Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Extra Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   pic: Look what Samta Left us! (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=81869)

CraigHickman 04-02-2010 10:06

pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 

MrForbes 04-02-2010 10:07

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Wow, that looks great! Looks like you'll be busy putting together....

Are the three sided roundish tubes an extrusion, or milled?

JohnFogarty 04-02-2010 10:47

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
O.o lol it's an expensive way of doing what we did loool

Fe_Will 04-02-2010 10:49

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Very nice. Where is the like button when you need it. I may have to sneak over and see this in person.:rolleyes:

Any idea of the weight?

Akash Rastogi 04-02-2010 10:56

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
An estimate on cost of 1 system would be nice too please. PM if you don't want it published.

gblake 04-02-2010 11:33

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Hmmm... If Santa left it for you, then it must be illegal. He delivers in December and that is before the build season starts ;)

PS: Oooh! Shiney!

MrForbes 04-02-2010 11:38

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Santa did not leave the parts, Samta did.

Read the subject line

;)

gblake 04-02-2010 12:09

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by squirrel (Post 913246)
Santa did not leave the parts, Samta did.
;)

Oh! Is that Santa's less reputable cousin, the one who sells stuff out of the back of his sleigh?

CraigHickman 04-02-2010 12:48

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by squirrel (Post 913193)
Wow, that looks great! Looks like you'll be busy putting together....

Are the three sided roundish tubes an extrusion, or milled?

Milled. They're referred to as a tri-lobular boss. They sandwich the two sideplates together. Definitely go check one out if there's an Outback sponsored team at your regional(s).

Quote:

Originally Posted by Fe_Will (Post 913212)
Very nice. Where is the like button when you need it. I may have to sneak over and see this in person.:rolleyes:

Any idea of the weight?

You're welcome to! Or rather, go see 997's, as we're a bit of a drive from Corvallis...

Weight for one assembled chassis (not including gearboxes, motors, pulleys) is 12.4 lbs. Insanely rigid and tough, with plenty of mounting for several team's superstructures.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Akash Rastogi (Post 913220)
An estimate on cost of 1 system would be nice too please. PM if you don't want it published.

Actually, since Outback teams work with Outback, it varies from team to team. Some teams buy their own stock, and the machine time is donated, some team buy everything. It really varies. If you're interested, shoot me an email and I can put you in touch with someone at Outback.

Quote:

Originally Posted by gblake (Post 913272)
Oh! Is that Santa's less reputable cousin, the one who sells stuff out of the back of his sleigh?

Nope, Samta is my play on the name Sam, for the leading machinist on the west coast, owner and head guy at Outback Manufacturing.

AdamHeard 04-02-2010 12:55

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CraigHickman (Post 913283)
Milled. They're referred to as a tri-lobular boss. They sandwich the two sideplates together. Definitely go check one out if there's an Outback sponsored team at your regional(s).



You're welcome to! Or rather, go see 997's, as we're a bit of a drive from Corvallis...

Weight for one assembled chassis (not including gearboxes, motors, pulleys) is 12.4 lbs. Insanely rigid and tough, with plenty of mounting for several team's superstructures.



Actually, since Outback teams work with Outback, it varies from team to team. Some teams buy their own stock, and the machine time is donated, some team buy everything. It really varies. If you're interested, shoot me an email and I can put you in touch with someone at Outback.



Nope, Samta is my play on the name Sam, for the leading machinist on the west coast, owner and head guy at Outback Manufacturing.

If some teams are paying for them, what is the cost of the entire unit?

Jon Jack 04-02-2010 14:25

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
I'm really curious on the cost of this system...

If teams are paying for this system as a package, then does the entire system cost less than $400? It looks like every part is fabricated, just the cost of the machinists time would exceed $400. This doesn't even begin to touch on the cost of material.

This must mean that Outback is selling these systems to teams at a substantially reduced rate and taking a loss, right? Could any FIRST team call up Outback and get this system for $400 or less?

Andy L 04-02-2010 14:35

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Beautiful, although I'm kind of curious who is running their robot on one tread...

efoote868 04-02-2010 16:01

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jon Jack (Post 913347)
I'm really curious on the cost of this system...

If teams are paying for this system as a package, then does the entire system cost less than $400? It looks like every part is fabricated, just the cost of the machinists time would exceed $400. This doesn't even begin to touch on the cost of material.

This must mean that Outback is selling these systems to teams at a substantially reduced rate and taking a loss, right? Could any FIRST team call up Outback and get this system for $400 or less?

Looks like to me its not all one piece. So, combined it could be upwards of $1000, but if you break it into individual pieces, they'll be less than $400.

CraigHickman 04-02-2010 16:54

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andy L (Post 913354)
Beautiful, although I'm kind of curious who is running their robot on one tread...

I was wondering that too, until I saw the box of parts that made its way down to California. All teams have been well taken care of, and then some.

Say, wasn't I supposed to send a part file to someone on your team? I recall something about that, but I'm really not sure... Toughbox adapter plate or something?

Quote:

Originally Posted by efoote868 (Post 913417)
Looks like to me its not all one piece. So, combined it could be upwards of $1000, but if you break it into individual pieces, they'll be less than $400.

This is somewhat close to the correct answer for this. For those concerned about pricing: Don't worry about it. It's on a team by team basis, and each team can probably work something out with Outback. If you're really interested, I'd suggest getting in touch with Outback to find out how it would work for your team. If you need help doing so, email or PM me and I'll be glad to help.

Do people really think we'd invest this much time and effort for something even close to not legal? It's not worth showing up to the competition and being even slightly into the gray area.

Anyway, I forgot to put spec's for our drive system:
-Final drive speed is slightly below 9fps under load
-Chassis weight as shown is 12.4 lbs. Expected to be sub 30 with motors and gearboxes
-Each unit is module, and can be dropped out of the robot should repairs be necessary
-Each track unit is incredibly rigid when bolted together, and each module is reversible to allow use on both sides of the tracks
-Gearboxes will be hobbed out of single block of aluminum with a mating plate to allow quick changes of components

Any technical questions I can answer about these?

AdamHeard 04-02-2010 18:04

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CraigHickman (Post 913450)
I was wondering that too, until I saw the box of parts that made its way down to California. All teams have been well taken care of, and then some.

Say, wasn't I supposed to send a part file to someone on your team? I recall something about that, but I'm really not sure... Toughbox adapter plate or something?



This is somewhat close to the correct answer for this. For those concerned about pricing: Don't worry about it. It's on a team by team basis, and each team can probably work something out with Outback. If you're really interested, I'd suggest getting in touch with Outback to find out how it would work for your team. If you need help doing so, email or PM me and I'll be glad to help.

Do people really think we'd invest this much time and effort for something even close to not legal? It's not worth showing up to the competition and being even slightly into the gray area.

Anyway, I forgot to put spec's for our drive system:
-Final drive speed is slightly below 9fps under load
-Chassis weight as shown is 12.4 lbs. Expected to be sub 30 with motors and gearboxes
-Each unit is module, and can be dropped out of the robot should repairs be necessary
-Each track unit is incredibly rigid when bolted together, and each module is reversible to allow use on both sides of the tracks
-Gearboxes will be hobbed out of single block of aluminum with a mating plate to allow quick changes of components

Any technical questions I can answer about these?


Yes, for a handful of teams there is a special deal... but what if 1000 teams wanted a base? No way he's giving the good guy price then.

CraigHickman 04-02-2010 18:19

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 913490)
Yes, for a handful of teams there is a special deal... but what if 1000 teams wanted a base? No way he's giving the good guy price then.

Should that situation arise, it would be dealt with. I don't see the purpose in delving into "what if" scenarios, as they don't reflect the current state of reality.

AdamHeard 04-02-2010 18:24

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CraigHickman (Post 913499)
Should that situation arise, it would be dealt with. I don't see the purpose in delving into "what if" scenarios, as they don't reflect the current state of reality.

It does reflect the current state of reality. Are these COTS components? Are they parts fabricated by a sponsor as a donation? If so were they made in the 6 weeks? Was the amount the team paid just the material costs, not an unfairly low price on machine time?

These are serious issues, you can't just bend the rules and get away with it. If you completely answered the first set of questions, I wouldn't be inquiring further.

waialua359 04-02-2010 18:26

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Whatever it costs, I'll bid $1000 asap via paypal.
LMK!:D :D
Not for a real FRC entry, but for fun at our shop.

CraigHickman 04-02-2010 18:29

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AdamHeard (Post 913502)
It does reflect the current state of reality. Are these COTS components? Are they parts fabricated by a sponsor as a donation? If so were they made in the 6 weeks? Was the amount the team paid just the material costs, not an unfairly low price on machine time?

These are serious issues, you can't just bend the rules and get away with it. If you completely answered the first set of questions, I wouldn't be inquiring further.

EDIT: I've decided to clear this up to ditch the issue. Here's how it works:
-Teams begin by requesting sponsorship. If Outback accepts, they then buy the material for a drive base.
-Outback donates the machine time to fabricate a drive base.
-Teams buy the belts and pulleys through Outback, a Brecoflex vendor

That being said, PLEASE ask me if there's any questions. Don't assume, I'm here to help!

Andy L 04-02-2010 20:41

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
I'm not sure about the part Craig, I'm at school right now 2 hours away from my team :(

I'm hoping they send me some pics of everything though, I'm excited to go to SVR this year

CraigHickman 05-02-2010 00:20

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andy L (Post 913568)
I'm not sure about the part Craig, I'm at school right now 2 hours away from my team :(

I'm hoping they send me some pics of everything though, I'm excited to go to SVR this year

I'm sure they'll send you pics. We're working on uploading our archive, so I'll send you the link (or put it up in public if the team OK's it) when we have it.

Andy L 05-02-2010 02:48

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by CraigHickman (Post 913735)
I'm sure they'll send you pics. We're working on uploading our archive, so I'll send you the link (or put it up in public if the team OK's it) when we have it.

they sent me a couple, they look sweet, I wish I could see them in person before March!

CraigHickman 05-02-2010 02:50

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Andy L (Post 913795)
they sent me a couple, they look sweet, I wish I could see them in person before March!

That'd be cool. Where are you going to school? (care to PM me the reply? We can keep the personal convo out of the public thread...)

cilginbilgin 05-02-2010 03:16

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
Santa is a good boy !

fordchrist675 06-02-2010 18:50

Re: pic: Look what Samta Left us!
 
I just have to point how....Samta huh? Looks like a decent very decent gift :D


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 23:13.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi