Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Championship Event (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=12)
-   -   Freshman on Drive team (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=136933)

AWoL 27-04-2015 10:39

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
Our operator is an 8th grader, and other than that I'm (driver) a Sophomore and our human player is a senior.

Sperkowsky 27-04-2015 10:42

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fanny Z (Post 1476251)
We weren't at Champs this year but our driver and human player are freshmen, our operator is a grade 10, and our coach is a senior (Grade 12). Generally we don't change our driver every year, but we might be changing our human player next year to adapt to the game.

Your going to need to get a hp from the swim team

marshall 27-04-2015 10:46

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
One of 900's drivers is a freshman. She's awesome! She is going to be a force next year after her experience this year.

BrendanB 27-04-2015 11:02

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 346CADmen (Post 1476884)
Just curious how do you have an 8th grader on the team? Is he/she 14?

The team has always had an open policy to allowing younger students who have aged out of FLL the opportunity to come to join the FRC team as a Junior Member. Many teams have mentors with younger children who hang around the shop and help out and when the FLL teams at the Windham Middle School grew too large some of the older students who were ready for something more challenging could apply and spend time participating in FRC. The operator joined last year (2014) and this year is the lead student programmer. Its a great way to train up new students and pass on knowledge from more senior members to help transitions from year to year.

To a degree its a gray area in FIRST since its for "High School Aged Students" however no where does it say what age/grade they need be in to participate in FRC so its open for teams to decide.

Wired_Mike 27-04-2015 11:35

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
I don't know for certain, but I am pretty sure that the entire 2056 drive team is made up of freshman. They have only had 3 drive teams since their rookie year in 2006-2007.

Each drive team started together their freshman year and stays as the drive team through senior year. This drive team rotated in this year since it is the 9th year that they have been competing. It seems to work pretty well since they have won every regional event they've attended since they started.

Pretzel 27-04-2015 12:18

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
One of team 1619's two human players was a freshman in high school this year, but a second year member of the team. Having a freshman is not any sort of disadvantage if you are picking your drive team based on ability and maturity rather than seniority. Our team uses a tryout system along with peer reviews (each candidate says who they think would be best for each role in a private setting with a mentor) to decide the drive team each year along with a minimum required rules competency.

This year's breakdown was as follows:
Driver: Senior
Backup Driver: Junior
Operator: Junior
Backup Operator: Senior
Human Players: Senior and Freshman (the senior is the backup operator)

346CADmen 27-04-2015 12:50

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
To a degree its a gray area in FIRST since its for "High School Aged Students" however no where does it say what age/grade they need be in to participate in FRC so its open for teams to decide.[/quote]

Having only done a quick search, I did find on the FIRST home page FRC is 9th-12th grade ages 14-18. While not date specific, would guess as long as the students are registered in STIMs all is well.

And as far as having freshman on the drive team, all for it. Allowing students to become "vested" in program responsibilities will assure their interest is maintained.

Whippet 27-04-2015 22:35

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
The age for FRC participation seems to have been intentionally left as vague as possible to ensure that everyone who wants to is allowed. That being said, the FRC game manual has for the past few years stated that driver positions are limited to "Pre-college" team members. My old team, 3043, interpreted this as "any student that has not yet reached college-going age." This is how I was able to be human player in 7th grade, and being on the field really sparked my desire to continue my FRC participation for as long as I possibly could, and was a factor in my being elected co-captain of team 4301 as a freshman. It was truly a transformative experience, and I would encourage anybody in the position to try to do so. I do seem also seem to recall seeing an all middle school FRC team at kickoff 2013 in Lubbock.

I would recommend that we try to maintain our driver selection criteria on the skills of the driver, rather than the age of the candidate. My teams have found success there; YMMV.

Source: That's me feeding in the bottom left corner at 2:35 in the video.

Billfred 28-04-2015 00:20

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
We weren't there this year, but last year's 4901 drive team had three freshmen at Championship. Then one had to leave Friday night for a family funeral, so it was two freshmen...and an 8th grader.

JohnFogarty 28-04-2015 00:31

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Billfred (Post 1477650)
We weren't there this year, but last year's 4901 drive team had three freshmen at Championship. Then one had to leave Friday night for a family funeral, so it was two freshmen...and an 8th grader.

We had freshman/middle school guys driving at Orlando this year, but yeah not at champs this year. S A D B O Y S.

EricAnderson191 28-04-2015 00:39

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
One of our pit bosses is an 8th grader. When she did FLL she had nerves of steel on the game board and we are hoping for more of the same next year.

We were under the impression drivers need to be grade 9 or higher.

Eric

346CADmen 28-04-2015 08:24

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Whippet (Post 1477593)
The age for FRC participation seems to have been intentionally left as vague as possible to ensure that everyone who wants to is allowed. That being said, the FRC game manual has for the past few years stated that driver positions are limited to "Pre-college" team members. My old team, 3043, interpreted this as "any student that has not yet reached college-going age." This is how I was able to be human player in 7th grade, and being on the field really sparked my desire to continue my FRC participation for as long as I possibly could, and was a factor in my being elected co-captain of team 4301 as a freshman. It was truly a transformative experience, and I would encourage anybody in the position to try to do so. I do seem also seem to recall seeing an all middle school FRC team at kickoff 2013 in Lubbock.

I would recommend that we try to maintain our driver selection criteria on the skills of the driver, rather than the age of the candidate. My teams have found success there; YMMV.

Source: That's me feeding in the bottom left corner at 2:35 in the video.


Age out of FLL is why the FTC program exists, no? I don't want to harp on this issue, nor discourage anyone. Odd with all the rules that are so direct and succinct that this one with age eligibility is so open.

lark95 28-04-2015 08:55

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
This year we had a freshman human player, a sophomore primary and secondary driver, and a junior coach.

Sparkyshires 28-04-2015 09:35

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
Our first stick (driver), second stick (operator), and human player were seniors, and our drive coach was an alumni/mentor who is moving away this summer, so next year the entire drive team will be new. it will be interesting!

Whippet 28-04-2015 09:36

Re: Freshman on Drive team
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 346CADmen (Post 1477701)
Age out of FLL is why the FTC program exists, no? I don't want to harp on this issue, nor discourage anyone. Odd with all the rules that are so direct and succinct that this one with age eligibility is so open.

I didn't age out of FLL; I was just too obsessed with FIRST, and so was doing FRC and FLL simultaneously. In 8th grade, I was captain of both my school's FLL and FTC teams while still doing FRC.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 19:09.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi