Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Extra Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=151917)

jlbimson 17-10-2016 10:31

pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 

bcampbell 17-10-2016 10:32

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
How did you manufacture the gear teeth on the turret and the variable angle ball holder? What kind of tolerances were you able to hold?

jlbimson 17-10-2016 10:55

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bcampbell (Post 1612105)
How did you manufacture the gear teeth on the turret and the variable angle ball holder? What kind of tolerances were you able to hold?

One of our sponsors does laser/water jet cutting for us. The tolerances are pretty tight, but the teeth mesh very nicely with the other gears. The turret did end up having a little bit of slop in the gearbox, but not too bad.

AdamHeard 17-10-2016 11:13

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
We've waterjetted many 20 and 24 dp gears over the years at exact size without issue.

254's turret this year was water cut.

148 does a fair amount on laser.

gc_coxen 17-10-2016 11:52

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Very interested how this turns out. What drove the decision to make a turret catapult?

bkahl 17-10-2016 11:59

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Not only is this catapult on a turret, the ball cradle slides for different shot trajectories...

#TSIMFD

frcguy 17-10-2016 12:03

Few things:

1. You guys aren't using it at CCC? Thought this was going to be one of the 3 you all are playing with.

2. How does it intake?

Anyways, this thing is hands-down awesome. Even if it's not done, you should still bring it to CCC so we all can see it in person!

jlbimson 17-10-2016 12:06

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gc_coxen (Post 1612118)
Very interested how this turns out. What drove the decision to make a turret catapult?

We wanted to try some mechanisms that we had never tried before, and the programmers wanted to work more with vision. A lot of the reasoning behind our decisions was "because we can."

Knufire 17-10-2016 12:31

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Could we get another picture of the bearing setup on the turret? :)

AdamHeard 17-10-2016 12:32

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Knufire (Post 1612130)
Could we get another picture of the bearing setup on the turret? :)

It's the same as what 254 did for season, a 1601-washer-r3-washer-1601 stackup on a #10. This rides on a 1/4" plate (or 3/16" if no washer).

Iteration of what 1323 did in 2012 but w/ smaller bearings.

jwfoss 17-10-2016 13:04

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Looks like 1678 caught a little bit of the small robot fever for the offseason. Can't wait to see some pictures of the completed robot.

Justin Montois 17-10-2016 13:41

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quick glance told me it was a swerve drive ;)

Looks cool. Interested to see how the intake works.

Michael Corsetto 17-10-2016 14:46

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by frcguy (Post 1612123)
Few things:

1. You guys aren't using it at CCC? Thought this was going to be one of the 3 you all are playing with.

2. How does it intake?

Anyways, this thing is hands-down awesome. Even if it's not done, you should still bring it to CCC so we all can see it in person!

1. Not at CCC. We will only be competing with one bot at CCC. Our 2016 Adrian practice bot will be driven by team 299. The rest of our students are volunteering.

2. Intake is mostly assembled, not mounted though. There are other mechanisms still missing as well!

Maybe we'll bring it to CCC, but we have a lot of other stuff to do just to make the event happen!

Thanks,

-Mike

wajirock 17-10-2016 14:58

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
That is a very nice looking robot! How is the catapult powered? I don't think I see any pneumatics or elastic tubing. Is it motor driven?

Cothron Theiss 17-10-2016 15:09

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
I'm just curious as to what that thingamabob is in the corner. Were your machinists bored?

AdamHeard 17-10-2016 15:10

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cothron Theiss (Post 1612176)
I'm just curious as to what that thingamabob is in the corner. Were your machinists bored?

That's a Turner's Cube.

frcguy 17-10-2016 15:13

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 1612177)
That's a Turner's Cube.

Devin's pride and joy.

jlbimson 17-10-2016 15:38

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wajirock (Post 1612173)
That is a very nice looking robot! How is the catapult powered? I don't think I see any pneumatics or elastic tubing. Is it motor driven?

The catapult will be powered by both surgical tubing and pneumatic cylinders. We just haven't mounted them yet.

Andrew_L 17-10-2016 15:47

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Looks gorgeous, hopefully one day I can dive into the CAD of this thing.

Gotta ask though, what's with the giant rivets?

Bryce2471 17-10-2016 15:53

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Awesome looking bot! I can't wait to see the final product.

How will you access the electronics for maintenance or repair?

PS. Love the random things in the rest of this photo

ollien 17-10-2016 16:10

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
*snip*

AlexanderLuke 17-10-2016 16:11

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jlbimson (Post 1612124)
A lot of the reasoning behind our decisions was "because we can."

That reasoning has led you this far, and it looks stunning. Did any prototyping in the offseason go into this, or did you perhaps test a catapult during the build season?

I would love to see some more pictures from different angles, or maybe even a video once it is operational :D


Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew_L (Post 1612187)
hopefully one day I can dive into the CAD of this thing.

+1.

niklas674 17-10-2016 16:16

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
This robot is absolutely beautiful. I hope y'all will show it off at ccc. I'd love to see it.

jlbimson 17-10-2016 16:26

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andrew_L (Post 1612187)
Gotta ask though, what's with the giant rivets?

We got those by accident during the season, and are just trying to get rid of them.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryce2471 (Post 1612190)
How will you access the electronics for maintenance or repair?

The entire turret assembly (and everything on it) can be unbolted from the drivetrain, but the electronics are a huge pain to access.

Quote:

Originally Posted by AlexanderLuke (Post 1612199)
That reasoning has led you this far, and it looks stunning. Did any prototyping in the offseason go into this, or did you perhaps test a catapult during the build season?

I would love to see some more pictures from different angles, or maybe even a video once it is operational :D

We did a couple of weeks of prototyping in June, but the rest was done in CAD over the summer. I will upload more pictures when we finish it, along with some other specs.

wesleyac 17-10-2016 16:37

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryce2471 (Post 1612190)
How will you access the electronics for maintenance or repair?

With great difficulty and possibly tears :P

The electronics on this bot are pretty crazy, given how small it is. We ended up needing to mount the PCM on the turret, because it won't fit elsewhere.

Quote:

Originally Posted by bkahl
Not only is this catapult on a turret, the ball cradle slides for different shot trajectories...

You're seeing one of the two independent shot adjustment mechanisms ;)

RoboChair 17-10-2016 16:49

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cothron Theiss (Post 1612176)
I'm just curious as to what that thingamabob is in the corner. Were your machinists bored?

My boredom and associated hijinks are the stuff of legend.

bkahl 17-10-2016 16:51

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wesleyac (Post 1612209)
You're seeing one of the two independent shot adjustment mechanisms ;)

I assume an adjustable hard stop? I don't think the adjustable cradle is enough with a single throw length to get a fender shot, and considering I see what appears to be a mount for spring assist, you'll need/want some kind of Hardstop. Maybe that's what the empty pocket in the plate the catapult rotates around is for? A VP to adjust the throw?

Everytime I've looked at this picture (a lot of times) I've noticed something cooler. My favorite part may be that the catapult is offset by ~30 degrees on the turret to allow for a longer lever arm.

This robot is all about the little details, pun intended.

RoboChair 17-10-2016 17:08

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bkahl (Post 1612211)
I assume an adjustable hard stop? I don't think the adjustable cradle is enough with a single throw length to get a fender shot, and considering I see what appears to be a mount for spring assist, you'll need/want some kind of Hardstop. Maybe that's what the empty pocket in the plate the catapult rotates around is for? A VP to adjust the throw?

Everytime I've looked at this picture (a lot of times) I've noticed something cooler. My favorite part may be that the catapult is offset by 30 degrees on the turret to allow for a longer lever arm.

This robot is all about the little details, pun intended.

Yes, there is an adjustable hard stop that uses a custom tiny disc brake. At least that's how I understand it is going to be.

Bluman56 17-10-2016 18:18

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RoboChair (Post 1612217)
Yes, there is an adjustable hard stop that uses a custom tiny disc brake. At least that's how I understand it is going to be.

Has 1678 bought up the world supply of disc brakes? You guys sure do love that stuff :P

I'd love to see this up close (as I'm sure others would as well) so I'm curious if the team would be able to show some of the details that we might not otherwise catch in photos like these. It would be a fantastic learning experience.

Otherwise, wicked cool stuff! Props to the team for the hard work over the summer.

Bryce2471 17-10-2016 19:49

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Did you build a functional prototype of the catapult with all these articulations?
I get the feeling that building the prototype would be a major challenge in itself, probably worthy of CAD.

nuclearnerd 17-10-2016 23:48

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
I'm guessing one of the missing mechanisms is something to hold the ball in the arm cup when driving? Or does the intake do that as well? Can't wait to see the whole thing - please make a release video!

Harrison.Smith 18-10-2016 01:08

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by nuclearnerd (Post 1612272)
I'm guessing one of the missing mechanisms is something to hold the ball in the arm cup when driving? Or does the intake do that as well? Can't wait to see the whole thing - please make a release video!

A release video would be sweet!

This robot is looking awesome I cannot imagine the headaches y'all had fitting everything in a size similar to Mittens, but without the arm. Looking forward to seeing this at Madtown.

DaveL 18-10-2016 01:28

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
The things that caught my eye are the compact compressor bracket and the wheels.

It looks like you cut openings in the polycarb and then bent it.
How did you bend it? Was it heated in an oven and then put into a form?

On the wheels, they look worn down. Did you sand off tread to make it turn easier?

Dave

jlbimson 18-10-2016 10:23

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bryce2471 (Post 1612235)
Did you build a functional prototype of the catapult with all these articulations?

We built a catapult prototype, but not with the adjustable stop, scoop, or turret.
Quote:

Originally Posted by nuclearnerd (Post 1612272)
I'm guessing one of the missing mechanisms is something to hold the ball in the arm cup when driving? Or does the intake do that as well?

There will be a pair of omni wheels that help to hold the ball in place, and pivot downwards when firing.
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveL (Post 1612292)
It looks like you cut openings in the polycarb and then bent it.
How did you bend it? Was it heated in an oven and then put into a form?

On the wheels, they look worn down. Did you sand off tread to make it turn easier?

We cut the polycarb on our CNC router and made the bends using a heat gun and a press/break. The wheels are just used ones from the season, nothing special.

marshall 18-10-2016 10:24

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jlbimson (Post 1612203)
We got those by accident during the season, and are just trying to get rid of them.

Got a part number or link to them? I haven't seen those before but they look intriguing.

Knufire 18-10-2016 11:55

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Blind Rivet Supply sells a wide assortment, they'll be labeled as "large flange" rivets.


RoboChair 18-10-2016 12:20

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jlbimson (Post 1612329)
We built a catapult prototype, but not with the adjustable stop, scoop, or turret.

Well, we did prototype the adjustable scoop, just as a manual adjustment.

Quote:

Originally Posted by marshall (Post 1612330)
Got a part number or link to them? I haven't seen those before but they look intriguing.


Fastenal
is where we got them.

araniaraniratul 19-10-2016 01:15

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Definitely a swing away from the usual simple swiss knife style, but I love it. Wish I could be at Madtown!

araniaraniratul 19-10-2016 01:19

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by DaveL (Post 1612292)
The things that caught my eye are the compact compressor bracket and the wheels.

It looks like you cut openings in the polycarb and then bent it.
How did you bend it? Was it heated in an oven and then put into a form?

On the wheels, they look worn down. Did you sand off tread to make it turn easier?

Dave

You know you've made it big when people assume every imperfection is genius!

Bryce2471 12-11-2016 18:11

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
I intended to watch this robot play at Madtown, but I apparently tuned in too late.
How did it turn out? What were the learning experiences?

T^2 12-11-2016 18:24

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
It was pretty terrible

frcguy 12-11-2016 19:52

Quote:

Originally Posted by T^2 (Post 1616041)
It was pretty terrible


That's a little harsh. While it didn't perform fantastically, I still thought it was a phenomenal piece of engineering and thoroughly enjoyed seeing it.

jlbimson 12-11-2016 21:10

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by frcguy (Post 1616056)
That's a little harsh. While it didn't perform fantastically, I still thought it was a phenomenal piece of engineering and thoroughly enjoyed seeing it.

Not harsh at all, as it seriously didn’t work. I’m going to post a render and more details, including lessons learned, sometime next week.

ollien 12-11-2016 21:20

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jlbimson (Post 1616060)
Not harsh at all, as it seriously didn’t work. I’m going to post a render and more details, including lessons learned, sometime next week.

Would you mind posting a model of that compressor bracket? I'd love to 3d print one of those.

Bluman56 12-11-2016 21:25

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jlbimson (Post 1616060)
Not harsh at all, as it seriously didn’t work. I’m going to post a render and more details, including lessons learned, sometime next week.

Seems like it was geared really fast. Was this the case or was there just no ramping code?

billbo911 13-11-2016 11:25

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by frcguy (Post 1616056)
... I still thought it was a phenomenal piece of engineering and thoroughly enjoyed seeing it.

Nick's assessment is right on the money! It is stunning to see what has been built into such a tiny chassis.

Granted, Lemon Drop did not perform up to the level we have come to expect from 1678, it certainly does meet their engineeding capabilities.
I have little doubt that if they continue to refine the drive code, it will be exactly what you would expect from them!

asid61 13-11-2016 14:20

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jlbimson (Post 1616060)
Not harsh at all, as it seriously didn’t work. I’m going to post a render and more details, including lessons learned, sometime next week.

After watching it on stream, it looked like it only had a few small errors that knocked it out of the game, rather than a failure of the overall design.

AnthonyDV 13-11-2016 15:33

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bluman56 (Post 1616063)
Seems like it was geared really fast. Was this the case or was there just no ramping code?

The robot was about 80% done. Building the bot took longer than expected which left the programmers without any time to test their code. The robot's new drive code was not ready so we wrote tank drive code in between matches. Tank drive, a short wheel base, and new drivers who did not have any driver practice contributed to the lack of control. The lack of time to test and find bugs also cause the robot to destroy itself.

tickspe15 13-11-2016 18:35

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
..

Basel A 13-11-2016 18:56

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AnthonyDV (Post 1616126)
The robot was about 80% done. Building the bot took longer than expected which left the programmers without any time to test their code. The robot's new drive code was not ready so we wrote tank drive code in between matches. Tank drive, a short wheel base, and new drivers who did not have any driver practice contributed to the lack of control. The lack of time to test and find bugs also cause the robot to destroy itself.

So basically, you got a taste of what an average FRC team's season is like? :P

AlexanderLuke 13-11-2016 19:43

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
While we wait for more updates from the folks on 1678, perhaps someone who went to the Madtown event could share some additional close-up pictures of this robot with the rest of us? :D

frcguy 13-11-2016 20:16

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AlexanderLuke (Post 1616156)
While we wait for more updates from the folks on 1678, perhaps someone who went to the Madtown event could share some additional close-up pictures of this robot with the rest of us? :D

Happy to!



Here it is being worked on in their pit.



While this is a photo of when it flipped, that's not why I took it and am sharing it. It shows the packaging on the bottom of the robot really well. Look at the spacing between those MiniCIMs :ahh:!

Lil' Lavery 13-11-2016 23:41

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Are those Talons/Victors attached to anything, or simply being held in place by wire tension? :confused:

jlbimson 14-11-2016 12:10

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Lil' Lavery (Post 1616176)
Are those Talons/Victors attached to anything, or simply being held in place by wire tension? :confused:

The ones on the bottom are zip-tied to the bellypan. We have a couple more on top of the bellypan that are pretty much just stuffed under the turret.

jwfoss 22-11-2016 10:39

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Inquiring minds would love to see more details on this. Maybe its just me but the complexity of this machine seems like a change from the typical 1678 design mentality. Just pushing the boundaries for the "offseason"?

bkahl 22-11-2016 10:47

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jwfoss (Post 1617276)
Inquiring minds would love to see more details on this. Maybe its just me but the complexity of this machine seems like a change from the typical 1678 design mentality. Just pushing the boundaries for the "offseason"?

To be fair, the same argument could be made for their 2016 in-season bot. It was pretty complicated with the rotating, telescoping arm.

I think it's probably a product of lots of experience gained over the past few years and some increased resources that have brought their build techniques to the next level.

Whatever it may be, 1678 never ceases to put out MFD designs, and I love it.

Michael Corsetto 23-11-2016 12:35

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jwfoss (Post 1617276)
Inquiring minds would love to see more details on this. Maybe its just me but the complexity of this machine seems like a change from the typical 1678 design mentality. Just pushing the boundaries for the "offseason"?

Justin,

I think the kids are working to tidy up the CAD and get it out so people can take a better look at what went into the design.

First, there definitely was a desire to push the boundaries and see what the current group of students was capable of. The packaging was really intense, and took a lot of whiteboard sessions to figure most of it out.

We also got to try out 5-6 different mechanisms the team hasn't designed before, which was valuable experience. This has paid off for us in past years, so we thought we'd continue trying new mechanisms in the offseason, but built in the "1678 style".

Lastly, this process highlighted some of the general areas we can improve on in the next 1.5 months. With new students every year, there will invariably be strengths and weaknesses in their design, assembly, programming and project management skills (to name a few!). Going through something like this allows mentors like me to better focus my energies on growing students in the ways they need to develop, in order to work as a cohesive unit come January.

We'll find out soon enough if the efforts paid off!

-Mike

Monochron 23-11-2016 13:37

Re: pic: 1678 Offseason Robot Progress
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Michael Corsetto (Post 1617400)
Going through something like this allows mentors like me to better focus my energies on growing students in the ways they need to develop, in order to work as a cohesive unit come January.

Separate from all the cool engineering, I would love to hear more about how you worked on this. How to develop students is something we are always looking to improve on.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:32.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi