Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Off-Season Events (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=20)
-   -   Getting a headstart? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=28298)

Bcahn836 29-04-2004 19:13

Getting a headstart?
 
I was just wondering what does your team do to get a headstart on next years competition?

We were thinking about developing a 4wd drive train using the chips, and try to get the most efficiency out of the motors.

phrontist 29-04-2004 21:38

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bcahn836
I was just wondering what does your team do to get a headstart on next years competition?

We were thinking about developing a 4wd drive train using the chips, and try to get the most efficiency out of the motors.

Yeah, I've been thinking about this too. Here is a list of stuff I've undertaken during the offseason.

*Recruit!!! :ahh:
*Learn as much as possible about PIC programming, as I want to have quite a bit of extra processing done next year
*Buy/Research/Fiddle with Sensors
*Look for sponsors
*Make a small IR tracking robot, based on this years game. (I didn't get to do it this year, they forgot the parts when they shipped the kit :( )
*Make a general purpose control box with a multitude of switches, knobs, etc.
*Research a new navigational system idea (not my own) that uses an optical mouse with an adjusted focal length to measure movement.
*Convince the tech-staff (who dislike me ;) ) to let me reformat the laptop they gave the team and install linux!

Marc P. 29-04-2004 21:43

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
I have mixed feelings here. On the one hand, it's necessary to hone one's skills in terms of programming, design, etc. On the other, there's only 6 weeks in the build period for a reason...

I only hope that whatever anyone does in the off-season, they keep Gracious Professionalism in mind, and no one gets started designing/building a robot before the game for next season is even revealed
:cool:

Cory 29-04-2004 22:08

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Don't kid yourself. Every great team starts designing stuff they can use during the build season during the summer and fall. If teams didnt do this, the level of innovation would be far lower than it currently is.

P.S. Why does everyone like to throw gracious professionalism around? It's become a catchphrase more than anything else, imho. Please tell me why it is ungracious and unprofessional to teach students the principles behind drivetrains, mechanisms, programming, etc. Why is it ungracious to have a knowledgebase to work from when the season starts? If you don't work during the offseason, *you're* missing out. You don't get to learn. You dont get to try new ideas.

Do you have any idea how many teams you just called ungracious unprofessional cheaters?

Cory

Marc P. 29-04-2004 22:14

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cory
Don't kid yourself. Every great team starts designing stuff they can use during the build season during the summer and fall. If teams didnt do this, the level of innovation would be far lower than it currently is.

Cory

Design is perfectly fine. But I do worry when a design becomes a fully assembled mechanism, waiting only for the robot controller and motors from the kit. Sort of defeats the purpose of having only 6 weeks.

Arefin Bari 29-04-2004 22:35

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Bcahn836
We were thinking about developing a 4wd drive train using the chips, and try to get the most efficiency out of the motors.

if you need help with the drive train let me know... i got some ideas...

ngreen 29-04-2004 22:38

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Marc P.
Design is perfectly fine. But I do worry when a design becomes a fully assembled mechanism, waiting only for the robot controller and motors from the kit. Sort of defeats the purpose of having only 6 weeks.

Many of these become fully assembled mechanism for testing. This is perfectly fine. There are rules against using parts built outside of the 6 week period and I can't think of a case where someone has broken them. People use the summer to build there knowledge for the next season. Read some whitepapers to learn more about different teams ideas. Many of them are designed and tested during the summer. I personally plan to learn more C programming, work on a new drive for next year, work on something possibly showing different applications of pneumatics and possible thought for next year, and maybe research and test new materials to try and use next year.

dez250 29-04-2004 22:49

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
one thing i would reccommend to do is train the students interested in the electrical side of the robot. This seems to be the area i have found that there isnt time once build starts you will have time to train people in. One major thing i would reccommend is take a past robot and strip it of its electrical components (wires, victors, spikes, cables, etc...) and after training the students in learning how to wire it, give them a box of the removed parts (or new parts if you have ample supplies) and ask them to try to wire as much as they can (with or with out your help). I know the biggest learning came when i was asked to help rewire an old bot i never worked with from 3 years ago last year.

Marc P. 29-04-2004 22:51

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ngreen
Many of these become fully assembled mechanism for testing. This is perfectly fine. There are rules against using parts built outside of the 6 week period and I can't think of a case where someone has broken them. People use the summer to build there knowledge for the next season. Read some whitepapers to learn more about different teams ideas. Many of them are designed and tested during the summer. I personally plan to learn more C programming, work on a new drive for next year, work on something possibly showing different applications of pneumatics and possible thought for next year, and maybe research and test new materials to try and use next year.

Of course, it's a great thing to further your knowledge in the off season, but the reason I bring it up is I've heard multiple reports of a team that builds their entire actual robot drive train before kickoff, and just waits for the kit to plug in the motors, the robot controller, and whatever item the game would require them to build, so they end up with a full robot in less than 2 weeks. Sort of irritated me to hear about that, but I guess everyone will play the game their way.

I don't mean to sound negative at all, I just hope people keep gracious professionalism in mind. I plan to use the (object formerly known as edubot) to improve my understanding of C, and I've been closly following all the discussions about new drive trains, and may play with a few things myself.

Cory 29-04-2004 23:01

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Marc P.
I've heard multiple reports of a team that builds their entire actual robot drive train before kickoff, and just waits for the kit to plug in the motors, the robot controller, and whatever item the game would require them to build, so they end up with a full robot in less than 2 weeks.

Well then you shouldn't believe everything you hear.

I heard some team removed their robot from the pits at nats so they could work on it at night!

I heard someone saw a robot being taken inside a hotel!

But I don't believe any of it unless I saw it with my own eyes :)

Luckily most people are honest enough not to do what you describe. A few teams have the resources to take a set of plans and hand them to a shop, and get the finished parts for say a gearbox, arm, etc in the timeframe you just described. Doesn't mean they cheated though :)

Cory

Max Lobovsky 29-04-2004 23:05

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by phrontist
*Research a new navigational system idea (not my own) that uses an optical mouse with an adjusted focal length to measure movement.

Excellent, excellent idea. That's one of those things that you reall think, "why didn't i think of that." Now i have a new thing to waste hours a day searching on the internet about. Interfacing a mouse (or part of its hardware) will be a challenge, but wow, that would be cool.

sanddrag 30-04-2004 02:27

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cory
Do you have any idea how many teams you just called ungracious unprofessional cheaters?

Perhaps you meant maliciously amateure? :D Anyway, yeah. Most of the rumors about teams are untrue. And if anyone/ any team does have maliciously amateur practices, all I care about is that I'm not a part of it. If they don't want to be graciously professional, that is their own choice, it does not concern me nor should it concern anyone else. Just everyone do your best to be a gracious professionalist.

Now, for the issue of building things over the summer and whatnot. I can pretty much just second what Cory said. Nobody uses custom pre-built stuff on a competition robot and learning by doing no matter what time of the year it is, is both gracious and professional. That is how technology advances.

Travis Covington 30-04-2004 02:51

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dez250
One major thing i would reccommend is take a past robot and strip it of its electrical components (wires, victors, spikes, cables, etc...) and after training the students in learning how to wire it, give them a box of the removed parts (or new parts if you have ample supplies) and ask them to try to wire as much as they can (with or with out your help).

Never!!! ;) Those of you who know me understand where I am coming from...

But I DO have to agree with this point. Re-wiring the robot, or possibly better, starting from scratch with just some motors on a board and wiring that up completely, loading the program, and admiring your work is a HUGE help later on down the road during the 6 week build period. The students will really enjoy building something from scratch... especially the elctrical stuff, because once the program is loaded, it will actually work remotely without having to touch the wires of the motors to the battery terminals! (yeah, we do that too! shhhh!)

Training members before the 6 week build period is probably the single most important thing ANY team can do.

Ali Ahmed 30-04-2004 03:14

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
We are going to add somethings to the robot that we could not do during the build season becuase it might have been against the weight rules and such. We let the newer members do that so they can learn. the more vetren members, like me, will be coming up with a prototype gearbox with team 60 and 254. the reason teams come up with a drive train before kickoff is because that is all you can actually do that can potentially be used on the bot. Sometimes you can't even do that. Foe example, last year nobody knew that they were going to change from 5/8th drills to 1/2 drills or give 2 Atwoods instead of 1 like the year before. But I highly doubt some teams will actually build the drive before and really put that one on the bot. There would have to be some sort of mods for space and such. I don't think that any team will do that just to win a comp.

Amanda M 30-04-2004 03:17

Re: Getting a headstart?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sanddrag
Perhaps you meant maliciously amateure? :D Anyway, yeah. Most of the rumors about teams are untrue. And if anyone/ any team does have maliciously amateur practices, all I care about is that I'm not a part of it. If they don't want to be graciously professional, that is their own choice, it does not concern me nor should it concern anyone else. Just everyone do your best to be a gracious professionalist.

Now, for the issue of building things over the summer and whatnot. I can pretty much just second what Cory said. Nobody uses custom pre-built stuff on a competition robot and learning by doing no matter what time of the year it is, is both gracious and professional. That is how technology advances.


I can tell you that our 2004 desing came mostly from the prototype chassis that 254 and ourselves put together in the offseason and competed in the CalGames. We wanted to have some experience working together, and we wanted to try out the six-wheel drive system.
Tht doesn't make us ungracious. We never used any of the parts on our finished robot. We changed some things in our competition design, and we re-machined everything. It just gave us practice. As long as there are no parts added from outside the build period, then there is no violation of any rule in FIRST. It's all about advancing technology, and it's hard to do that in only six weeks a year.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:05.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi