Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   The Top Ten (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=86439)

Jared Russell 30-07-2010 09:09

Re: The Top Ten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 340x4xLife (Post 970430)
... 1 Hall of Fame, 15 Regional Chairman's Awards, 5 Division Champs, 12 Regional wins.

13 Regional Wins (we have 5 :))

Rich Kressly 30-07-2010 10:55

Re: The Top Ten
 
how about 71-71?
:ahh:

Justin Montois 30-07-2010 11:07

Re: The Top Ten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jared341 (Post 970453)
13 Regional Wins (we have 5 :))

There's probably more mistakes, got the info off the FIRST website. :)

JesseK 30-07-2010 11:54

Re: The Top Ten
 
Normalize the question, otherwise the results are skewed and we can spend days arguing. "Best in the History of FIRST" shouldn't pit 1994 teams against 2010 teams because the dynamics are completely different between then and now.

I'd suggest an era-based approach, for example a 'last 5 years' approach. Dynasty teams from the early 2000's that haven't produced much as far as mult-regional wins, Einstein or CMP awards in recent years shouldn't get love over teams that have for the 'last 5 years'.

Eras:
The old-schoolers ('92-'99) denoting the days before coopertition
The ramp-up ('00-'04) denoting the years before FRC really hit the bend in the exponential growth curve and also introduction of common COTS gearboxes
The newGens ('05-'08) based upon the old control system
GenNext ('09-present) based upon the new control system

Peter Matteson 30-07-2010 13:03

Re: The Top Ten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JesseK (Post 970468)
Eras:
The old-schoolers ('92-'00) denoting the days before coopertition

Slight correction.
Co-opertition started in '99. (Tecknocats were the last sole champ in '98 and Juggernauts, Delphi Elite and Aces High were the first Co-Champs in '99)
Divisions started in 2001.

Mark McLeod 30-07-2010 14:25

Re: The Top Ten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JesseK (Post 970468)
... for example a 'last 5 years' approach. Dynasty teams from the early 2000's that haven't produced much as far as multi-regional wins, Einstein or CMP awards in recent years shouldn't get love over teams that have for the 'last 5 years'.

That approach mixes things up a bit.

For the years 2005 to 2010

Teams
Ending
at ---- #Awards - #Teams
-----------------------------
70 ------- 117 --------- 7
120 ----- 105 --------- 7
360 ------ 89 ---------- 7
240 ------ 87 ---------- 7
1720 ---- 85 ---------- 9
180 ------ 84 --------- 10
350 ------ 79 ---------- 5
40 ------- 74 ---------- 5
370 ------ 74 ---------- 5
1520 ---- 72 ---------- 9
80 ------- 66 ---------- 6
230 ------ 64 ---------- 8
470 ------ 61 ---------- 6
300 ------ 59 ---------- 6
1630 ---- 58 ---------- 4
50 -------- 57 ---------- 4
110 ------ 56 ---------- 5
60 -------- 55 ---------- 6
1750 ----- 55 ---------- 9
130 ------ 54 ---------- 6


Note that the 1711-1720 & 1741-1750 blocks only existed for 4 of those 5 years.

It's also interesting that for the 171-180 block of teams, each and every one of the teams remains active.

Gene F 01-08-2010 19:51

Re: The Top Ten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 340x4xLife (Post 970430)
Not to plug our own ten, but the 340's are pretty good for only having 6 teams. Especially with Chairmans...

340- 5- RCA,2- Division champs, 2-regional champs, 2-regional finalist
341- Hall of Fame,4-RCA, 1-Divison Champ, 4- Regional Champs, CMP EI
342- 4-RCA, 1-Regional Champ, 3- Regional finalists
343- 2-RCA, 1- Division Champ, 4- Regional Champs
346- 1- Reginal Champ, 3- Regional Finalist
348- 1- Division Champ, 1 CHMP Finalist

... 1 Hall of Fame, 15 Regional Chairman's Awards, 5 Division Champs, 12 Regional wins.

Team 343 has 6 regional championships.

Mark McLeod 02-08-2010 12:12

Re: The Top Ten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gene F (Post 970629)
Team 343 has 6 regional championships.

I count 8 Regional Championships for Team 343.

2001 FL
2001 VA
2002 FL
2002 MO
2005 VA
2006 VA
2008 GA
2010 SC

Justin Montois 05-08-2010 23:29

Re: The Top Ten
 
Wow the FIRST website is terrible for records. You'd think THE organizing body would keep the best records.

Good thing we have CD.

cziggy343 06-08-2010 13:33

Re: The Top Ten
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Mark McLeod (Post 970677)
I count 8 Regional Championships for Team 343.

2001 FL
2001 VA
2002 FL
2002 MO
2005 VA
2006 VA
2008 GA
2010 SC

didn't go to VA in 05. 7 regional wins for 343 :p and we also were Einstein finalsits as well as Championship EI winners in '03.

still going with 61-70 as the best ten :D

Mark McLeod 06-08-2010 13:49

Re: The Top Ten
 
My mistake. The winners at VA in '05 were 401, 435, & 122.

JackN 06-08-2010 15:28

Re: The Top Ten
 
What about 71-80. I think the teams covered in this range are just as good as the teams from 61-70. We all know about team 71, who still has the most championship victories in the history. Team 78 was in their first year this season, but looking at the success that team 121 had with many of the members that make up the team. One of my favorite teams, 79 is also included in this group. I am willing to bet they are the only team to eliminate the #1 alliance as the #8 alliance in Atlanta twice. Teams 74 and 75 are both well respected, well known, and successful teams in their respective areas.

waialua359 06-08-2010 15:29

Re: The Top Ten
 
I'm glad that a couple of Hawaii teams (359, 368) are helping to keep the 360 group in the mix. I believe that both our teams have about 60 FRC awards since we started in 2000.
Some of the FIRST data is inaccurate and missing stuff. They also deleted any awards prior to 2001. Not sure why.

EricH 06-08-2010 21:24

Re: The Top Ten
 
You know, when Chris posted the 60s, he forgot one.

64: Gila Monsters (split into 39 and a couple of other teams after the 2005 season)
They only won a ton of awards... culminating with a world finalist. They were a force to be reckoned with out here on the West Coast.

Tetraman 06-08-2010 22:32

Re: The Top Ten
 
61-70 is probably the best bracket and 171-180 is the very close second.

Chris is me has the best take on it, (except technicly 174 has 3 FLR wins).

It's really tough to bracket another series of teams.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 13:41.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi