Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Extra Discussion (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=68)
-   -   pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=89768)

Cory 22-01-2011 03:59

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
This has to be a joke. Conservatively, that would be a NINE HUNDRED POUND block of aluminum. 7075 is about $7-10 per pound. That's a $6000-9000 block of aluminum. No sponsor is stupid enough to waste that kind of material. This also ignores the fact that there is no such thing as 7071 aluminum. The frame would also be substantially weaker than a properly constructed welded tube or sheet-metal chassis.

Basically...obvious troll is obvious.

SirTasty 22-01-2011 04:37

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
In that case, I must leave a well-deserved,

114Klaatu0x72 22-01-2011 05:34

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Decagon wheels mounted directly the cims will be the drive train of the future.

MrForbes 22-01-2011 09:56

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Very nice design! Robotics is supposed to be fun...this is definitely fun :)

Tom Ore 22-01-2011 10:00

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
I agree that this is good fun - most likely this is someone's practical joke on CD. If not, one consolation is that you learn more from failure than success.

Sean Raia 22-01-2011 10:14

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Consider the following: his name is poohbear, this was his first post, his location is "the dirty south", and he claims his robot can go 105 miles per hour... this all sounds pretty legitamate to me.

poohbear 22-01-2011 10:39

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 114Klaatu0x72 (Post 1005556)
Decagon wheels mounted directly the cims will be the drive train of the future.

I have to agree with this one. You all will see!

ratdude747 22-01-2011 13:02

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
i smell troll...

AlexH 22-01-2011 18:11

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
So its about 865 amps to spin the wheels (assuming 6" wheels and a 120lb bot) and victors are rated at 40 amps. That comes out to 22 victors per side times 4 (22 victors per each motor) is 88 victors and that comes out to $7920 excluding shipping. Are you sure you want to spend almost 8 grand on ESC's?

Also the CIMS stall current is 133 amps so you might want to find a better way to drive your bot because 865 is 6 1/2 times the rated stall current of the CIMs

Trent B 22-01-2011 18:49

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by AlexH (Post 1005838)
So its about 865 amps to spin the wheels (assuming 6" wheels and a 120lb bot) and victors are rated at 40 amps. That comes out to 22 victors per side times 4 (22 victors per each motor) is 88 victors and that comes out to $7920 excluding shipping. Are you sure you want to spend almost 8 grand on ESC's?

Also the CIMS stall current is 133 amps so you might want to find a better way to drive your bot because 865 is 6 1/2 times the rated stall current of the CIMs

Forget about the number of victors needed. You have a 120 amp kill switch :ahh:

basicxman 22-01-2011 19:54

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Cory (Post 1005548)
Basically...obvious troll is obvious.

Quote:

Originally Posted by SirTasty (Post 1005553)
In that case, I must leave a well-deserved,

Agreed, but my lord this thread was funny. I'm giving the poster a rep.

Thermal 22-01-2011 20:07

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Great design! But, there is one small issue. You have no fillets for strength in your design.

Add some fillets and you'll be indestructable! Also, go with 9 sides, because like JVN said, nonagonal robots have a 100% winning percentage.

Joe Schornak 22-01-2011 22:19

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
After viewing this robot design, and the request for veteran tips within, I decided that it would be a good idea to put together a robot design guide, so that we can all learn to design effective robots in the future.

BEHOLD! Joe Schornak's Robot Design Guide


nighterfighter 22-01-2011 22:46

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
Freshmen with drills and jigsaws ARE a cheap alternative to a 5 axis mill though!

DavidGitz 22-01-2011 23:28

Re: pic: Final 2011 Drivetrain
 
This is pretty awesome, and loving the Picard Maneuver reference. A small part of my mind wonders though, if this poster wasn't trolling. Then I would feel bad, on a couple different levels.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:27.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi