Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Extra Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=142591)

Sperkowsky 26-01-2016 14:59

pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 

hardcopi 26-01-2016 15:00

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Looks good, nice and clean... those wheels though... they look like they might rip the ball up.

BryceKarlins 26-01-2016 15:00

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Are the Flywheels actually mounted that high? We've found that mounting them in the exact center works best.

BryceKarlins 26-01-2016 15:02

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hardcopi (Post 1530447)
Looks good, nice and clean... those wheels though... they look like they might rip the ball up.

If you sand down the edges of the wheel, they work great. Just spin them up on the shooter, and hold a piece of sandpaper up to them.

T3_1565 26-01-2016 15:06

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Looks like a nice simple way to score. Easy to build. Doesn't take up too much space. Looks easy enough to tweek and make a consistent shot out of it.

Nice job

Ginger Power 26-01-2016 15:06

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Looks awesome guys! Great work!

notmattlythgoe 26-01-2016 15:06

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BryceKarlins (Post 1530448)
Are the Flywheels actually mounted that high? We've found that mounting them in the exact center works best.

Just a heads up. Those aren't fly wheels.

Quote:

fly·wheel
noun
a heavy revolving wheel in a machine that is used to increase the machine's momentum and thereby provide greater stability or a reserve of available power during interruptions in the delivery of power to the machine.

jkelleyrtp 26-01-2016 15:48

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by notmattlythgoe (Post 1530455)
Just a heads up. Those aren't fly wheels.

Just so I understand, the "flywheel" part of a shooter would be the extra weight added and not the actual firing wheels themselves? While these wheels are not flywheels, is it safe to say that heavy shooting wheels are technically flywheels in their own right?

notmattlythgoe 26-01-2016 15:56

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jkelleyrtp (Post 1530470)
Just so I understand, the "flywheel" part of a shooter would be the extra weight added and not the actual firing wheels themselves? While these wheels are not flywheels, is it safe to say that heavy shooting wheels are technically flywheels in their own right?

Yeah, I guess a heavy shooter wheel would be a flywheel in itself.

Sperkowsky 26-01-2016 18:52

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BryceKarlins (Post 1530448)
Are the Flywheels actually mounted that high? We've found that mounting them in the exact center works best.

We updated it and put a small spacer. Making it slightly lower on the ball.

Orion.DeYoe 27-01-2016 17:52

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by notmattlythgoe (Post 1530455)
Just a heads up. Those aren't fly wheels.

Can you please provide me with a threshold for when a spinning object is considered "heavy"?

AdamHeard 27-01-2016 22:17

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Orion.DeYoe (Post 1531121)
Can you please provide me with a threshold for when a spinning object is considered "heavy"?

When it's a flywheel.

pilleya 27-01-2016 22:22

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
A flywheel does not have to be heavy, to be able to store energy/momentum. The speed of rotation is also important as well.

Just look at Formula 1 Racing Flywheel System. They use 240 mm diameter flywheel which weighs 5 kg and spins at around 64,500 rpm. They can store enough energy to give a power boost of 60 kW for 6.67 seconds.

IndySam 28-01-2016 08:54

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
a heavy revolving wheel in a machine that is used to increase the machine's momentum and thereby provide greater stability or a reserve of available power during interruptions in the delivery of power to the machine.

I can see both sides of this argument. In general when I think of a flywheel I think of something that stores energy and/or dampens. Personally I would not consider a shooter wheel a flywheel but I have no problem with those who choose to do so.

At least it's not a piston :)

Orion.DeYoe 28-01-2016 08:56

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Yeah, I was attempting to indirectly point out that you can't say a wheel is, or isn't, a flywheel based on its weight. Because whether or not it's "heavy" just depends on how much energy you need to store.

I just wanted to emphasize the fact that the OP's terminology was correct and that these are considered flywheels in this application.

notmattlythgoe 28-01-2016 08:59

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Orion.DeYoe (Post 1531413)
Yeah, I was attempting to indirectly point out that you can't say a wheel is, or isn't, a flywheel based on its weight. Because whether or not it's "heavy" just depends on how much energy you need to store.

I just wanted to emphasize the fact that the OP's terminology was correct and that these are considered flywheels in this application.

But they're not, these wheels are not storing energy (or at least enough energy to make any difference) which is the exact point of a flywheel.

IndySam 28-01-2016 09:07

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
That's a flywheel!


Chris is me 28-01-2016 09:32

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by notmattlythgoe (Post 1531415)
But they're not, these wheels are not storing energy (or at least enough energy to make any difference) which is the exact point of a flywheel.

Yes they are. They're storing kinetic energy. If the wheel needs to be spun up before the ball contacts it for it to work as intended, then the wheel is a flywheel. Whether or not it is a particularly good flywheel isn't relevant. Spinning wheel shooters in FRC work by storing kinetic energy, which is exactly what a flywheel is.

Electronica1 28-01-2016 09:34

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by notmattlythgoe (Post 1531415)
But they're not, these wheels are not storing energy (or at least enough energy to make any difference) which is the exact point of a flywheel.

It is still a flywheel, just not a particularly good one.

Sperkowsky 28-01-2016 09:50

It's definitely a fly wheel but not in the traditional sense. We spin the wheels up for a couple of seconds to gain energy before the ball is pushed into the wheel therefore it is a fly wheel.

mustangs2647 28-01-2016 10:31

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
looks nice but what whats your method of loading it?

Monochron 28-01-2016 11:13

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by notmattlythgoe (Post 1530480)
Yeah, I guess a heavy shooter wheel would be a flywheel in itself.

You guys might need some sleep. I can't see those wheels producing a useful amount of lift at all.

swaxman12345 28-01-2016 11:27

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by hardcopi (Post 1530447)
Looks good, nice and clean... those wheels though... they look like they might rip the ball up.

They do.

notmattlythgoe 28-01-2016 11:54

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Monochron (Post 1531488)
You guys might need some sleep. I can't see those wheels producing a useful amount of lift at all.


Sperkowsky 28-01-2016 17:45

Quote:

Originally Posted by mustangs2647 (Post 1531464)
looks nice but what whats your method of loading it?

It's just a matter of reversing the motors and pitching it down.

Ginger Power 28-01-2016 17:55

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by swaxman12345 (Post 1531497)
They do.

Do you have pictures or anything to support this? I'd be interested in seeing what kind of damage of they caused, and what the application was that caused it.

Sperkowsky 28-01-2016 18:22

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ginger Power (Post 1531690)
Do you have pictures or anything to support this? I'd be interested in seeing what kind of damage of they caused, and what the application was that caused it.

+1

Ben Wolsieffer 28-01-2016 19:23

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
We did some prototyping with those wheels, and while they did scuff the ball, they didn't cause any major damage to our ball. It likely depends on the amount of compression you have.

Ginger Power 28-01-2016 20:00

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lopsided98 (Post 1531720)
We did some prototyping with those wheels, and while they did scuff the ball, they didn't cause any major damage to our ball. It likely depends on the amount of compression you have.

We had the same result in the process of testing, but we got it to a point where there was no sign that it was fired.

viggy96 29-01-2016 19:22

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
What motors are you using there in the image?

pilleya 29-01-2016 19:38

Re: pic: FRC 2869 - 2016 Shooter
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by viggy96 (Post 1532194)
What motors are you using there in the image?

The motors in the image are 775pro's they are a new motor available this year and are available from VEX or West Coast Products.

http://www.vexrobotics.com/vexpro/mo.../217-4347.html

http://www.wcproducts.net/motors


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 17:17.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi