Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Legality of Fiberglass as a building material? (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=89964)

Dripto 24-01-2011 16:17

Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
We weren't able to find anything mentioning the legality of Fiberglass in the manual, does anyone know if its legal as a building material, or if it has been in past years? Thanks.

Joe G. 24-01-2011 16:21

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Perfectly legal, as long as it doesn't violate cost and other rules. 842 has been known for their pultruded fiberglass frames for several years. As a general rule, if a material isn't specifically stated as illegal, it probably is allowed.

Mike Betts 24-01-2011 17:05

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Because of venue restrictions (not to mention just plain good manners) I would not plan on being able to mix/cure resin in the pits at a competition. You should ask yourself, what do we do if this fails at the comp?

davidthefat 24-01-2011 18:02

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe G. (Post 1007299)
Perfectly legal, as long as it doesn't violate cost and other rules. 842 has been known for their pultruded fiberglass frames for several years. As a general rule, if a material isn't specifically stated as illegal, it probably is allowed.

Depleted uranium is not banned... Does that mean that we can use it? :rolleyes:

But honestly what if we were to get our hands on that stuff? How amazing would that be?

548swimmer 24-01-2011 18:03

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by davidthefat (Post 1007380)
Depleted uranium is not banned... Does that mean that we can use it? :rolleyes:

But honestly what if we were to get our hands on that stuff? How amazing would that be?

Little bit heavy, but otherwise awesome!

falconmaster 24-01-2011 20:01

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Its available from
http://www.creativepultrusions.com/

Most plastics distributors can order it

Gdeaver 24-01-2011 22:25

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Another source Bedford Reinforced Plastics, Inc.
http://www.bedfordplastics.com/

MrForbes 24-01-2011 22:33

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by 548swimmer (Post 1007381)
Little bit heavy, but otherwise awesome!

They make it in different thicknesses, and the 1/8" stuff is strong and light. We've used it too. I hear it also works for arms?

Henry Williams 24-01-2011 22:37

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Even though it is legal there are a few things I would want to say.
Fiberglass is not very light
It is also somewhat brittle depending on shape etc.
I say both from experience as me and my friend were putting away an entire field's worth of the playing surface from Lunacy, aka regolith, and it took us a long time because if you picked up too many sheets at once it would crack, splinter, and form sharp edges.

Maybe my views are somewhat skewed from my experiences with fiberglass so maybe things will work out differently for you.

Team 2811 24-01-2011 22:51

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Fiberglass is very easy to break and if it does, you will have to take all of the rest of the fiberglass off. Then you will have to replace it. If this happens multiple times, the cost will really add up.

Just my advice. My team tried using fibergalss in 2009 during Lunacy. It was constantly breaking and we needed to replace it often. This really added up in our costs.

Good luck

MrForbes 24-01-2011 22:52

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Interesting, we used it for our chassis for 3 years and never had these problems. I guess it depends on how you design your robot....you have to use fiberglass in appropriate places, and design the thing properly, then it works fine. Like any other material, I suppose.

Gdeaver 24-01-2011 23:53

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
It's all in the design, choice of material and construction techniques. We have made many light weight and durable arms from pultrusions. Never had a failure. I have seen many AL arms eat them selves. I have seen teams use poor construction methods with Pultrusions and watch them fail.

davidthefat 25-01-2011 00:41

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by squirrel (Post 1007670)
They make it in different thicknesses, and the 1/8" stuff is strong and light. We've used it too. I hear it also works for arms?

Where can one acquire these materials from?

Akash Rastogi 25-01-2011 01:30

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Gdeaver (Post 1007756)
It's all in the design, choice of material and construction techniques. We have made many light weight and durable arms from pultrusions. Never had a failure. I have seen many AL arms eat them selves. I have seen teams use poor construction methods with Pultrusions and watch them fail.

Same here, we've used it in simple but effective applications on our 2008 arm.

Machining/drilling holes in fiberglass is the only hassle. Masks and gloves along with goggles::safety::

MrForbes 25-01-2011 09:54

Re: Legality of Fiberglass as a building material?
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by davidthefat (Post 1007793)
Where can one acquire these materials from?

See post #6 in this thread. Generally it's a good idea to read all the posts in a thread, before asking a question about the subject.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 21:38.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi