Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Have you tried parking on the Batter? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=144603)

Ginger Power 23-02-2016 23:01

Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
I think this is something that a large majority of teams are overlooking. Staying on the batter at the end of a match is not trivial. It is also going to be required to be competitive at high levels of play, you can't capture without doing so. Having 3 teams all park on the batter is even harder.

The challenge is made even harder by the lack of visibility of the batter, and the invisibility of the dividers on the batter. If you haven't yet, watch some matches from the Merrimack Week 0 event. The real field will offer some challenges that are hard to replicate.

I will also say that the RP for Capturing will be extremely rare during qualification matches because teams won't be able to park on the batter (it'll also be challenging to score 8 boulders...). The rarity of a robot that can reliably do its part to capture during the end game will make said robots highly sought after come alliance selection.

As the reveal videos start to come out, I'm sure we'll see most of the elite teams climbing. I don't believe this is only for the 10 point advantage over parking, I think it's because they realized early on that fitting 3 robots on that batter is going to be a challenge.

So have you practiced parking on the Batter (or climbing for that matter)? How do your experiences compare?

Knufire 23-02-2016 23:06

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
What part of parking on the batter did you find diffcult? Alignment? Fitting between the dividers? Or backdriving/sliding down the ramp after power is cut?

cjl2625 23-02-2016 23:08

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
A drivetrain with a brake helps.

Sperkowsky 23-02-2016 23:08

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
I have and turning the robot at an angle is a must. Those tiny lips will not stop a sliding robot. We can score 8 low goals in a match alone. So, capturing the tower is a big part of our strategy. We are slightly worried though in qualification matches some teams will be reluctant to change up their strategy.

MrForbes 23-02-2016 23:14

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
our robot just goes right on it, and parks...and we can shoot a goal...

using kit wheels is a big help. The little cleat is like a wall to the kit wheels.

Anthony Galea 23-02-2016 23:20

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Having a shifting drivetrain is nice for this. ;)

Ginger Power 23-02-2016 23:42

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Knufire (Post 1545601)
What part of parking on the batter did you find diffcult? Alignment? Fitting between the dividers? Or backdriving/sliding down the ramp after power is cut?

From what I've seen at week 0 events, robots slide down and roll off the batter after the power is cut. This is probably more common for robots with large pneumatic wheels... most of them... there are obviously going to be tricks and effective techniques for parking on the Batter. My argument is that most teams won't even consider any of the tricks until after they roll off the batter in their first match.

Ty Tremblay 23-02-2016 23:44

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ginger Power (Post 1545644)
From what I've seen at week 0 events, robots slide down and roll off the batter after the power is cut. This is probably more common for robots with large pneumatic wheels... most of them... there are obviously going to be tricks and effective techniques for parking on the Batter. My argument is that most teams won't even consider any of the tricks until after they roll off the batter in their first match.

This is all dependent on gear ratio, wheel size, friction, etc.

pfreivald 23-02-2016 23:46

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
It's easier when you're in the air, hanging from a RUNG. :D

page2067 23-02-2016 23:48

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ginger Power (Post 1545644)
From what I've seen at week 0 events, robots slide down and roll off the batter after the power is cut. This is probably more common for robots with large pneumatic wheels... most of them... there are obviously going to be tricks and effective techniques for parking on the Batter. My argument is that most teams won't even consider any of the tricks until after they roll off the batter in their first match.

Totally agree

We are making a parking brake to account for this - we tested, and our pneumatic front and back wheel roll right over the 3/4 in cleat - with our gear ratio - .

page2067 23-02-2016 23:57

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Our hangar takes care of it - bit it is still a medieval myth.

lethc 24-02-2016 01:34

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sperkowsky (Post 1545604)
I have and turning the robot at an angle is a must. Those tiny lips will not stop a sliding robot. We can score 8 low goals in a match alone. So, capturing the tower is a big part of our strategy. We are slightly worried though in qualification matches some teams will be reluctant to change up their strategy.

With defense?

scca229 24-02-2016 12:23

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
*Speaking from the position of never having done this.*

Couldn't you pull fully onto the batter and then back yourself down to purposefully set the wheels statically against the lip? When the power is cut, you wouldn't then be sliding down creating extra momentum to carry the wheels over.

Of course I'm suggesting this when the driver is 55+ feet away looking through defenses...but I think it should work. The kids thought I was out of my head when I had them stand 48' away (length of the classroom) from a pair of back-to-back chairs representing the low goals the Monday after kickoff...and then told them it is really another 8 or so feet further. Now they understand why I did it.

Sperkowsky 24-02-2016 12:26

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by lethc (Post 1545697)
With defense?

Yea we had plenty of teams play defense on us. A good defender can definitely shut us down a bit but, I think they are going to focus on the high goal shooters for the most part. We also have had a lot of driver practice with a week 0, and 5 practice events with other teams.

Sperkowsky 24-02-2016 12:28

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by scca229 (Post 1545986)
*Speaking from the position of never having done this.*

Couldn't you pull fully onto the batter and then back yourself down to purposefully set the wheels statically against the lip? When the power is cut, you wouldn't then be sliding down creating extra momentum to carry the wheels over.

Of course I'm suggesting this when the driver is 55+ feet away looking through defenses...but I think it should work. The kids thought I was out of my head when I had them stand 48' away (length of the classroom) from a pair of back-to-back chairs representing the low goals the Monday after kickoff...and then told them it is really another 8 or so feet further. Now they understand why I did it.

It depends a lot on the wheels and gear ratio. With stuff like pneumatic wheels going over the lip pretty much no matter what. The best way to do it is drive on the batter and then rotate or try to drive up at an angle.

BrendanB 24-02-2016 12:28

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ty Tremblay (Post 1545645)
This is all dependent on gear ratio, wheel size, friction, etc.

^This.

Our robot was at the official Week Zero event and didn't need one to stay on the batter however that wasn't the case for every robot.

If you really want to end the match parked on the Batter, start planning something to hold you there now if you don't have the ability to test your robot on a lexan incline between now and your event.

Caleb Sykes 24-02-2016 12:42

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ty Tremblay (Post 1545645)
This is all dependent on gear ratio, wheel size, friction, etc.

Speed controller setting is also important. I'll be checking with every team I encounter that their speed controllers are set to brake mode.

scca229 24-02-2016 12:45

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sperkowsky (Post 1545993)
It depends a lot on the wheels and gear ratio. With stuff like pneumatic wheels going over the lip pretty much no matter what. The best way to do it is drive on the batter and then rotate or try to drive up at an angle.

I guess this might be an advantage of the plain old Kit Bot drive train as we don't have an issue with that. 8" pneumatic wheels, no other modifications to the provided kit and ours doesn't move when power is cut on the incline of the batter. Maybe I need to find out if the kids actually greased the gearboxes :yikes: We are also royally underweight, so that is probably helping as well.

Andrew Schreiber 24-02-2016 12:53

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Caleb Sykes (Post 1546011)
Speed controller setting is also important. I'll be checking with every team I encounter that their speed controllers are set to brake mode.

Fair heads up, CAN bus teams can dynamically switch that really easily. It's actually pretty nice.

BJT 24-02-2016 13:05

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
If you have a heavy end of your robot, park that against the lip. Our robot is pretty heavy on the back when the shooter is up, and stays parked. Low gear and brake mode on the talons helps so if you roll into the lip it is slow.

daliberator 24-02-2016 13:44

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sperkowsky (Post 1545990)
Yea we had plenty of teams play defense on us. A good defender can definitely shut us down a bit but, I think they are going to focus on the high goal shooters for the most part. We also have had a lot of driver practice with a week 0, and 5 practice events with other teams.

Were you scoring 8 boulders at Suffield in 5-minute matches, or somewhere else with regulation time? Either way, that's pretty cool.

whitetail 24-02-2016 14:38

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
We have two fingers that go down and stop us at the end of the match from rolling off the batter.

Sperkowsky 24-02-2016 14:50

Quote:

Originally Posted by daliberator (Post 1546077)
Were you scoring 8 boulders at Suffield in 5-minute matches, or somewhere else with regulation time? Either way, that's pretty cool.

Well both. I think our max at Suffield was 11 with a capture. During a normal match we can do 8. While crossing the B and D defenses. Although we can also do the Cheval DE Frise and Drawbridge solo we can not do it while scoring 8 boulders

Coach Seb 24-02-2016 18:22

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
"A ROBOT has CHALLENGED the TOWER if, at the conclusion of the MATCH, the ROBOT is fully supported by the TOWER, but hasn’t met the criteria for SCALING the TOWER."

To make sure i understand this correctly, this means that the robot cannot touch the courtyard carpet, it has to be positioned fully on the batter ?

MrForbes 24-02-2016 18:29

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
That's the plan....

Chris is me 24-02-2016 18:35

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sperkowsky (Post 1546127)
Well both. I think our max at Suffield was 11 with a capture. During a normal match we can do 8. While crossing the B and D defenses. Although we can also do the Cheval DE Frise and Drawbridge solo we can not do it while scoring 8 boulders

There were 6 balls on the midfield at Suffield, three at the human player station, and three in all of the robots in your alliance. In order to score 11 balls in a match, you would need to have obtained every ball your alliance could have possibly controlled except for one. Since balls weren't returned to human players, this is a bit suspect. I had to leave Suffield early since 228 had some problems to fix, so I didn't watch all your matches, but this is a tall order even in a 5 minute match. Did they start returning balls by the end of the day or something?

Sperkowsky 24-02-2016 19:21

Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris is me (Post 1546276)
There were 6 balls on the midfield at Suffield, three at the human player station, and three in all of the robots in your alliance. In order to score 11 balls in a match, you would need to have obtained every ball your alliance could have possibly controlled except for one. Since balls weren't returned to human players, this is a bit suspect. I had to leave Suffield early since 228 had some problems to fix, so I didn't watch all your matches, but this is a tall order even in a 5 minute match. Did they start returning balls by the end of the day or something?

They got a shipment of boulders half way through the day.

Caleb Sykes 24-02-2016 19:41

Re: Have you tried parking on the Batter?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Sperkowsky (Post 1546127)
During a normal match we can do 8.

I'm going to call a "video or it didn't happen" on this. Please prove me wrong.

Sperkowsky 24-02-2016 19:48

Quote:

Originally Posted by Caleb Sykes (Post 1546318)
I'm going to call a "video or it didn't happen" on this. Please prove me wrong.

I'll get a video in 2 weeks. :)


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:13.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi