Like Device
 

What do you think they mean by like device:confused:

What does this refer to?

device
 

First has recently said that tape measures ans other like devices are not allowed on the robots

What do you think that they mean by like devices :confused:

How about spring steel?
 

Maybe they mean things that unroll themselves when given the opportunity to do so?

Joe J.

No, I believe that means anything that has any chance of getting entangled *which I can easily see a tape measurer getting entangled.* So if you were to use spring steel along with a solid, stiff structure, I don't see any problem.

So:

Rule of thumb. If there is ANY way you can see a device getting entangled, take it of your robot.

I was suggestion that a coil of spring steel is a "like device" which means it too would be illegal.

I agree with you that FIRST is going to disallow anything that has a chance of getting entangled in another robot.

We shall see.

Joe J.

up to the judges and referee
 

Basically, FIRST is going to use common sense for this. And it will be up to the inspectors when they are inspecting in the pit area and up to the referee from match to match. (Still waiting to be briefed before the regional competition for guide-lines when doing inspections as an inspector. Don¡¦t worry, I will be as tough as any inspector can get. ;) )

As soon as they see that part of your robot extending out have a possibly of getting stuck, they will call it illegal. So, avoid using anything long and flexible, or sticky, or have risks of getting caught in sharp edges. You have to imagine all sort of possible situation for your device to be entangled in.

I think it will end up a match to match decision, since most teams will try really hard to make their devices not likely to create entanglement.

So make sure you use something solid and strong. A bunch of telescoping tubing should be safe... a triple-folded should be too...

An arm with Velcro or tapes (sticky side out) or little hooks probably isn't legal. If you have little rubber band sticking out, even just one, it¡¦s probably at a risk of entanglement¡K You get the idea.

I have a feeling that this ruling will be different from place to place. Especially if the device is right in the middle between legal and illegal, and the inspector is having a hard time. Some inspectors will be easy going and let the robot off the hook... some inspectors won't be as lenient. I believe a lot of robots will past inspection, and will be left to the referee to make the call.

Considering the number of matches, the intensity of matches, and the randomness of what teams will be doing, I really think that the extension will face plenty of challenges during qualifying rounds to determine if it is legal or not. So, make sure ALL parts of your robot is robust enough, including something really light that will extend with 8 seconds left in the match about 20 feet, with no other robot to bother it.

And make sure your extension DOESN¡¦T fall out when you don¡¦t want it to. Have it lock in place really hard before you want it to extend out.

By the way, I think a lot of teams will get away by only releasing the extension the last 7~8 seconds. The less the referee see the device extended, the less likely it will be called on, even though FIRST say they will treat the extension as being released at ANYTIME during a match.