Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

This should be a quick and easy question.

Is it legal to build one's own custom circuitry to charge the backup battery from the main 12v battery system during the competition? FIRST distributes a rudimentary charging system schematic, but my specific question is whether or not it is legal to charge the backup battery during competition with a custom-designed battery charger.

Any insight into this issue would be greatly appreciated. I know that many teams are having difficulty with the longevity of the battery life of the backup battery. This should be one way to help out. If it is determined that it is legal, and our if team can get our design to work, I will be sure to try to post the schematics on this thread.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

Michael,
<R53> The 7.2v backup battery may be charged on or off the robot. When off the robot, the battery is to be charged with the provided 7.2V backup battery charger. When mounted on the robot, the backup battery may be charged from the EX18-12 primary battery by using the custom charging circuit available from Innovation First Inc. (note: IFI will provide the design for this circuit on the IFI website, however teams must obtain the parts for this circuit and assemble it themselves)

The rule book is your friend. I suggest everyone download the manual to your laptop or shop computer. Acrobat reader has a nice search feature that helps me in finding answers quickly.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

The rule on the subject of charging the backup battery:

<R53> The 7.2v backup battery may be charged on or off the robot. When off the robot, the battery is to be charged with the provided 7.2V backup battery charger. When mounted on the robot, the backup battery may be charged from the EX18-12 primary battery by using the custom charging circuit available from Innovation First Inc. (note: IFI will provide the design for this circuit on the IFI website, however teams must obtain the parts for this circuit and assemble it themselves)

It seems to say that you have to use one of the methods supplied by FIRST. However, it is not exactly clear. Try Q&A for a definitive answer.

And for the record, I don't think we've ever had any longevity problems. We could run most of the day on one backup battery, partly because it was rarely used.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

I was referring specifically to circuitry that was DIFFERENT from the circuit that was provided by FIRST. I have read the rule book, but felt that its position on custom circuitry for the charging of the battery was a bit vague at best. I may have to get clarification directly from FIRST on this.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

I have been unable to post at the FIRST question and answer forum. Is there no one that knows whether or not we are allowed to use custom cicuitry to charge the backup battery during competition?

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

Your issue is with the word "may", right? As in "[w]hen mounted on the robot, the backup battery may be charged" with the IFI device, vs. "[w]hen off the robot, the battery is to be charged" with the supplied charger. This is definitely one for the Q&A, because the intent of the rule-writer is non-obvious. Highlight (very explicitly) their choice of wording, so that the Q&A moderators don't give you a boilerplate RTFM response. In terms of posting to the Q&A forum, your team's main contact should have received login information by e-mail; ask them for the password to the account FRC135, or have them post on your behalf. If your main contact is not available, or has lost the information, ask here for another team to post the question for you.

Incidentally, here's the charger circuit from IFI (which you assemble).

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

The issue with the word "may" does not bring into the fact of using another board than the IFI one. The word "may" is meant as you may or may not charge from the 12V battery. If you chose yes you move on in the sentence told be told you are to use the IFI board.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

I concur with Steve. There is a rule written telling you how you're allowed to charge the backup batt. If it's on the robot, you may charge it or not. If you choose to charge it, you're allowed to use the IFI circuit. All of the rules concerning the electrical system are very strict to keep robots from turning into short-lived arc welders. I'm pretty sure you should just assume that if they don't explictly allow something, then it's illegal.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

I know from personal experience that the CMUcam will chew through a backup battery in about an hour. I'm not sure if the servos run off it, or if the CMUcam is actually eating up all of that juice, but the camera is almost unusable after an hour of twitching around tracking. I don't know about you, but I'm changing the backup battery out after each match.

JBotAlan

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

I seem to remember the spec is 200 ma, which is a lot for a little battery pack.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

i cannot seem to find this whitepaper or w/e on ifirobotics.com.
can anyone give me a direct link?
this is about the backup battery chargeing while on the robot.
thanks

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

It's on the main page of ifirobotics.com under the "news or announcements" section and links to: http://www.ifirobotics.com/docs/firs...up-charger.pdf

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

If its only drawing 200mA, you should be able to get more than an hour off one of the IFI packs. Even with a 1A discharge, we usually get about 600-650mAh out of the packs, which is pretty good considered I believe they are rated at 700mAh.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

The servo motors will run off the backup battery wether plugged into the brain, or the camera. This may be why it does not seem to last very long.

Re: Custom Chargers for backup battery
 

If you plug the camera from TTL to TTL serial port the camera will draw power from 5v channel on the RC which uses a 12v source.