Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   How to get gears fast (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=153372)

Flashback0902 10-01-2017 10:15

How to get gears fast
 
Go to the enemy player station and beg for a gear until they give you one or you get a foul. Or you can cooperate with the other team before the match and give gears to each other.

ImpeachedCat629 10-01-2017 10:23

Re: How to get gears fast
 
I believe one way, which most teams are probably thinking of, is to be capable of receiving gears from the loading station and get across the field in 4-6 seconds with being able to place the gear in at most 3 seconds

Richard Wallace 10-01-2017 11:20

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flashback0902 (Post 1628513)
Go to the enemy player station and beg for a gear until they give you one or you get a foul. Or you can cooperate with the other team before the match and give gears to each other.

Begging Robot: Please give me a gear.

Gear Ninja: NO GEARS FOR YOU!

-----

Ubiquity 10-01-2017 14:44

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flashback0902 (Post 1628513)
Go to the enemy player station and beg for a gear until they give you one or you get a foul. Or you can cooperate with the other team before the match and give gears to each other.

Isn't going into the opponent loading station a violation?

engunneer 10-01-2017 14:47

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ubiquity (Post 1628722)
Isn't going into the opponent loading station a violation?

only if their robot is present. it's worth knowing these rules.

you can't sit in your opponent's key (shooting area near boiler) for 5 seconds, but the limit on loading zone is based on hitting an opponent.

SenorZ 10-01-2017 14:53

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Collusion:
Each alliance agrees to scoot the 18 gears into the opponent's driver station. They now belong to the opponent alliance.

bdaroz 10-01-2017 14:54

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Flashback0902 (Post 1628513)
Go to the enemy player station and beg for a gear until they give you one or you get a foul. Or you can cooperate with the other team before the match and give gears to each other.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Ubiquity (Post 1628722)
Isn't going into the opponent loading station a violation?

The only rule I can find applies to being in the KEY, not the LOADING STATION. Also the loading rules aren't ALLIANCE color specific.

This also doesn't seem to break the conduct rules (eg C01/C02) as it's not used to 'throw' a match, if the action is reciprocated (eg both teams can use the other team's loading station).

I would also expect Q&A to nuke this.

markmcgary 10-01-2017 14:57

Re: How to get gears fast
 
I expect some red or blue tape to be added to the gears. You can only score your alliance color gears. Reminds me of the noodles.

engunneer 10-01-2017 14:57

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bdaroz (Post 1628729)
The only rule I can find applies to being in the KEY, not the LOADING STATION. Also the loading rules aren't ALLIANCE color specific.

This also doesn't seem to break the conduct rules (eg C01/C02) as it's not used to 'throw' a match, if the action is reciprocated (eg both teams can use the other team's loading station).

I would also expect Q&A to nuke this.

If one team is asking the other team on a different alliance to change how they play to make it easier for everyone, that is specifically against C02 and C03. I do expect Q&A to address this.

rlance 10-01-2017 15:26

Re: How to get gears fast
 
In the heat of battle the other alliance might slide a gear into your robot if they aren't paying attention to what color you are.

bdaroz 10-01-2017 15:36

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by engunneer (Post 1628732)
If one team is asking the other team on a different alliance to change how they play to make it easier for everyone, that is specifically against C02 and C03. I do expect Q&A to address this.

Quote:

C02 - Asking other Teams to throw a MATCH – not cool. A Team may not encourage an ALLIANCE, of which it is not a member, to play beneath its ability.

C03 - Letting someone coerce you in to throwing a MATCH – also not cool. A Team, as the result of encouragement by a Team not on their ALLIANCE, may not play beneath its ability.
These are talking about one-sided events - throwing a match. If both alliances agree, it's an equally competitive strategy, not throwing the match.

Kartoffee 10-01-2017 15:38

Re: How to get gears fast
 
THE RESURRECTION OF THE NOODLE ALLIANCE!!

In all reality though, good idea. I think that FIRST won't like the collusion, because it means that some teams won't have heard the idea and will be punished for it.

While I hope to use this myself, I don't think it will be allowed.

Good luck all!

engunneer 10-01-2017 15:40

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by bdaroz (Post 1628761)
These are talking about one-sided events - throwing a match. If both alliances agree, it's an equally competitive strategy, not throwing the match.

for them to agree, one must start the conversation, which entails one team asking the other if they agree with X. Therefore, one team is asking the other to X, even if they already know about X and agree willingly. The asker is breaking one rule, and the other team is breaking the other.

It's pretty clear that this strategy is against the intent of the rules.

Doug Frisk 10-01-2017 15:44

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Pretty sure this strategy would net both alliances a red card under H07.

engunneer 10-01-2017 15:49

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Actually, Doug's point about H07 made me re-read H08 which explicitly forbids this strategy. H07 only prevents someone from leaving their zone, but does not prevent the "gear donating" alliance from sliding game pieces to the "gear receiving" alliance over the line.

H08 specifically does prevent this action, so we don't even need Q&A clarification any more. this "strategy" causes the donating alliance to "deliberately cause GAME PIECES to leave" their loading lane via a parth not allowed in the 3 point rule.

Quote:

A. during TELEOP,
B. by a HUMAN PLAYER or DRIVER, and
C. through a LOADING STATION slot.

RoboChair 10-01-2017 15:52

Re: How to get gears fast
 
H08 prohibits the ability to pass the gears into the opposing Alliance Station from your Loading Lane. However it does not prevent you from loading gears into the robots of the Opposing Alliance.

frodobaggins05 10-01-2017 19:37

Re: How to get gears fast
 
The first person has no idea what he is talking about. The other team is NOT going to give you their gear!

frodobaggins05 10-01-2017 19:39

Re: How to get gears fast
 
this is NOT going to happen!

pipsqueaker 10-01-2017 21:31

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ImpeachedCat629 (Post 1628520)
I believe one way, which most teams are probably thinking of, is to be capable of receiving gears from the loading station and get across the field in 4-6 seconds with being able to place the gear in at most 3 seconds

This estimate seems very optimistic to me, especially when you consider defense. In fact I think gear bots will be a very attractive target for defense even during qualification matches this year

Caleb Sykes 10-01-2017 23:46

Re: How to get gears fast
 
I like how working with the other alliance to earn mutually beneficial ranking points in some years is considered "coopertition" and working with the other alliance to earn mutually beneficial ranking points in other years is considered "collusion."

I think I'll just go on the offensive and tell teams they are not in the spirit of coopertition if they don't want to work with me. :rolleyes:

EricH 11-01-2017 01:04

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Caleb Sykes (Post 1629051)
I like how working with the other alliance to earn mutually beneficial ranking points in some years is considered "coopertition" and working with the other alliance to earn mutually beneficial ranking points in other years is considered "collusion."

I think I'll just go on the offensive and tell teams they are not in the spirit of coopertition if they don't want to work with me. :rolleyes:

It depends on the game, the scenario, and if it's designed in. 2015 is a prime example. The Coopertition totes were the "allowed and approved" method. The noodles were something the teams came up with, and the GDC nerfed it. In 2016 there really wasn't anything. 2012 had the coop bridge, which had its own collusions...

Basically, if it's part of the game challenge and designed in as such, it's coopertition. If it's not part of the original game challenge, it's collusion. (Not official definitions, just what I've observed the reactions being.)

BeardyMentor 12-01-2017 06:51

Re: How to get gears fast
 
2015 was a weird animal because of how ranking worked. I would not expect to see anything like the noodle agreement this year. One team getting the gear ranking point does not benefit the other team at all. Additionally, a team getting all four rotors running is going to result in a lot of points potentially winning the match and depriving their opponents of 2 ranking points. Unlike in 2015 where ranking was entirely based off of average match score. Your ranking was almost independent of your opponents score. This is not true this year where the largest component(50%) of your ranking is the relative score. Helping your opponents during a match to score points is not going to be beneficial to you this year.

Boltman 12-01-2017 14:38

Re: How to get gears fast
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pipsqueaker (Post 1628970)
This estimate seems very optimistic to me, especially when you consider defense. In fact I think gear bots will be a very attractive target for defense even during qualification matches this year

Not only that its back and forth ..... possibly 6 sec +2 but another 6sec +2 and another 6sec + 2 before another cycle... thats 24 seconds not to mention defense and sight.

In weeks 1 and 2 , I expect a dedicated good gear bot to place about 3 gears max successfully before endgame climb....

later season Top teams might be able to 7 or 8 before climb

Brandon_L 12-01-2017 15:28

Re: How to get gears fast
 
the noodle agreement all over

Akash Shah 12-01-2017 16:35

Re: How to get gears fast
 
I honestly feel that a floor pickup could be the fastest way to get a gear. Also, opens up the opportunity for a *cough* 3 gear autonomous ;) .


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:00.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi