Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Extra Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   pic: Ethanol powered car from GM (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=49253)

6600gt 02-10-2006 23:53

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sanddrag
Perhaps WVO is the answer.

Where to find 7 billion barrels/year of it?...LOL.

Schnabel 03-10-2006 06:08

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KenWittlief
well, yeah, but you are talking about 16% of billions and billions of dollars per year that are presently going to other countries, that could stay here.

and I believe the pollution from burning ethanol is near zero.

Yeah, but then we would have to import all of our corn to eat, then we would end up getting more of a cost per can of corn at your local grocery store.

"Hey mom, can we get some corn?"
"No, it is too expensive"
"But it's on sale for $4.50 a can." :ahh:

KenWittlief 03-10-2006 08:16

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Schnabel
"Hey mom, can we get some corn?"
"No, it is too expensive"
"But it's on sale for $4.50 a can." :ahh:

no, it would only cost around $80 per barrel for light sweet corn :^)

Tristan Lall 03-10-2006 08:18

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KenWittlief
the billions of dollar per year that we would be putting into our own economy (which is presently going into the pockets of obscenely wealthy kings and families in the middle east) would provide meaningful jobs for thousands of people in this country

and it would also drive the growth of an ethanol based transportation system, resulting in the needed infrastructure being created and built up over the years

the best part is this is a renewable resource. It wont be gone in 50 or 100 years.

What sort of infrastructure? Trucks? They need a breakthrough in large-scale storage and transport, before this is reasonable in anywhere but the U.S. Midwest.

And realistically, no matter who's running the hydrocarbon fuel show, the profits get absorbed by those in positions of power. It's not just sheikhs; Americans, Europeans, and eastern Asians all have their own homegrown oil magnates. If you don't like the profit sharing, simply transferring responsibility to the domestic arms of Exxon or Texaco (or maybe Monsanto, if corn-based fuel becomes popular) won't solve the problem.

And while I certainly can't make a definitive prediction based on such a small set of evidence, remember that even if thousands of jobs are created in America, if higher fuel costs make disposable income decrease, the standard of living might well follow. Even a small (percentage) decrease, because it's due to something as ubiquitous as automotive fuel, will have significant effects on GDP. So one can only hope that the increased consumption due to slightly lower unemployment will mitigate this.
Quote:

Originally Posted by Ken Wittlief
people have demonstrated the will to do the right thing regarding our economy and our environment.

Consistently? I doubt that. The "right thing" for the economy depends greatly on your views on such things; it's a complex enough system that it's difficult to prove any particular economic strategy is the correct one. Effectively, that means that damned near anything can be justified as the "right thing". Environmentally, people are willing to do token things, like buy organic foods, once in a while—but on average, there's not much evidence for people doing the "right thing" on a consistent basis. The lifestyle that we all enjoy simply doesn't lend itself to very environmentally responsible choices. Demand that people drive more efficient cars? They complain about their liberty. Ask them nicely? They don't do it. You have to trick them with hybrids (and the associated mystique—like "atomic" in the 50s) to get them to embrace efficiency—until they realize that current hybrid technology can't pay for itself in gas savings, not even with $1.20/L gas.

KenWittlief 03-10-2006 09:26

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
My wifes best friend recently purchased the Toyota Hybrid (the Prius?)

she is the head nurse at a hospital, and her husband is an industrial engineer. Nobody tricked them into buying the car, they understood the long term cost vs the money they would save on fuel

and they had to take what they could get from the dealer when they could get it, at the list price, because the car had a 3 month back order.

AudieMurphy 03-10-2006 09:43

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Think I read that they can now take cellulose ethanol from just about anything that grows. If I remember the article right, the speculation was that it would be switchgrass and not corn that would fuel our cars if we made a move to ethanol because switchgrass can be grown almost anywhere and harvested multiple times per year giving a much greater energy yield per acre.

Tristan Lall 03-10-2006 11:35

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KenWittlief
My wifes best friend recently purchased the Toyota Hybrid (the Prius?)

she is the head nurse at a hospital, and her husband is an industrial engineer. Nobody tricked them into buying the car, they understood the long term cost vs the money they would save on fuel

and they had to take what they could get from the dealer when they could get it, at the list price, because the car had a 3 month back order.

Let's say you drive 15 000 km per year, and you have a choice between a 45 MPG Prius and a 30 MPG Corolla sedan or wagon (similarly-sized cars). At $0.95/L, you save $372.42 per year*. Now, if you keep the car for seven years, that's $2 606.96. Does the Prius cost more than that much above and beyond a Corolla? And that doesn't even take into account the interest you could earn on that money, if it were in hand and invested over that timeframe. And it doesn't count the cost of service for a Prius (which has many expensive components due to its low volume) versus that of a Corolla (which is ubiquitous).

Of course, there are some comparisons that can be made, that do save money—between buying something like a Dodge Magnum and a Toyota Prius, for example. These are comparably-priced cars. Or if you really do drive 45 000 km per year, the Prius can save some money.

The trouble is, people see "hybrid", and think that they're automatically doing something fantastic by buying it. It has to be right for the use that you put it to; current hybrids are not a solution for everybody, so long as cost is a factor.

*U.S. gallons, Canadian dollars, and gas is currently around $0.78/L.

KenWittlief 03-10-2006 12:53

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
last time I worked out the math it was cheaper to buy a base model Saturn Ion (5 speed) that got 38 to 42mpg than to buy a hybrid electric car (several thousand dollars more) that got 55 to 65mpg, if you planned to drive the car 120k miles

this has been all over the news this summer. It only takes a few minutes to run the calculations if you know the specs and prices of two cars, and the price of gas. Hybrid electric cars do cost you more than a base model economy car to own and drive.

People know that, and there is still a back log of orders for hybrid electric cars- which is what I was trying to point out - people are buying them for other reasons than to save money.

I know of at least one hyrbid owner whos son is a Marine in Iraq. Maybe its their way to take a step towards breaking the strangle hold the middle east has on our transportation system.

If I could buy a one passenger electric car that could hit 45mph, with a 30 mile range, for $7 or $8k, I would, for the sole purpose of driving to work, 15 miles each way. I could design a car myself in a few days that would meet my requirements, but it would be very expensive for me to build one in my garage.

The problem is the economy of scale. For a new car company, or a new car line to be viable you have to build hundreds of thousands, or millions of cars a year, to compete against the gas models that are presently available. That requires a huge startup investment (probably $1B or more).

So far no one has stepped up to the plate to do it.

MattB703 03-10-2006 15:22

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by KenWittlief
.....
If I could buy a one passenger electric car that could hit 45mph, with a 30 mile range, for $7 or $8k, I would, for the sole purpose of driving to work, 15 miles each way. .....


A Honda Spree? (I know it is not electric, but it probably uses less energy than the electric company would use to power your electric car)

Conor Ryan 03-10-2006 16:46

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
My opinion on alternate fuel cars:
  • Have you seen Who Killed the Electric Car? ?
  • Why aren't there any fully electric cars produced by the Big Automakers?
    • Yes there is a market for electric cars
  • Why isn't there a car that runs on thought?

JaneYoung 03-10-2006 16:58

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Why isn't there a car that runs on thought?
just to name a few:
- going in circles
- hitting a blank wall
- losing my train of thought, keyword - train -

other than that I think my mind could power/drive a car very well.

BobC 03-10-2006 17:33

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
What I want to know is why does Diesel cost so much more than gasoline. Yet it cost 30% less to make diesel than it does gasoline. Why does the price of a gallon of fuel go up the day after the price of a barrel of oil go up on the open market. Yet it takes for ever for the price to come down. I can tell you how much diesel fuel went up between 2004 and 2005.

I drove appox. 59,000 miles in 2004
I drove appox. 60,000 miles in 2005

THE COST OF FUEL ???

2004 was $12,000
2005 was $18,000

sanddrag 03-10-2006 18:50

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BobC
I drove appox. 59,000 miles in 2004
I drove appox. 60,000 miles in 2005

Geez. Where do you go every day?

Wetzel 03-10-2006 19:08

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
In Northern Virginia, there is another cost to factor into your hybrid benefit matrix: time. Up until June 1st 2006, a hybrid qualified for special licence plates that exempted you from HOV restrictions. In the heavily congested 95 and 66 corridors, this could save you an hour or more a day in sitting in traffic.

That has much greater value than a few gallons of gas each week.

Wetzel

6600gt 03-10-2006 23:21

Re: pic: Ethanol powered car from GM
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BobC
What I want to know is why does Diesel cost so much more than gasoline. Yet it cost 30% less to make diesel than it does gasoline.


Economics of supply and demand. Semis use Diesel, enough said.


Quote:

Originally Posted by Conor Ryan
[*]Have you seen Who Killed the Electric Car? ?

Every one should watch this video!!!!!

Hydrogen is the next gasoline that oil companies want to make money from. It has nothing to do with the enviornment.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:08.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi