![]() |
Previous Year's spare parts
Here's a not-so-hypothetical question:
S.P.A.M. went with the Nothing-But-Dewalt gearboxes for the drive train again this year (as we did last year). Last year we built (modified per Joe Johnson's white paper) 4 sets for the robot and 4 sets as spares. We never needed the spares. This year we again built 4 sets plus 4 sets as spares. I anticipate that at the end of the season we will have all 8 sets of spares sitting on the shelf, unused, that we cannot use for any future competition since they were built in a previous year. This is different from purchased spares (which we can use in other years) since we actually performed fabrication on them. Could we sell, trade or donate them to another team next year? Would that team be allowed to use them? I'd say by the letter of the law maybe, but certainly by the intent yes if they bookkeep the allowable cost since the raw parts are readily available to any team. It doesn't give anyone an unfair advantage. What do you think? |
Re: Previous Year's spare parts
Gary,
I understand you logic but i think the answer would be that it is not legal. While Spam's intent is GP i am looking at this from an overall FIRST perspective. Lets say i prototype a new super transmission in the off season and test it so that it works perfectly. Now i am not allowed to use it because it wasn't build during the season but we are mentoring a rookie team and now find it legal to give our off season transmission to them, thus giving them an advantage of a tested transmission that they didn't have to build. So now that that gets out a few teams get together and build transmissions in the off season and just trade each other for them the day after kickoff. How would this be fair. In a perfect world where everyone followed the rules to the letter and had good intentions like you do i would say it is fine but unfortunately i can see that if teams start this trend it will only go south fast. Greg |
Re: Previous Year's spare parts
Quote:
|
Re: Previous Year's spare parts
The rules next year might change, but they probably won't. Since 1) you modified them and 2) you don't fit the definition of a vendor, those spares are not going to be usable on a competition-legal robot other than the one they were intended for.
The most reasonable course I see is to use them on a non-competition project, or give/trade/sell them to another team for such use. |
| All times are GMT -5. The time now is 07:44. |
Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi