![]() |
What is the most (SKETCHY) thing you've seen on a robot?
So we're working on our climber now, and it struck us how incredibly ghetto (jurry-rigged, cheap, unrefined etc.) it is.
Ours has ground-down bolts, nuts used as spacers, angle ground gearboxes, a wrench as a ratchet, rubber bands, bent steel bars, ground down hex shafts a seatbelt, and generally a lot of crap. Here's pictures: https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...ZGJGeGls M053 https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...VzZGJGeGlsM053 https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...VzZGJGeGlsM053 https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...VzZGJGeGlsM053 https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...VzZGJGeGlsM053 https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...VzZGJGeGlsM053 https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...ZGJGeGl sM053 https://photos.google.com/share/AF1Q...VzZGJGeGlsM053 Anyways I don't have the best hopes for our end-game this year (even if its my fault). What's the most ghetto thing you've seen on your robot? |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I have personally built far more janky robot parts than those and won events with said janky robot. Driving a janky robot very well is far better than driving a top tier robot poorly.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Any pictures? Just curious :)
We got a fair amount of driving practice in before bag and tag, but this is my first time driving mecanum, and we have a pretty bad weight imbalance screwing with our strafing. Still hoping for a fun regional next week though, I'll drive my best! |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
In 2014, we had a linear ballista-style ball launcher that used really fat latex tubing. We were running into concerns about the wear and tear on the tubing because it only wrapped around two 1/4 bolts, and there was probably upwards of 150+ pounds of tension in the launcher when retracted. So yes, lots of pressure on a little surface.
It was evident that lubricant was necessary, but as the material was latex, we had to opt for water-based lubricant since oil-based lubricants degrade latex. Well, the only water-based lubricants available near the regional were in the form of personal lubricants at the nearby drug stores and supermarkets. In our pit for the rest of the event, we had a tube of Astroglide covered with red duct taped and labeled "Secret Sauce." We applied a fresh coat to the latex tubing before every match. Not sure if it's the kind of "ghetto" you're looking for, but it's certainly an unexpected fix to a problem. Worked like a charm, though. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
In 2013, our design was to have the robot drive to the HP station, be fed frisbees, and hold onto the frisbees until the endgame, where we would scale the pyramid and dump the frisbees into the top of the pyramid for points. The collector for the frisbees broke during the Quals of Colorado, and we ended up fixing it with duct tape and a Team Driven t-shirt.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Edit: also at our first event we had to C-clamp a major component(without it we couldn't shoot properly) into place after it broke, we then proceeded to run 2 perfect cycles back to back at Inland Empire with a seriously crippled robot. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I don't know about anyone else, but personally, I find the phrase "most ghetto thing" offensive.
Invite conversation about shoddy construction and poor taste if you want to, but to equate it to anything that comes out of poor urban areas reeks of classism and racism. It has no place here. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Dear Craftsman tools,
I am very disappointed in my 1/2" Craftsman ratchet. It doesn't perform nearly as I expect when jury-rigged into an FRC component. I'd like to claim on my lifetime warranty. ... Dear FRC team, Although we appreciate your talent and unique use case. We can't provide a replacement for a use we clearly did not intend. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Come on dude everyone knows what he means with ghetto do be so critical about it.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I have a friend from a team that describes how sketchy an idea/solution is by removing letters from the word "sketchy." I've been a part of teams that got down to what I would consider "ske."
And yeah, no need to refer to badly-made robots parts as ghetto. There are plenty of other words that less people will find offensive that one can use. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
The most (insert non-racist word here) hack I've seen was 1646 in 2008 at Great Lakes regional. They built a ball herding lap runner and a fast one at that... and during eliminations their mechanism broke to the point of requiring removal, and that caused all sorts of weight distribution issues. OK, what to do? Add weight, obviously... but what to add? Obviously they couldn't add extra CIMs or batteries (the latter was more obvious then than in 2014), so they had to go for the next heaviest thing in the pits, tools! Wrenches, a drill press vice, you name it, they added it to the front of the robot to get the weight back. They didn't advance to finals, but it was still funny to look at.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I still have the crescent end of a combo ratchet/crescent wrench that we used to make a gearbox addition in order to prevent backdriving of a motor at all times. The funny part was that at first we installed the wrench the wrong way, meaning that it had to be taken completely apart (a not so kind procedure) before being reinstalled.
There was a part last year on our robot, which held the end of a Dart actuator in place, that was meant to be CNC milled. It was a small part that was to be made from box tubing with precision, not thinking about the small surface area of the part, I attempted to run it on a CNC mill with a tape plate (3 of the 4 sides had to be cut, hence the tape plate). One loudly thrown part later, I decided that manual machining would be precise enough since we did not have enough time to machine a fixture for the part at that point in the build season. Thus was born the "TNC" (Tyler Non-numerically Controlled) bracket, a part which could only be described as "passable" after using a belt sander to attempt to shape the part from a rectangular piece of box tubing down to the teardrop shape specified in the CAD model. It was eventually replaced after two regional events worth of abuse caused it to begin to buckle (I later postulated that techniques used such as "using a vice to mash it back to square" and "beating on it with a hammer" did not result in it having the highest measure of structural integrity), but while it was on the robot it fairly evident that it did not belong despite the fact that it worked. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I just had to address a student about this exact issue in the pits at Kettering last week. She was addressing a cable ran to the second floor via a ladder with caution tape wrapped around it. My exact words to her were "unless there's 7 hungry families living in that ladder, you need to find a different word to describe it."
It's not about being politically correct, it's about being inclusive and approachable. (I hope) you wouldn't call someone acting in an undesirable manner gay for the same reason that you shouldn't call the crap you put on your robot ghetto. In doing so you let those who are gay and those who actually live in the ghetto know that they are undesirable and that they are crap respectively. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Yes, we know what he means. But it is time that society breaks away from these traditional and disrespectful terms and descriptions. We are well into the 21st century, lets not condone these sort of descriptions any where, let alone in the FIRST community. Also many teams struggle with limited resources, let's not take away the pride that they feel when they have finished building their robot, even though it may not live up to some peoples standards. While you may see it as okay, to be submitting photos of parts on your own robots, teams which may be proud of their ability to utilise that tool or part in that way also look at CD |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Our 2013 robot, designed to be a 30-point climber, never worked due to poor engineering and a lack of any tangible top-level design. We missed our first couple of qualifications matches just trying to get the thing to pass inspection, and the climbing mechanism was destroyed a couple matches later in a collision with another robot. We ended up building a simple 10-point climber that was held together entirely by zip ties that we broke at the beginning of the match, allowing the robot to climb at the be beginning of the match and literally nothing else. If we tried to do defense, the zip ties would fail prematurely and remove any ability for is to score points. (Un)fortunately,I am not aware of any existing photographs or videos of said robot.
Our 2014 entry was far more effective, but looked even more poorly constructed: https://youtu.be/QDLsJxaACUA |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Ignoring the possible offense of the term used (and noting in passing that I have heard far more offensive terms that mean the same thing), here are a few examples of creative use of products:
There was a rookie robot at Bayou in 2014 (Aerial Assist) which was largely constructed of scrap metal, such as old road signs. The goalie riser was particularly shocking, but up close, all the rough edges were knocked down and it was a slick piece of work on an extreme budget. The second iteration of our boulder pickup this year used a Home Depot "Homer Bucket" cut off to about 12" tall and "dissected like a frog" to both help bring the boulder to the centerline of the robot and ensure a clean pour into the launcher. Iterations 3, 4, and 5 have returned to all aluminum and/or polycarb construction, but none have centered the ball as cleanly as #2. Our 2013 Ultimate Ascent climbing slide was rather curious. A CIM was mounted in a piece of angle which was mounted to a T-hinge, and drove a timing belt sheave directly. The other end of the timing belt drove a "lead screw" composed of threaded rod and a coupling nut. The |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Well, some people interpret things differently. It all depends on your point of view. I wouldn't say they are considering it as a racist word, more as a word, when taken out of context, could be offensive to others.
CD is more of a formal forums when it comes to FIRST robotics - r/FRC would possibly be more accepting of the word, though I wouldn't suggest using it there in the first place. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Such as building an Einstein field worthy robot out of a leaky shipping container with a 3 phase wiring job that would make any licensed electrician scream in horror. Yes our build practices were sub-par, but that did nothing to deter us from rebuilding practically our whole robot and practicing like mad to be on even footing with the best and the greatest. Edit: I feel that the term "Janky" has the closest feel and meaning to what OP was going for, let's all just agree to use that and carry on with this thread as intended before it gets any further derailed. Let's just use this as a learning experience. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Well , it seems that at least one person may have missed the point of this discussion. Seriously, if you were a student in an economically disadvantaged school struggling to come up with funding to even continue from year to year, how do you think you would feel to read comments that essentially make fun of anything you and your team tried to do with limited resources? Is that the spirit that FIRST is trying to inspire?
I'll say it again: the implication that comes with the perjorative "ghetto" (and no, it is not the dictionary definition being discussed here) has no place in FIRST. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Last year our off season bot had lexan rectangles on hinges so they could slide down the totes but not up. Fortunately, they would flip too far rendering our manipulator useless.
The solution resulted in the majority of our robot's usefulness relying on the preserverance of paperclips and rubber bands. If it works, im not complaining ;) |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I'll say as a person of color, I don't allow any of the students on the team I mentor use the term ghetto. I had the discussion and broke down the uses of the term and why it's an issue. I don't use it myself. I see it as offensive, particularly as I came from some not so great environments. As I work on making FIRST and other robotics programs more accessible to other students in my area that aren't all the same, I have to do my part to break some things down.
Now to the actual question.. It would most likely be either the pulleys and pneumatic grippers we built for last year's robot. Had some roughly machined metal that was ill-shaped, poorly cut, not smooth, and not uniform for the cable we were using, along with haphazardly cut stock metal. Actually during a community event while running with the robot I actually nearly got skewered by the thing as the bridge wasn't reset. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
To be honest, a lot of your examples look really professionally put together compared to a lot of robots I have seen, and quite a few that I have been a part of making.
Last minute fixes and adjustments are always a great experience. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Wow I didn't think I'd get hit for saying what I did.
I'm not on chief delphi to explain my methodology on how I've dealt with racism all my life. 1339 has had issues in previous years that were dealt with in different ways. I'll see if I can get photos |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
In 2014 (Aerial Assist), we were having problems with the ball falling out of our shooter. Our shooter was a catapult of aluminum bar, bent to have a circular footprint where the ball rested until being shot. The problem was that it wasn't deep enough. As the drivers raced off after picking up the ball, the acceleration would sometimes cause the ball to drop out. We needed some way to keep it in, but whatever we used had to be something we could pull it over as we picked it up off the floor.
Of course we discovered this problem at our first district, and were trying to fix it during "out of bag" time just before the second district. Mentors had come up with a few proposals, but testing showed them inadequate. We had a few failures. The time was running out. Then someone saw the broom. It was a push broom, 28" wide, with tall, soft, bristles. It fit perfectly. The bristles were easy to drag the ball over with our pickup mechanism, but they provided just enough resistance to keep the ball in the cradle before we shot. The only thing that made it look a little not so...err...that word, was that it fit so well and worked so well you very well might have thought that we did it on purpose. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Last year one of the gussets on our elevator broke a day before we left for IRI. We somehow didn't have a replacement so we made up a janky solution to hold on one of the bearings using another VEX gusset bolted on. We ended up leaving it like that for our two other off seasons after IRI...
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Last year we quickly realized while we were at NE District Champs that we needed a can burglar... and so starts the tale of the Jank Shank...
It was an awful piece of 1/2 conduit and some hacksawed brackets with a horribly mounted piston on the side of our robot. It worked with mighty hutzpa! We eventually took it off do to complications with the integrity of the device when we went to St. Louis. :( But... when we competed at the offseason event River Rage in NH there was once again a need for the Shank! I was able to borrow and not return (with permission) a piece of square conduit from team 138 and I constructed a new Jank Shank. This monstrosity was held together purely by electrical tape, it was awful. It took be a total of 20 minutes, and the entire time I kept telling people to not expect much, it would only work once. If anyone who was there remembers how this new Shank worked... good. It worked once in a semifinal auto to grab the Great RC painted orange like a Great Pumpkin (Charlie Brown!) and everyone thought it broke accidentally because it was all bent up afterward. It was meant to do that! And that is the most janky thing I have ever seen on a robot I built! |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Let me just say that there's a whole lot of people chiming in here that I don't think have any real insight into this discussion on "ghetto".
Eastside Memorial High School, a 'borderline failing' high school which replaced an actually 'failed' high school, used to host FRC Team 3320, which I helped mentor from 2013 until they disbanded mid-season in 2015. This school serves a very poor population, with 86.9% of students listed as "Economically Disadvantaged" on the school's webpage. Quote:
Now, implying that those kids think everything they'd ever made must be crap because the team didn't have resources, that I have a problem with. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Back on the topic of "least professionally engineered solution deployed on a robot"
a literal lead brick from the small parts catalog, 1997, roughly hewn with a hack saw to get the total robot weight to the exact maximum. You can still find the basic item at small parts (since they were purchased by amazon) http://www.amazon.com/Small-Parts-Le.../dp/B003SLEVSA on FRC Team # 122, used to counterbalance a long arm. |
I'd say use Mickey Mouse but Disney would probably sue.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
A lot of robots used 5 gal buckets for Frisbee storage for Ultimate Ascent. Successful engineering is all about making the best use of your resources.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
I tried really hard to have our defense manipulator be made out of 2x4s this year, but we opted for fancier material in the end. Mechanisms that use cheap materials and ultra-low precision machining are my favorite part of any robot. ![]() |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Man I hope the PC police don't get all spun up over that. Sadly, I'm sure someone will find it offensive. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Disney Engineering is not that bad... Six Flags engineering that's a whole other story: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fnAawCUTNC4 Let's not even talk about the original Haunted House. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
In response to a post that was deleted...
Six Flags does maintain the rides, or hire the contractors who do so. Sort of like not everyone on a robot teams necessarily designs the robot. BTW the video audio does clearly state these facts. Mind you - I have no problem with innovative use of materials in robots. I would like to see it rewarded in fact, but I would hope not to the point of creating safety issues. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Maybe vendors will see the value in having an "FRC Robot Tested Tough" sticker on their products. Like in the days of yore when Timex had funny ads showing how tough their watch was. https://www.youtube.com/watch?featur...&v=ynSrvluQBy8 |
For our flywheels this year we hacksawed, drill pressed, and lathed down a bolt so that it would fit onto a motor shaft
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Since I've been on Cyber Blue, the most "ghetto" solution we had was in 2013 when we replaced a floor pickup system with a blue bucket for taking frisbees from from the HP station.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
In 2010 we had a ramp assembly that required the addition of a duct tape roll core; being used to prevent the robot from smashing itself and losing comm every time the ramp was closed.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
In 2014 we used a drill and a hex bearing(still attached to the chassis) as a lathe
In 2015 we needed HDPE spacers and wheels for our lift so we mangled a milk jug and some casters. Best BOM item ever: Mangled caster x4 Sketchineering at its finest |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I remember this past winter we were at an FLL competition demoing with 461. They had their 2012 bot and one of their tiny belts broke and they didn't have spares with them. They ended up using a wristband as a belt and it kinda worked for awhile. I personally loved how simple but creative a fix it was!
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
We went into our W1 competition with our shooter guides taped on, and our camera mount was entirely made of tape. No need to be elegant if what you have works.
We do plan on making more permanent solutions to these in the future, but we didn't want to make any major last-minute changes to an already functional and practiced component. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Anyways, the most sketch thing we've done is the mod to our AM14U2 kitbot for driver training. We attached two 2x4s as forks with this really interesting contraption for mounting the camera, but you still couldn't see the ball you were trying to pick up. We then proceeded to drive it through an obstacle course made out of chairs and other furniture. The best part was fastening the plywood top to the robot and then trying to frantically drill holes above the RoboRio to plug in the camera. Fun times. http://imgur.com/a/1vw1P |
2014 rookie year in aerial assist. Robot won't stay in correct configuration at match start. We used zip ties to hold the arm up and then used the autonomous to jerk the robot to a stop hard enough to break said zip ties. We also didn't have enough pneumatic guts to get the ball over the truss without a solid running start.
2015 recycle rush. Needed to spring load some clips that we're supposed to pick up totes by the handles during our second district competition. The only thing we had were hair ties from the girls on the team. Our running joke is that hair ties got us to Worlds. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
We all have our "offensive" terms. It seems to be the adults who are posting about the offensive terms. Kids may shrug it off if not guided by adult sensibilities. My minority students use the term "n..ga" even though I try to stop them. Terms even mean different things to different people. Lets "chill" (I'm not trying to offend those from northern latitudes) on the whole topic and get back to the real question...
Our first season we used 150 lb zip ties to keep shafts from flexing. It worked great, but I wouldn't brag to my engineer friends... oh wait, yes I would, bc it worked! We also used a Lowes bucket (not to offend the HD crowd) on our Frizbee collector bin. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I was going to say "What is the most MacGyver'd thing you've seen on a robot?" but I have a feeling most of the posters on here wouldn't know what I was talking about ;)
A lot of stuff gets 'MacGyver'd' the last night of build or between matches when you just need to get something to work in a very short amount of time. Sometimes it works so well it gets left alone :yikes: Just remember even people who hold an A&P license now had to get a start somewhere, learning how to work on something when they were younger. When you look back someday at stuff you built in the beginning you'll wonder why you did that (really?! is that what I thought was good?!?! :eek: ) but at the time you were just proud you did that AND made it WORK at that time!!! Knowledge, and refinement, comes with experience :) |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
The closest thing i think of is our net in 2014. Lack of materials made it hard, so we got some PVC and a net, attached it to some bolted down wood blocks, and Voila! We have a way to catch balls! Surprisingly enough, the net never fell out (it was not secured in any way except for being inside the wood a few inches) and was part of the reason we went to district champs (too bad we couldn't pay for it...) |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
We had to fix our intakes at an off season event one year and we discovered a shaft key had come out. While looking for said shaft key we found a rivet on the floor. I don't think I need to elaborate on this any more...
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Sometimes people are just offended too easily. Sometimes offensively so.
For the record, in our neck of the woods we sometimes refer to this as "cajun engineering", in jest but not intended as an offense. Also for the record, the guy whose hands are in the picture that I posted as a "cajun compass" is not in fact a cajun, but I am at least 3/8 cajun myself, and I did not intend to be mean to either the man wielding the crawfish tray as a circle guide or to my own relatives. Nor do I believe any of them took it that way. Chill! |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I was not able to witness the performance of the robot, but I remember in 2014 Aerial Assist, I looked down the end of the convention center and I saw a robot that featured a folding chair (with arm rests) as the catching mechanism.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Okay, okay, can we move past whether or not you think the title of the thread is offensive? We get it. You've all made your point. Now let's focus on the actual INTENT behind the words and what the thread was intended to be about?
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
This year, I've seen a robot that held its intake in starting configuration with... wait for it... ...Painter's tape. Yep, folks, painter's tape, 1" wide and stretched long. I knew they needed a new piece when they were trying to find a spot to stick the two pieces they made every time they went out for a match together... |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
The following story is not the most kludgey thing we have ever done, but it is one of the most successful kludges we have ever pulled off.
This year at Mount Olive, we took the robot out of the bag and noticed the intake arm was spinning loose on the shaft. We looked a little closer and somewhere between final testing and bagging the robot, the 3/16" key had fallen out of the sprocket. After looking through everything we brought we discovered that the spare key stock had not been packed. After calming down, we cut the heads off of some #10 bolts and shoved them into the empty keyways and re-tightened the retaining set screws with loctite and they held for the entire event. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
We had an interesting "fix" this past weekend. During a match the sensor for our defense manipulator broke off. This sensor tells the robot where the arm is so we can go under the low bar/portcullis in autonomous mode. With no spare sensor we hot glued a limit switch to the inside of our robot, used the unused wire from the limit switches pwm cable as a string, and fastened the other end to the arm. This depressed the switch when the arm was fully down. The funny thing is that it worked for the rest of the competition.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Although I disagree with the thread creator's diction, due to the conotations with racism and poverty, I do wish to share the"jankiest" thing that we on 2910 have done this season.
Our current robot: Lady Bertrude, had one of the shooter motors come completely off during our second to last semi final match at the Glacier Peak week 2 event. The repair consisted of wrapping "Engineering Tape" (duct tape) around it until it was reasonably secured. this allowed us to play in the last match, where the other shooter motor bent horribly to one side. Also, during build season, we did not build a channel for the climber rope, and promptly allowed it to rest on top of our gatherer angler sprocket and chain. These kind of jury rigs often are the result of a lack of time or budget, and really ought to be looked at more fondly than anything else, as they add character and identity to a robot, and symbolize creative and clever design in a pinch. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Here's another "improvised" repair that was notable.
Boilermaker Regional, 2013. In the finals it was the 1 seed vs 2 seed. 359+868+1747 vs. 234+1741+3147. 3147 had a "unique" design that year, with nothing but a human-loaded "bucket" frisbee shooter and drivetrain in the base, and on top of that a belt-driven climber that also housed the battery and electronics. Final match 1: 3147's climber breaks at the actuator driving the base-to-climber joint, and can no longer support the climber assembly. They are disabled for the rest of the match as a result. Not good, as that assembly can't be removed (since all the eletricals were inside it). Likewise, with the assembly flopped down, they're not in starting configuration... What to do? Allaince 2 uses thier timeout coupon, and after the timeouts, 3147 comes out... with a broomstick supporting the climber! IIRC it was also duct taped in, which added to the "jerry rigged" look of the repair. Suffice to say, the stick snapped in match 2, they were disabled once again, and with Alliance 1 winning both matches the competition was settled. TheBlueAlliance links to the matches: http://www.thebluealliance.com/match/2013inwl_f1m1 http://www.thebluealliance.com/match/2013inwl_f1m2 You gotta do what you gotta do sometimes... :D |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
As a robot inspector I would immediately commend you guys for using a ratchet in such an innovative manner. I love jury-rigged stuff. In a competition full of beautiful robots made with CAD/CAM and precisely machined components I always enjoy seeing students who pull off an innovative solution using unconventional materials.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
As an urban educator, I commend the rational discussion in this thread regarding the language in the OP's title. I think we've arrived at a mature and reasonable conclusion.
That said, I also think that youngsters who are inculcated within a specific cultural context are not yet experienced enough to truly empathize with those in other contexts. This is not their fault, but rather just a lack of life experience. So, I want to provide some more information: At our district regional this past weekend, the first thing my students-of-color said to me as we walked into the pit area was: "I don't see anyone else that looks like me." How racism and classism operates is less and less on a personal level these days (which is good!), but more and more on an ontological and systemic level (which is pernicious!). Just go to Google Images right now and type in the word "engineer", and describe the top pictures that pop up. In fact, I'm gonna do that now! Here is what pops up for me: http://i.imgur.com/pWbqtof.jpg As you can see, beyond the lack of racial diversity in this representation, there's also a lack of gender diversity. This is emblematic of the normalization of certain representations of students of color. This normalization, which some scholars refer to as anti-blackness, is the ontological construction through media and narrative of what it means to be an urban youth. In essence, when we think about an "urban youth", whatever that may mean, the first images that pop into mind is not an engineer in a shirt-and-tie wearing a hard-hat. And it's not just people who are privileged that carry those thoughts! Some of my students do as well! That's how pervasive anti-blackness is within our culture. I was judging a debate round once, when two teams were debating this very issue, and a student asked in cross-examination to another student: "Where is the black identity in America that is not equivocated with struggle?" Even at the regional competition this weekend, we were asked by our judges to juxtapose our success as a rookie team with our students' socioeconomic status. Ultimately, this is why the language we use is super important. Yes, we can take back that term "ghetto", and yes, some of our students might not even see or take offense to that term. However, it's not just this one term. It is the amalgamation of the images and representations they see, the language they hear being used to describe them, the fact that their perception of the role of police in society is very different than majority culture, the fact that they can't hang out at a park in the afternoon without being harassed by authorities, etc. All of these add up to systemic racism. I'll get off my soap-box now. :) EDIT: That picture was gigantic. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
How about a riveted seat belt to secure a battery in its holder:D ?
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
1 Attachment(s)
I'll submit our ghetto secret weapon that seemed to work out ok
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Accepting the previous conclusions about choice of language, I'm rolling with "janky" to describe things that look like they shouldn't work, but do anyways (and as such, these are among the best moments for fond recollection in years to come).
You wouldn't know it by looking at our more recent robots, but 862 was once defined by our mastery of all things jank. With inconsistent availability of build spaces and a complete lack of precision tooling (our first in-house drill press was a pretty big deal), we promoted ourselves based on our "old school" build philosophy (if it requires any more tooling than a hacksaw and drill, it can't be done). During my rookie year in '06, our team had an expanding hopper to hold poof balls; the walls of the hopper were made of fabric, which naturally kept getting torn. In between each match, we patched up any new holes with zip ties, until eventually we ended up with no fabric left at all; just a sheet of zip ties linked together like chainmaille. (I would also call out our collection roller system from the same year, but that wasn't really all that janky; it just sucked.) The next year in '07, we initially didn't give our claw enough leverage to consistently clamp onto the inner tubes and hold them stable; a couple of gel insoles zip tied to the claw helped to solve that problem with better friction. (Don't even get me started on the janked-out ramp we concocted for other bots to climb on top of; alumalite sign panels were never meant for use as weight-bearing elements, much less with 2.5" swiss cheese holes drilled through them!) During the '08 competition season, we discovered that we had vastly underestimated the side loads that our elbow joint would be subjected to; we managed to get by for a while, bending it back into shape in between each match with a pair of vise grips and our trusty dead-blow hammer... But when it snapped clean in two near the end of the competition season, we ended up needing to replace the whole assembly. Later during the post-season, we wanted to protect our nice expensive mecanum wheels during demonstrations on concrete; for a while there, we ran the bot with strips of carpet zip tied to the wheels as sacrificial treads. (We also ended up using the same carpet-tread technique a year later in '09, of course, to protect the FRC-mandated slick wheels!) |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I remember seeing a team that duck taped a cim on their robot. When I asked them why they did that they responded with "we ran out of gaff tape"
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
We brought our practice robot in pieces (drive base and ball manipulator) to the local library for drive practice (yes, our city library lets us drive the robot around! They're awesome!) and realized that we forgot the 3/8" spacer block for where the mechanism bolts onto the frame. The only tools we had brought were the basic ones we knew we needed to bolt the frame on, including an ample set of wrenches. Wrenches that were approximately 3/8" thick...
Fast-forward to a week or two later, and to this conversation: Me: "I need a 3/8" wrench." Other team member: "Uh..." Me: *searching toolbox* "I know we have one. More than one. Where are they?" Other team member: "Uh..." Me: "... they're all on the robot, aren't they." Other team member: "Yup." That same day I also found all of our small allen keys substituting for hitch pins, holding our bumpers in place. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Perhaps a better name for this thread would have been "Necessity is the mother of invention? "
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
I may not have been clear, but do you realize I was talking about 122's robot from the 1997 game, Toroid Terror? This was from before 122 even paired with New Horizons, I think it was with Phoebus High School, but it was so long ago I'm not even sure of that. Jeff Seaton or John Evans might be the only ones who remember anymore.
As I recall, the 1997 robot for 122 had a 36" square base, with the wheels oriented 45 degrees out of plane and a tall base for a two-linked arm so the robot was almost impossible to get through any doorways. The shoulder joint had some surgical tubing and what I'm pretty sure was the lead brick from the small parts catalog to help counter balance the crazy torque that arm had to deal with when delivering inner tubes. The 1998 robot was my first year, so looking at the prior year's, I just remember Ansel Butterfield describing what the parts were, so maybe I heard wrong or my memory is fuzzy after nearly 20 years. Quote:
|
Re: What is the most (SKETCHY) thing you've seen on a robot?
I have a story that probably qualifies as ghetto.
A few years ago, I was at a Regional with a large number of Rookie teams. On Friday morning, walking through the pits, I noticed one of the Rookie teams was charging their robot battery using alligator clips, while it was still plugged into the robot using the Anderson connector. It was one of the most cringeworthy things I've ever seen at an FRC Regional. Of course, they didn't know any better, so you can't really blame them. Now, one of the first things I look at when I visit a Rookie pit, is how they're charging their batteries. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Probably the most kludged-together robot I've seen was back in 2005. Kit frame. Electronics protection was a clear plastic tub upside down. Superstructure was a small stepladder. Arm was a single piece of PVC (not a bad option). The gripper, on the other hand, was a masterful piece of engineering: Needle-nose pliers (or was it a pair of dikes?), stuck into the end of the PVC pipe so the handles were out and slightly open. Talk about creative uses of materials... |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
All fixed for worlds though |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
At centerline last year there was a robot with a cornhole game on top of a kit bot frame. Still put up more points then anyone on our alliance.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Team 3928's can burglar from last year was pretty janky, we had to bend plastic (pvc?) pipe by using a heat-shrink gun between qualification and finals because one broke.:D
(It's the grey one in this picture) |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
On our current robot we have a potentiometer double sided taped to our chassis then a cut pen tube attaching it to the shaft. I'll see about getting a picture.
|
Re: What is the most (SKETCHY) thing you've seen on a robot?
We're using a garage door spring to help lift our arm and to slow it down when it comes down
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
On my test chassis I wanted a way to couple my enclosed rotary shaft encoders to the shaft on the AndyMark gear boxes. So we tie wrapped a piece of automotive hose around the shafts on either end making a 1 foot long flexible shaft coupler that goes back to a brace in the middle of the robot.
I was concerned it might slip but it does not. I was concerned the misalignment from end to end might cause it to lash, but it does not. It is janky (jenky sp?) and I like it. :D That's not quite as bad as the day a friend and I put a model airplane prop on a weed-whacker small engine clamped to my deck to test something. What could ->possibly<- go wrong there? (Leave that dumb trick to the professionals okay kids!) |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
At an off-season several years ago we had a motor sticking out the side of the robot's superstructure with wires in danger of being damaged by contacting other robots. After trying and failing to fashion a wire guard out of polycarb, we pulled an empty plastic soda bottle out of the trash, cut off the top, and zip-tied it around the end of the motor.
I have seen aluminum ladders cut into short sections and used as robot frame pieces. I don't know what category I'd put this one in: a rookie team at the 2014 Arkansas Regional used a mannequin leg as a kicker for Aerial Assist. They also had a lampshade they put over the top of the robot. |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
My next suggestion was a boot - they stopped taking my suggestions after that. :p |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
How about a box made of pegboard which was *made* to entrap the ball in the Hub City Regional of 2014? (it was affectionately known by all as "Fridgebot" and did exactly what was required of it... although it made a few people mad... and the referees had to make an improv move on entrapment, but still! it was awesome! (so creative, they were)
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Handyman Corner Red attempted to demonstrate creative and often humorous ways to tackle relatively common tasks, such as taking out the trash or making use of derelict cars, or to create something extravagant out of whatever he could get his hands on. Memorable examples included a paddlewheeler made out of a van on pallets and a revolving door, a jetpack made from two propane tanks, a hybrid car from recycled golf carts and satellite dishes, and a kiddie ride made from a bar stool attached to the agitator of a washing machine. Duct tape, "the handyman's secret weapon," was almost always the fastener of choice. In one episode, he tried to duct tape the Ontario-Quebec border as a potential solution to Quebec separatism. The segment customarily concluded with the aphorism "If the women don't find you handsome, they should at least find you handy." Whenever you find yourself over engineering, I just ask myself can this be done with a some piece of junk I've got laying somewhere :) ![]() |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Not sure if this qualifies as sketchy/janky, but I have to bring up what our team has dubbed "chairbot" from 2014
https://imgur.com/bHhtJpb |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
On our robot at the Greater Toronto central regional the screws holding a cim into a transmission were loose. Needless to say we didn't have enough time to fix it properly so we used pieces of scrap metal, zip ties and about a half roll of duct tape to hold it in place.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
In 2013 we were prototyping a shooter and ran out of hubs for Banebot wheels and ended up wrapping a cim shaft in duct tape and pressing the wheel on. Needless to say the design didn't work, partially to the wheel we used and a shabby structure and partially to the uncentered rotation of the wheel.
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Catcher only or could it shoot too? (Don't know the rules too well rookie year was 2015) |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
Example of it earning a possession in a match (so it is much more than a mere defense bot). |
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
Re: What is the most ghetto thing you've seen on a robot?
Quote:
|
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 14:56. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi