Chief Delphi
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Rules/Strategy (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   Who Owns This Goal (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=32822)

Dr.Bot 15-01-2005 11:04
Who Owns This Goal
 


The following situation came up. The Red tetra is on the Blue, but the Blue is higher. The Red vertex is within 6 inches, the Blue isn't. I say Red owns the goal. What do you thinK?

rmmlg 15-01-2005 11:17
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
I agree that Red owns the goal since it appears that the Red is on top of the blue, even though the blue is higher (interesting little paradox). How was it that the tetras got in that position (i e, in which odrer were they placed onto the goal?)

pyroslev 15-01-2005 11:18
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
I say Red but at the actual competition, it may depend upon the opinion of the referee. Red will most likely get the points. :]

sj31419 15-01-2005 11:18
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
Well i guess it would be the blue since the rules say that the tetra must be completely on the tetra or it isn't counted as on it.

sj31419 15-01-2005 11:21
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
Well,now that I think about it red is on completely.How did he do that anyone know?

Dr.Bot 15-01-2005 11:36
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
We were messing around, putting tetras on two at a time, and they got tangled. This is unlikely to happen during competition, but we need to thank about all the 'angles.'

663.keith 15-01-2005 11:56
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
red owns the goal if the blue tetra is more than 6 inches away from the vertex.

Petey 15-01-2005 11:59
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by rmmlg
I agree that Red owns the goal since it appears that the Red is on top of the blue, even though the blue is higher (interesting little paradox). How was it that the tetras got in that position (i e, in which odrer were they placed onto the goal?)
It is a question of interpretation, but the rules do state that the tetra that is physically higher gets ownership, so I'm going to break the trend and go with blue.

Has anyone asked this in an update?

--Petey

dk5sm5luigi 15-01-2005 12:06
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
If blue is indeed in scoring position (the 6" rule and stuff) then I would say blue because if you look at the back corner it shows that blue was put on top slightly after red was.

Cory 15-01-2005 13:30
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Petey
It is a question of interpretation, but the rules do state that the tetra that is physically higher gets ownership, so I'm going to break the trend and go with blue.

Has anyone asked this in an update?

--Petey
yeah, but for that to happen blue has to be "scored" which, according to FIRST, means within 6"

Haldir 122690 15-01-2005 14:09
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
How did you even manage to get the tetras in that position anyway? Seriously. Do you even think the tetras will get in that position in a match anyway?

Katie Reynolds 15-01-2005 14:18
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Haldir 122690
How did you even manage to get the tetras in that position anyway? Seriously. Do you even think the tetras will get in that position in a match anyway?
Read the thread before you ask questions.

Quote:
Originally Posted by rmmlg
... How was it that the tetras got in that position (i e, in which odrer were they placed onto the goal?)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr.Bot
We were messing around, putting tetras on two at a time, and they got tangled. This is unlikely to happen during competition, but we need to thank about all the 'angles.'

Hershko 15-01-2005 14:28
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
1 Attachment(s)
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr.Bot


The following situation came up. The Red tetra is on the Blue, but the Blue is higher. The Red vertex is within 6 inches, the Blue isn't. I say Red owns the goal. What do you thinK?

In opinion non of them will owns the goal.
see the pic I draw.

Cory 15-01-2005 14:50
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
Please keep discussion on topic... the original poster asked which would be scored, not whether or not the tetras could indeed get in that position (Which they OBVIOUSLY did since there's a picture of them).

Steve W 15-01-2005 14:52
Re: Who Owns This Goal
 
Quote:
Originally Posted by Dr.Bot
We were messing around, putting tetras on two at a time, and they got tangled. This is unlikely to happen during competition, but we need to thank about all the 'angles.'

It probably will as we did the exact same thing while testing.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:45.
Page 1 of 2 1 2 >
Show 100 post(s) from this thread on one page

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi