Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Regional Competitions (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=10)
-   -   Should mascots be allowed in the pit? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=84203)

the programmer 12-03-2010 22:12

Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
at the Wisconsin regional i'm seeing a lot of mascots walking around the pit without spotters, i have serious doubts about whether it's safe for people wearing outfits that impair their vision and ability to walk going through a tight area with power tools and 120 lbs. robots

Karibou 12-03-2010 22:33

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
There's no rules strictly prohibiting them from being in the pits--and I don't think there should be*--but it is INCREDIBLY unsafe to wear anything but appropriately-fitted clothing in there. I always cringe when I see large dogs, bears, cubes, aliens, and other things walking through the pit, spotted or not. 1189 even takes our mascot capes off before going in, just because they're very airy and prone to flying out behind whoever's wearing them. Even if there's no large rotating/spark-creating machinery around, loose fabric can easily get caught on pit corners, power cords, banner stands, or other people, and it creates a huge safety hazard. Not being able to use your peripheral vision also results in a lot of bumping into things and tripping. Bulky costumes also take up valuable pit and aisle space.

*I would hope that most teams recognize how much of a hazard mascots in the pit are, and how it reflects on their team - I know that I for one always remember who I see with mascots in the pit, and it always sends off giant sirens in my head blaring "UNSAFE TEAM UNSAFE TEAM UNSAFE TEAM"...it looks horrible in front of the judges, too!

Chris is me 12-03-2010 23:27

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
There's a difference between mascots in the pits and mascots touching robots or using any kind of machinery, and I think that's a distinction that needs to be made. Obviously a mascot costume and a drill or lathe is a bad combination, but walking in the aisles in a mascot costume isn't exactly going to lead to machines flying in your face.

Molten 12-03-2010 23:34

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
I'd go with a no because they tend to add certain issues. First off, as Kara pointed out, it really hurts your ability to see. Secondly, how can they wear safety glasses with the head on? I know it may seem unnecessary, but rules are rules. Furthermore, why should they be in the pits? I thought mascots are supposed to be like a cheerleader for the team. Keep them with the crowds. I've seen them in the pits before too and never given it a thought before, but I'll start cringing the next time I see it. Good catch on safety.

Seth Mallory 13-03-2010 00:10

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
In San Diego the mascots had to have a ground guide.

Scott Carpman 13-03-2010 01:36

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Leave the mascots to the field side of the curtain where they can have a positive impact on the crowds. The pit side is congested enough already, the safety factor just compounds on the issue.

Molten 13-03-2010 11:17

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Perhaps we should just have signs put up that say "Please remove your head and tail before entering".

synth3tk 13-03-2010 11:29

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Scott Carpman (Post 936212)
Leave the mascots to the field side of the curtain where they can have a positive impact on the crowds. The pit side is congested enough already, the safety factor just compounds on the issue.

Very true. Especially when teams have more people in the pit than they probably should (I've seen teams where they couldn't move in their own pit). And they're still a hazard in the aisles, because teams are constantly moving robots to and from the field. That peripheral vision is important anywhere in the pits.

I'd go with a "no" to answer the original question, too. As a mascot for three of my five years with the team, I've tried to never wear the costume in the pits, or at least take the head off. Our bearcat suit allows me to wear safety glasses, so I'd automatically be in compliance with that rule. Generally, though, I only wear the suit in the pits if I'm on my way back to the stands.

As a mascot, you're there to entertain the crowd. The team members are already entertained with a robot. ;)

jamie_1930 13-03-2010 11:41

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
There is a huge difference between venues and allowed space so I think this is a more specififc question. There are situations in which this can be deemed unsafe, but for the most part mascots walking around, unless you've seen differently, are there to get the team more well known and a quick walk through the pits should be fine.

ttldomination 13-03-2010 12:05

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
When our mascot does its thing, it generally keeps to itself in the stands. On the off chance that it needs to come to the pits, then the mascot usually walks with someone else, or with his/her head off.

Let's not get too carried away with this. It's supposed to be fun.

Molten 13-03-2010 17:23

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ttldomination (Post 936278)
Let's not get too carried away with this. It's supposed to be fun.

I guess a lion getting ran over by a robot would be fun? Seriously, stick to the stands for your own safety or remove your head. I can't say the number of times I've almost gotten ran over by a robot in the pits. Can't imagine doing it with impaired vision and mobility.

ttldomination 13-03-2010 17:45

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Molten (Post 936393)
I guess a lion getting ran over by a robot would be fun? Seriously, stick to the stands for your own safety or remove your head. I can't say the number of times I've almost gotten ran over by a robot in the pits. Can't imagine doing it with impaired vision and mobility.

That image made me chuckle. :P

But out of all seriousness, I'm not saying that mascots shouldn't be safe. I'm saying that mascots are there to add to the fun of the competition and to not allow them in the pits would be a bit of a let down.

Katie_UPS 14-03-2010 19:20

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Well, what do you consider a mascot (I was at the wisconsin regional as well)? For my team, the girls in capes and tube skirts (three other girls and me) are our "mascots"(we send them down for dancing). In the pit and working, our capes are unsafe. But walking around? Not so much. I'll admit that the jellybean might've been a bad idea, but I can't say I saw all that many mascots running around in the pits. You need to define mascot. Is it just a person in a tiger suit or does it include a person dressed up but mostly keeping with their human-identity? Something that you might consider a mascot, other teams consider as an extension to their uniform/image (KING TeC comes to mind).

Molten 14-03-2010 20:07

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Katie_UPS (Post 936984)
Well, what do you consider a mascot (I was at the wisconsin regional as well)? For my team, the girls in capes and tube skirts (three other girls and me) are our "mascots"(we send them down for dancing). In the pit and working, our capes are unsafe. But walking around? Not so much. I'll admit that the jellybean might've been a bad idea, but I can't say I saw all that many mascots running around in the pits. You need to define mascot. Is it just a person in a tiger suit or does it include a person dressed up but mostly keeping with their human-identity? Something that you might consider a mascot, other teams consider as an extension to their uniform/image (KING TeC comes to mind).

This is something I've been thinking out myself. I think that the point where it becomes a problem is when you lose your ability to see and maneuver. IF we were to impose a restriction, I'd think it should include all headwear that restricts vision at the least.(this would include more then animal heads, some hats might provide similar issues.) I'd be open to the restriction on capes/tails/etc but don't find them to be as critical.

sanddrag 14-03-2010 21:40

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
I see absolutely no reason to have mascots or spirit parades in the pit area, and I think they should be disallowed.

Katie_UPS 14-03-2010 21:46

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by sanddrag (Post 937077)
I see absolutely no reason to have mascots or spirit parades in the pit area, and I think they should be disallowed.

a) certain mascots (humans in rediculous get-up, for example) are (for the most part)(case dependant) safe in the pits, and sometimes are field crew or scouts. But I think this is, falling back on my previous post, a matter of definition.

b) I have never seen a spirit parade in a the pit area. Or heard of one.

BrendanB 14-03-2010 22:20

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Never heard of parades in the pit either!

Molten: Since when is robots running around wild in the pits happened? And wouldn't wearing the extra padding cushion you from the impact just a little more than wearing shorts and a shirt? Just some of my thoughts.

I see no problems with mascots in the pits, but working on the robot is not a good idea whether in a costume or cape (now that I look back at GSR, I should NOT have been wearing that cape in the pit! I am guilty of this too!).

IMHO, they should really start restricting how many team members can be in a pit at once. If you are standing the in the walkway, most likely you aren't doing anything and should go up to the stands and stay out of the way. If I see a ton of team 4356's team members walking around, I don't see a problem, but if 8+ members of team 4356 are standing in their pit and are spilling into the walkway, there are too many of them. Again, our team is guilty of this too, but there many times are too many people in the pits which create a larger safety hazard.

my $0.02

Molten 14-03-2010 22:38

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by BrendanB (Post 937103)
Never heard of parades in the pit either!

Molten: Since when is robots running around wild in the pits happened? And wouldn't wearing the extra padding cushion you from the impact just a little more than wearing shorts and a shirt? Just some of my thoughts.

I've seen a parade or two. They aren't common, but usually consist of a bunch of kids in goofy outfits. Once saw a parade of guys in skirts.

Also, I was referring to teams getting in and out of pits between matches. Some move pretty fast with a short warning of "bot coming through" and thats it. The padding is nice if you were to get hit, but increases your chances of getting hit. I'd rather nobody get hit in the first place.

BrendanB 14-03-2010 22:41

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Molten (Post 937114)
I've seen a parade or two. They aren't common, but usually consist of a bunch of kids in goofy outfits. Once saw a parade of guys in skirts.

Also, I was referring to teams getting in and out of pits between matches. Some move pretty fast with a short warning of "bot coming through" and thats it. The padding is nice if you were to get hit, but increases your chances of getting hit. I'd rather nobody get hit in the first place.

I thought you were referring to LIVE robots, in that case, it is the teams fault as they should keep that to the practice field.

Solutions: Yell robot over and over and remember you are not the only one moving in the pits.

Not2B 14-03-2010 22:46

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
I don't like Mascots in the pits. They are there to entertain and drum up energy in the crowds. But more importantly, it's unsafe. Reduced visibility, odd fitting clothes, people moving around. It's not worth the risk.

I won't allow our mascot, Gigawatt, into the pits (or up and down stairs for that matter). And if you ever see it in the pits, tell it to get out.

A rule to ban them? I don't know. Not all mascots are the same. What about someone just wearing special clothes that is the mascot, but not a plush mascot. Too much wishy washy rulings. I would hope each team would be able to understand the safety risks and decide independently. (Of course, music in the pits had to be banned because some teams didn't see the issue...)

That didn't answer much of the question, did it?

Travis Hoffman 14-03-2010 23:23

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Not2B (Post 937128)

I won't allow our mascot, Gigawatt, into the pits (or up and down stairs for that matter). And if you ever see it in the pits, tell it to get out.

I like how you refer to your mascot as an "it". :)

Whenever we had our Safety Stormtrooper or TIE Fighter Pilot in the pits, we had someone on our team help guide them around while they were wearing their helmets and their peripheral vision was compromised.

One might prefer the bulkier mascots stay out of the pit aisles and definitely out of any one pit, but then, what's to say someone doesn't play the mascot discrimination card, turn the tables, and suggest that all fat guys be banned from the pits as well? I think that would ban 70% of our mentor crew. In a collision with a mascot of any size, I'd so win, though.

Which brings up an idea for a fun timeout activity on the field the next time the Pittsburgh field's blue alliance scoring system decides to forget the score in the middle of the match (have fun with that one, Waterloo) - Oversize Mascot/Mentor Sumo Wrestling.

Now there's a tangent for you.

JaneYoung 14-03-2010 23:59

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
LASA Robotics competes in BEST and this year I worked basically as a bouncer (my pet word for door monitor) in the pits at one of the competitions. The teams are given so many pit passes. It is up to them as to how they use them, but each person that entered the pit had to be wearing a pit pass. It kept traffic way down and allowed the pits to be used more efficiently by the teams, in my opinion. Being a bouncer (door monitor checking pit passes) sure taught me a lot about the teams and how they interact as a team and how they work within the rules set forth in the competition.

At state level, teams can bring in pep bands to help in the spirit end of things. From what I can tell, the teams have rules about their band members and their instruments. The band stays in the stands for a given period of time and when they leave, their instruments go with them. They are there to serve one purpose and one purpose only - to help provide spirit in the arena. In my opinion, mascots serve that same purpose. They can support their team and participate in mascot dances and cheers. They don't belong in the pits.

At some regionals that I have attended, I have seen areas near the pits where mascots have been allowed to gather but not directly in the pits. I think that if a student is needed in the pit and is also a mascot, the mascot costume gets stored safely and the student enters the pit to do the work needed.

It's always good to have a handler for the mascot to insure that they aren't bullied by children (yes, that happens), and to make sure they stay hydrated, esp. if they are in full costume. The handler can also help the mascot navigate their surroundings. Careful planning should go with having a mascot on the team and the guidelines should be clear and in place for them and for the team that travels with them.

Jane

synth3tk 15-03-2010 09:50

Re: Should mascots be allowed in the pit?
 
Travis, we're supposed to entertain the crowd, not scare the living crap out of them. :rolleyes:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:37.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi