Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Extra Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1 (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=143948)

droopy 16-02-2016 00:23

pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 

asid61 16-02-2016 00:24

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
This looks sketchy because of the wood, and yet really robust/effective at the same time because of they way it is constructed. Nice job.
How are you planning on mounting bumpers?
EDIT: Nevermind, looked up the team number. Ignore question.

juju_beans 16-02-2016 00:27

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
holy crap that wiring made me feel nauseous. You'll really want to clean it up and if you don't you'll be regretting it when you are trying to figure out why something is not working.

Tmeziere 16-02-2016 01:20

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

holy crap that wiring made me feel nauseous. You'll really want to clean it up and if you don't you'll be regretting it when you are trying to figure out why something is not working.
Knowing this team I am sure that their competition robot is going to be great. It looks great guys!

Tom Line 16-02-2016 01:26

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juju_beans (Post 1541000)
holy crap that wiring made me feel nauseous. You'll really want to clean it up and if you don't you'll be regretting it when you are trying to figure out why something is not working.

While constructive criticism can be harsh, it should also be delivered with courtesy and respect. You do not know this team's circumstance: for many teams it is a victory to wire a robot so that it can even turn on.

cadandcookies 16-02-2016 01:56

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by juju_beans (Post 1541000)
holy crap that wiring made me feel nauseous. You'll really want to clean it up and if you don't you'll be regretting it when you are trying to figure out why something is not working.

I suppose when you build your prototype chassis you take time to carefully route and label every wire, zip tie it down, make your perfectly radiused bends, and then redo that every time you need to tear it apart to try something new. I truly applaud your high standards.

Ian Curtis 16-02-2016 01:57

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by asid61 (Post 1540999)
This looks sketchy because of the wood, and yet really robust/effective at the same time because of they way it is constructed. Nice job.
How are you planning on mounting bumpers?
EDIT: Nevermind, looked up the team number. Ignore question.

In New England they build robots so tough they don't need no stinkin' bumpers.

Plywood isn't sketchy, it's a material with its own strengths (cheap, easy to work with, strong) and weaknesses (not "cool" according to some people). I like to say it's a cutting edge composite. IMO many teams would be well served by building more simple working things out of plywood than complicated not working things out of aluminum.

Tom Line 16-02-2016 03:05

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ian Curtis (Post 1541032)
In New England they build robots so tough they don't need no stinkin' bumpers.

Plywood isn't sketchy, it's a material with its own strengths (cheap, easy to work with, strong) and weaknesses (not "cool" according to some people). I like to say it's a cutting edge composite. IMO many teams would be well server by building more simple working things out of plywood than complicated not working things out of aluminum.

It took us a long time to convince certain team members that the coolest and best looking robot is one that wins.

Function over form every single time.

JesseK 16-02-2016 08:06

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tom Line (Post 1541038)
It took us a long time to convince certain team members that the coolest and best looking robot is one that wins.

Function over form every single time.

I've never been able to convince my team lead of this. I have to make sure the business team has 3 pounds of robot to do with as they please. Since weight hasn't been a huge problem in recent years, it's a good compromise.

Nathan Streeter 16-02-2016 17:26

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ian Curtis (Post 1541032)
Plywood isn't sketchy, it's a material with its own strengths (cheap, easy to work with, strong) and weaknesses (not "cool" according to some people). I like to say it's a cutting edge composite. IMO many teams would be well served by building more simple working things out of plywood than complicated not working things out of aluminum.

I'll give a hearty amen to this!

Brian C 19-02-2016 07:54

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
You folks DO realize that this may be in all likelihood their practice robot and their competition machine may be a twin but with different materials?

And yes as others have mentioned, show a bit of courtesy when providing your "constructive criticism" Not everyone can be as good as you are.......... ;)

Great job on the build guys, good luck this season!

echin 19-02-2016 08:26

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Just for clarification on this bot, we were given the chance to participate in the filming of a documentary called A Different Mind and received an extremely limited set of parts and six hours to design, build, and program a robot for FIRST Stronghold with this being the result. This why the wiring is such a mess and we are using the bottom of a tote as the back of the intake. While FIRST will not be the sole focus of the documentary, it will hopefully help to further spread FIRST and other similar programs.

This build definitely helped convince me that plywood is a great material and COTS parts are amazing:)

Brian C 19-02-2016 08:33

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by echin (Post 1542603)

This build definitely helped convince me that plywood is a great material and COTS parts are amazing:)

Sounds like it was a great opportunity for your team and I bet all of you learned some valuable things by participating. Very cool!

Plywood is a GREAT option for Robots. In fact check back in some of the archives or Google team 173 RAGE. They used to make their entire chassis out of 3/4" Marine Plywood "back in the day"

philso 19-02-2016 14:06

Re: pic: Team 3467 2016 Teaser #1
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian C (Post 1542607)
Plywood is a GREAT option for Robots.

Maybe not this year considering the latest Game Update ;)

3467's robot and ours are going to be toast(ed)...


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:55.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi