Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Championship Event (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   How many recycling containers are going to die this week? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=136799)

autox_vette 20-04-2015 14:56

How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
With all of the can grabbers that are being developed for champs and some of the power levels being tossed around in attempts to shave milliseconds, I think there are going to be many recycling containers destroyed at champs.

So, how many do you think will be destroyed over the 3 days?

I'll start it at 65

mlantry 20-04-2015 14:57

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
my guess will be 26

Koko Ed 20-04-2015 14:57

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
I haven't seen one destroyed this year.
I've heard of one being taken away and never heard of again at GTCR when a cleaner mistook it for one of their cans (their's were blue).

marshall 20-04-2015 15:03

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Koko Ed (Post 1474131)
I haven't seen one destroyed this year.
I've heard of one being taken away and never heard of again at GTCR when a cleaner mistook it for one of their cans (their's were blue).

I mean... no joke but we thought about throwing them... we thought it would have been appropriate for us given our robot from last year:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WqHk50xX1_A

And yes, the code does exist to throw them... though it has been safely hidden away.

billbo911 20-04-2015 15:11

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Citrus Circuits has already proven they can bust an RC lid. So, with that in mind, 600 teams, 8 divisions..... I'm guessing we will see 24 RC's sent to an early retirement.

Koko Ed 20-04-2015 15:21

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
I say no more than a few.

Tim Sharp 20-04-2015 15:32

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
I thinking with newly minted and untested canburgulars on many machines, the potential for can (and robot) carnage is definitely elevated.

Shrub 20-04-2015 15:43

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Poor cans are pretty beat up already. I'm guessing in the 10s max.

Noodles, about 30 per division (I saw about 20 dead noodles/regional max). Especially mechanum-heavy divisions.

MooreteP 20-04-2015 15:47

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Will they be recycled?

Procolsaurus 20-04-2015 15:50

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
5 or less. You might pop the top off but that's just 2 zip ties to replace. I have not heard of an actual failure of the cans at all.

pastelpony 20-04-2015 15:55

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
I wouldn't imagine the cans taking much damage. Some canburglar mechanisms might render a few unusable, though only maybe 3 or 4. Noodles, on the other hand...there might be a few packs of those lost.

nikeairmancurry 20-04-2015 16:00

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Less than 5. Ive seen 1000 matches live this year and even the most lengthy battles only end in penalties.

Seen a few popped tops though.

asid61 20-04-2015 16:00

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
I have a bet running with a teammate on at least 1.

Dominick Ferone 20-04-2015 16:14

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
If anyone is going to destroy a can, I'd put my money on 340. They grip the can so tight it is sometimes still indented when they let go. It also hurt them once at FLR.

GeeTwo 20-04-2015 16:23

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Looking at the mechanisms for rapid tote-grabbing, I'd guess that there will be no fatally damaged cans all weekend. I also guess five fatally damaged lids before Einstein, and another five on Einstein.

There will be many more lids separated from the cans which can be restored to service with new tie wraps and perhaps a half second with a drill.

I also expect at least one "spectacular G18" where a robot is dragged mostly or completely across the step. This seems most likely to happen when two grabbers engage with each other rather than being transitive through an RC.

avanboekel 13-05-2015 23:10

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Were there any recycling containers removed from play at champs? I don't remember seeing any.

Koko Ed 13-05-2015 23:19

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by avanboekel (Post 1481982)
Were there any recycling containers removed from play at champs? I don't remember seeing any.

I didn't notice any. They're Rubbermaid cans. They're supposed to take abuse from garbage truck which are far far more rough than any FIRST robot could ever hope to be.
The only time we lost one was at GTCR to a cleaner who wasn't paying attention and took it away. Other than that they were fine for the most part.

Abhishek R 13-05-2015 23:25

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Koko Ed (Post 1481984)
I didn't notice any. They're Rubbermaid cans. They're supposed to take abuse from garbage truck which are far far more rough than any FIRST robot could ever hope to be.
The only time we lost one was at GTCR to a cleaner who wasn't paying attention and took it away. Other than that they were fine for the most part.

Do you know if any lids were ripped off the can?

MaGiC_PiKaChU 14-05-2015 06:46

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Abhishek R (Post 1481985)
Do you know if any lids were ripped off the can?

If they didn't rip off on einstein, with all the abusive can burglars there, i doubt it...

GreyingJay 14-05-2015 10:00

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeeTwo (Post 1474187)
I also expect at least one "spectacular G18" where a robot is dragged mostly or completely across the step. This seems most likely to happen when two grabbers engage with each other rather than being transitive through an RC.

We almost had this at Finals 2 on Einstein. If 118 hadn't let go...

Mschmeh144 14-05-2015 10:11

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
I don't expect any damage to the cans. I do expect damage to can burglars though, seeing as we have broken ours a few times.

GeeTwo 14-05-2015 19:16

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeeTwo (Post 1474187)
I also expect at least one "spectacular G18" where a robot is dragged mostly or completely across the step. This seems most likely to happen when two grabbers engage with each other rather than being transitive through an RC.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GreyingJay (Post 1482024)
We almost had this at Finals 2 on Einstein. If 118 hadn't let go...

I do recall seeing one fairly tall robot whose top was pulled across the step, into the airspace over the opposite landfill. However, it appeared to be above the landfill totes and did not (I believe) result in a G18 violation.

Not only did the canburgular wars not quite reach the fever pitch I anticipated, I do not recall alliances going after the inverted totes or totes on the step in an effort to get those last few points, which I sort of expected at the division finals and on Einstein.

Loose Screw 18-05-2015 07:48

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeeTwo (Post 1482141)
Not only did the canburgular wars not quite reach the fever pitch I anticipated, I do not recall alliances going after the inverted totes or totes on the step in an effort to get those last few points, which I sort of expected at the division finals and on Einstein.

I remember watching 2338 grab an inverted tote so they could use it to push the opposing pool noodles next to the step. A very smart move that helped them move on to the next round.

hannaners 18-05-2015 16:56

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GeeTwo (Post 1474187)
I also expect at least one "spectacular G18" where a robot is dragged mostly or completely across the step. This seems most likely to happen when two grabbers engage with each other rather than being transitive through an RC.

Quote:

Originally Posted by GreyingJay (Post 1482024)
We almost had this at Finals 2 on Einstein. If 118 hadn't let go...

Quote:

Originally Posted by GeeTwo (Post 1482141)
I do recall seeing one fairly tall robot whose top was pulled across the step, into the airspace over the opposite landfill. However, it appeared to be above the landfill totes and did not (I believe) result in a G18 violation.

There was a case of entanglement during Finals 2 of the Hopper sub-division. The tug of war between 987 Highrollers & 1218 Vulcan Robotics begins around 0:40 and continues for over a minute. The red alliance received a red card for a G18 violation.

Rman1923 21-05-2015 18:59

Re: How many recycling containers are going to die this week?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by marshall (Post 1474136)
I mean... no joke but we thought about throwing them... we thought it would have been appropriate for us given our robot from last year:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WqHk50xX1_A

And yes, the code does exist to throw them... though it has been safely hidden away.

This is actually an amazing thing. I want one.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 16:19.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi