Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Technical Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=22)
-   -   Chassis weight (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=61855)

potatoarecool 16-01-2008 20:18

Chassis weight
 
Hey guys, I was wondering how heavy a robot would be if it was only made of parts from the kit, with nothing but the electronics, 2 motors, wheels and battery. Did anyone check for this? Thanks.

wilsonmw04 16-01-2008 20:26

Re: Chassis weight
 
We did that, sort of. We used a 6-WD with two sets of chains on each side. Without the battery it weighted ~47 lbs. With just the parts in the KOP i bet it's closer to 40 lbs.

wilsonmw04 16-01-2008 23:27

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zyik (Post 679685)
Ours is 13 pounds

I find that hard to believe when the frame itself is 17 lbs if you use every piece. heck the Transmissions + CIM's are close to 6 lbs each.

Otaku 16-01-2008 23:30

Re: Chassis weight
 
Our chassis (non-kitbot, fully custom) with no transmissions or anything is 17lbs. With transmissions and two CIMs total it feels much closer to 35lbs.

AndyB 17-01-2008 09:44

Re: Chassis weight
 
We weighed ours with a chassis, 4 wheels, 2 sprockets, 2 gearboxes, and no electronics and it came out around 26 lbs. No battery, only 2 cims. So factor in battery weight and whatever the weight of the electronics panel would be and it probably will run up to around 45 lbs.

Clifford 17-01-2008 10:35

Re: Chassis weight
 
If you're thinking about what your robot will weigh fully built, remember that the weight of the battery is not included in your total weight at inspection.

beemgruem 17-01-2008 10:40

Re: Chassis weight
 
Ours is with battery, electronics board, 2 normal 2 small wheels, 2 gearboxes, I don't remember the sprockets. It is 46 Ibs.

Aren_Hill 17-01-2008 10:46

Re: Chassis weight
 
We finished our frame yesterday at 11.5 lbs

sdcantrell56 17-01-2008 11:10

Re: Chassis weight
 
Our completely finished uber beefy drivetrain with motors and electronics is right around 50lbs

midway78224 17-01-2008 13:36

Re: Chassis weight
 
our drivetrain when we finish it was at 55 lbs that was with electronics, supershifters, six wheels, etc....

Madison 17-01-2008 13:44

Re: Chassis weight
 
Our frame is 10.75 lbs.

The complete, operational drive train, save 12V battery, is 35 lbs.

sdcantrell56 17-01-2008 13:50

Re: Chassis weight
 
How and why do some teams make the drivetrain so light? It would seem that it would hurt the CG a lot.

Madison 17-01-2008 13:55

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sdcantrell56 (Post 680115)
How and why do some teams make the drivetrain so light? It would seem that it would hurt the CG a lot.

We make everything as light as possible. Adding weight later is much easier than taking it off. In the ten years that I've been with FIRST, I've had a robot tip over twice.

sdcantrell56 17-01-2008 14:06

Re: Chassis weight
 
Don't get me wrong I really love your frames although they are a little thin for my liking...I just think that sometimes people worry about weight in the drivetrain a little too much since that is the best place for the weight.

Molten 17-01-2008 14:07

Re: Chassis weight
 
In the two years that I've been in FIRST, our robot has tipped over three times. (We played a lot of defense last year.) But MKrass is right, adding weight is really easy, I wish losing weight was the same.

sdcantrell56 17-01-2008 14:09

Re: Chassis weight
 
I think we maybe have flipped 3 times in our 3 years and that was all in our first season, but a lot of that is because of the beef in our drivetrains. Now we do go a little overboard sometimes (last year) but it has good results.

dlavery 17-01-2008 14:13

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by M. Krass (Post 680122)
We make everything as light as possible. Adding weight later is much easier than taking it off. In the ten years that I've been with FIRST, I've had a robot tip over twice.

... thinking back fondly to the year we actually had to bolt a 27-pound block of lead on to our robot as ballast.

Too bad FIRST does not still include the "Featherweight In The Finals" award. That was a great incentive!

-dave



.

AdamHeard 17-01-2008 14:15

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by wilsonmw04 (Post 679821)
I find that hard to believe when the frame itself is 17 lbs if you use every piece. heck the Transmissions + CIM's are close to 6 lbs each.

I'm not sure why zyik deleted her post; It was true. Our frame really is 12 pounds. We use extruded aluminum, not the kit frame.

sdcantrell56 17-01-2008 14:20

Re: Chassis weight
 
Ok so I went back and looked at our frame and our frame without anything weighs 20.9lbs. It is made out of custom aluminum plate and standoffs. This is also without any lightening patterns so that the machine shop wouldn't hate us too much haha.

Alan Anderson 17-01-2008 14:38

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 680136)
We use extruded aluminum, not the kit frame.

potatoarecool started this thread by asking how heavy a chassis made only from material from the Kit of Parts would be.

AdamHeard 17-01-2008 14:42

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Anderson (Post 680152)
potatoarecool started this thread by asking how heavy a chassis made only from material from the Kit of Parts would be.

I completely missed that.... My apologies.

In 2005 when 294 used the KOP frame we saved 1 pound or so removing bits here and there; I've also heard rivets instead of bolts saves a lot of weight.

GaryVoshol 17-01-2008 14:43

Re: Chassis weight
 
What is this chassis thing of which teams speak? It seems to be an object which you are able to weigh? I can't find one in our shop yet. :confused:

jgannon 17-01-2008 15:06

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 680161)
I've also heard rivets instead of bolts saves a lot of weight.

Can somebody who has done this with the KOP chassis give some idea as to the actual weight savings?

Sam2197 19-01-2008 15:32

Re: Chassis weight
 
our frame without anything on it weighed 43 pounds :ahh: we are gonna deffinately be cutting it close this year

Dick Linn 19-01-2008 23:24

Re: Chassis weight
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by GaryVoshol (Post 680162)
What is this chassis thing of which teams speak? It seems to be an object which you are able to weigh? I can't find one in our shop yet. :confused:

A chassis normally starts as a sophisticated structure fabricated from Unobtanium, which is quite difficult to see or weigh. Strong, but very flexible and difficult to grasp. Due to design changes and production difficulties in the normal FIRST shop, later iterations usually form out of aluminum, plywood, or other things you've been tripping over, depending on your budget. Near the end of the build period, portions of the chassis usually appear on the floor in the form of chips or sawdust, due to a process called "lightening". This is not to be confused with the phenomenon called "lightning", which is a part of the electrical and control subsystem that occasionally leaks out.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 01:11.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi