Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Electrical (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=53)
-   -   Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=92499)

garyk 20-02-2011 20:27

Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
I came aross a battery hazard I hadn't thought of before. I asked one of my team members to remove the pigtails (power cable and plug) from an old battery. I'm sure the battery still had charge to it.

She enterprisingly recruited another team member to help, and I saw that each had a wrench on the battery - one on the positive erminal and one on the negative. I immediately asked them to stop. If there's a wrench on each terminal, and the wrenches touch one another, they will short the battery!! Any piece of metal will conduct electricity, not just a wire and not just copper.

FYI, I could envision this happening, especially in a pit if two people change or just tighten connections and are in a hurry. Only one wrench on a battery at a time!

slijin 20-02-2011 21:42

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
As well-intentioned as this is, just how would the two wrenches contact each other while contacting the terminals? Wrenches aren't exactly as flexible as wires.

EricH 20-02-2011 21:48

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slijin (Post 1027911)
As well-intentioned as this is, just how would the two wrenches contact each other while contacting the terminals? Wrenches aren't exactly as flexible as wires.

Gimme a large pair of open-end wrenches (uninsulated, naturally) and some electrically-insulated reaching devices and I'll show you. Wrenches slip, wrench ends meet, "nice" shower of sparks.

Or, the human body can conduct electricity. Two students working contact, and the resistance is low enough, not only do you have sparks, but you have two shocked students, literally.

MrForbes 20-02-2011 21:55

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
It's not hard to short a battery with two wrenches, or a single screwdriver. I warned our students about the dangers several times before they assembled batteries to cables. It's a serious business. Please be careful and think about what you're doing.

Al Skierkiewicz 23-02-2011 22:16

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
garyk,
the greater danger here is that if the two wrenches touch while both contacting battery terminals, the chance for welding currents to flow is very high. Once the wrenches weld together and to the battery terminals, they will go to several hundred degrees rather rapidly depending on the state of charge. That temperature is also reflected in the battery which causes a rapid pressure rise that can lead to case failure, electrolyte leakage and possible explosion. It is for this reason, all battery terminals must be insulated at all times. Only work on one terminal while the other is insulated. The voltage is low enough that it can't force enough current through your body to be felt unless it is across a very sensitive (read that packed with lot's of nerves) area that is wet like with sweat or salt water.

pfreivald 23-02-2011 22:27

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Right. The danger with these batteries isn't electrocution, it's the spraying of boiling battery acid all around the general vicinity.

Not good for anyone!

cgmv123 23-02-2011 22:46

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
The batteries are sealed for that exact reason.

Al Skierkiewicz 23-02-2011 23:02

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Max,
The batteries are sealed so that you can use them upside down. The seals will not hold and likely will not be able to vent enough gas in abusive situations like shorted battery terminals. Case failure is the result.

pfreivald 23-02-2011 23:05

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by cgmv123 (Post 1030378)
The batteries are sealed for that exact reason.

Well, they're sealed so that you can tip them and nothing will spill... But sealed batteries brought to a boil create pressure that will eventually (and in the case of a terminal short that doesn't burn up whatever is shorting them like a fuse, very quickly) rupture the case, allowing the pressurized badness within to escape at high velocity...

MrForbes 23-02-2011 23:25

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Skierkiewicz (Post 1030354)
Once the wrenches weld together and to the battery terminals, they will go to several hundred degrees rather rapidly

This is a serious danger, you can be burned badly by hot wires or wrenches. I've seen it happen.

JDL 24-02-2011 16:58

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Al Skierkiewicz (Post 1030386)
Max,
The batteries are sealed so that you can use them upside down. The seals will not hold and likely will not be able to vent enough gas in abusive situations like shorted battery terminals. Case failure is the result.

I can tell you from experience ::ouch:: that a sealed battery will almost defiantly blow up during a fault, actually a non sealed battery probably will too under the proper conditions. And there is usually quite a mess to clean up after.

Put some care into working with batteries everyone. Use insulated tools or wrap regular wrenches and drivers with electrical tape. Same goes for test probes for meters and such, as little exposed metal as possible.

gorrilla 24-02-2011 17:03

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
It is quite dangerous, I shorted one of our 2005 batteries with a screwdriver while changing the leads, it wasn't fun...

dmitch 25-02-2011 15:50

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
I know for a fact that one screwdriver is enough to short a battery if the person is not paying attention. Thats why we have a black burn mark on our famed orange-handled screwdriver now. The kid wasnt paying attention and shorted the battery and got shocked in the process. 2 Wrenches could easily short a battery and shock 2 people instead of just 1.

Alan Anderson 25-02-2011 16:47

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dmitch (Post 1031359)
The kid wasnt paying attention and shorted the battery and got shocked in the process. 2 Wrenches could easily short a battery and shock 2 people instead of just 1.

12 volts isn't really enough to shock anyone unless it goes through wet skin. The person is likely to be startled (and perhaps slightly stung) by the sparks that fly upon initial contact.

The immediate hazard is from extreme heat as current flows unimpeded through the metal tool. The slightly less immediate but more dangerous hazard is from shrapnel and acid from an exploding battery.

DonRotolo 25-02-2011 22:57

Re: Battery Safety - two wrenches on the same battery
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by pfreivald (Post 1030366)
Right. The danger with these batteries isn't electrocution, it's the spraying of boiling battery acid all around the general vicinity.
Not good for anyone!

Not to mention the sharp and tiny bits of lead and plastic, coupled with globs of strong sulphuric acid. More than enough to ruin your day, week, month and year in a flash.

I, too, have seen the aftermath of a battery explosion. You too would never forget it.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:51.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi