Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

Prior to being a part of the GDC this season, I'm betting you probably would not have seen the need to spell out an exact definition for "honestly played". :D

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

[offtopic]That is somewhat of a misrepresentation of L'Hopital's rule. Dividing by zero is still undefined, L'Hopital's rule uses properties of derivatives to find a value for a limit when it seems undefined at first. I still can't divide by zero, but I can tell you what a function is doing when it is approaching dividing by zero. (yeah the difference is small, but one is impossible, the other doesn't have to be) Also, if you instead use a limit that approaches x/0, there is no reason for it to be equal to +infinity, -infinity is just as valid (and much less than 3)
[/offtopic]

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

Amen! I doubt we will see many pre-penalty scores even in the single digits. Even extremely weak alliances should score, at a minimum, in the 25 point range.

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

Even then I'm pretty sure someone could score ... hacky-sack anyone?

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

I'm sure he felt the need to specify it simply to ensure no two alliances would collaborate to deprive him of his donuts!

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

Did he say no Photoshopping? Knowing some of the characters on CD, I would have thought that should be at the top of the list.

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

He did say that it had to actually happen in a match. I'm sure he would take the few minutes to look at a regional's posted match scores. Although you could try to get away with it for a Thursday practice match. ;)

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

i have seen matches where none of the robots on an allience showed up in a match

besides we are dealing with the what-ifs since though the possiblility is small it still none the less exsists.

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

That might actually be a fairly high scoring match... seeing as all the immobile trailers would be in front of human players armed with orbit balls...

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

Yeah... 20 per PS. 2-3' to the trailer. YOU try and get a zero score! (It's fairly easy to do, but your PS and every other PS on your alliance would have to deliberately miss.) You can get 128 points pretty quickly. (2 per ball, 60 moon rocks, 4 empty cells per alliance)

Oh, yeah: I'm pretty sure Dave isn't counting practice matches.

[offtopic] Luke, you're right. It is an oversimplification.

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

Unless I missed it in this long thread, no one has pointed out that if the other team has no points, remember, you are towing their goal behind your robot. ANY cell in your trailer counts for them, even if your PS threw it there...hint...hint....

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

i forgot to mention this before but wouldn't an allience with no ability to win (for instance if all of its robots did't work) would try not to score anything simply to deprive your teams of supercells next round?

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

It's possible. Dave still gets his KKs, though. If the matches are played as intended, it won't happen.

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

Probably not. For one, one of the opposing alliance bots could be on their next alliance, and then i would hurt them. Also, ranking points are determined by the losing team's score, so it is in both team's best interest for the losing team to have as many points as possible.

Re: <G14> - ya win some, ya lose some
 

I don't know if you've realized it yet, but your wording has saved you from a strike one...

http://www2.usfirst.org/2009comp/eve...chresults.html (match 42)
http://www.thebluealliance.net/tbatv/match/2009gt_qm42

Cheers! :p