks like they have a low arm (2"-4" high from the ground) that comes out and pushes on (or holds) the lower rim of the RC bottom, while the intake wheels pull the RC in. This creates a torque for the RC to rotate up. Look at ~63 sec of the game clock. The low push arm that comes out is not colored.

Wow so much attention to detail every part of the stacking process is automated down to the second.... That is such a small detail but is super effective

118418 10-03-2015 22:14

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 118418 (Post 1456271)
For the RC flip, it looks like they have a low arm (2"-4" high from the ground) that comes out and pushes on (or holds) the lower rim of the RC bottom, while the intake wheels pull the RC in. This creates a torque for the RC to rotate up. Look at ~63 sec of the game clock. The low push arm that comes out is not colored.

Here is a picture of the push/hold arm, posted in the GTRC thread by EddtG or #1285. You can see it clearly here.

https://www.facebook.com/FIRSTRoboti...type=3&theater

Zentx 11-03-2015 02:10

Re: Video of 1114
 
Here is a closer look at 1114 from the side, including AUTONOMOUS !

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=r7-NigYFrWo

DonShaw 11-03-2015 07:11

Re: Video of 1114
 
If you watch the video a long black like antennae comes well above the legal height limit. The rule states at no time can a robot exceed 78" during the match and if it does its gets disabled and DQ'd.

It does not allow for a mechanical breakdown or malfunction. It is one of the simplest rules they have with no grey area.

This is in the first video posted on this thread.

Aren Siekmeier 11-03-2015 07:38

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DonShaw (Post 1456368)
If you watch the video a long black like antennae comes well above the legal height limit. The rule states at no time can a robot exceed 78" during the match and if it does its gets disabled and DQ'd.

It does not allow for a mechanical breakdown or malfunction. It is one of the simplest rules they have with no grey area.

This is in the first video posted on this thread.

http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/sh...4&postcount=14

JesseK 11-03-2015 09:21

Re: Video of 1114
 
From this thread I have learned that the Simbots will never ally with the Poofs.

Otherwise they'll have to make a movie about what happens when Transformers and Decepticons get along, and that would be quite boring.

Batterink 11-03-2015 09:39

Re: Video of 1114
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JesseK (Post 1456405)
From this thread I have learned that the Simbots will never ally with the Poofs.

Otherwise they'll have to make a movie about what happens when Transformers and Decepticons get along, and that would be quite boring.

Political thriller


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 05:16.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi