Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Robot Showcase (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=58)
-   -   Team 190 Promo Video (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=92889)

Nuttyman54 24-02-2011 20:44

Team 190 Promo Video
 
Team 190 Presents our latest creation: Gompe-saurus Rex, or G-Rex for short. It's one of the best looking and performing machines we've created to date. Built for speed and plays all aspects of the game. Minibot and deployment are under wraps until competition.

http://vimeo.com/20350475

Specs:
Drive - 4 CIM 6wd, can be changed from 6 traction dropped center to inline rear omnis for a more forward turning center.

Tube Scoring - Fast roller claw with elevator, 1.5 seconds bottom to top

Minibot - Secret. Deployment system includes alignment device (shown) to line up robot.

Autonomous - Camera controlled heading, ultrasonic controlled distance.

Grim Tuesday 24-02-2011 20:55

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Wow looks amazing! Fantastic lift and gripper!

dodar 24-02-2011 21:32

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Ive seen most teams using those green wheels for roller claws, what kind of wheels are they? who makes them?

Jeffy 24-02-2011 21:34

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by dodar (Post 1030958)
Ive seen most teams using those green wheels for roller claws, what kind of wheels are they? who makes them?

www.Banebots.com

swamp_child 24-02-2011 21:36

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Those would be banebot wheels.
http://banebots.com/c/WHB-WS-398
one of those

dodar 24-02-2011 21:41

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
I know that BB gearboxes are back ordered, so would that mean the wheels would be too?

Chris is me 24-02-2011 21:44

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
That looks far too simple to be a 190 robot.

Nuttyman54 24-02-2011 21:48

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Chris is me (Post 1030972)
That looks far too simple to be a 190 robot.

You haven't seen what goes on the back yet :-P. Trust me, it's 190 through and through.

Akash Rastogi 24-02-2011 22:13

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Hoping for another wall of maroon?

Sick gripper and I like the compact lift.

EgROS 24-02-2011 22:15

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Wow. A tube comes anywhere near that gripper and it snatches it right up. Well done!

Carter12s 24-02-2011 22:24

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
That looks fantastic! I really hope we can pit our bots against each other! Good Luck!

ks_mumupsi 25-02-2011 04:52

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Cant wait to see this at DC :)

Good looking bot and awesome music on the video.

Kims Robot 25-02-2011 08:02

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Simply amazing... I want to buy one of those grippers... just to run around my house with lol :)

Looks like another Einstein contender!

jwfoss 25-02-2011 08:06

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Easily one of the fastest roller grippers I've seen this year. Congrats on building a solid robot this year, I can't wait to get a closer look at it in a couple weeks at the WPI Regional.

lenny8 25-02-2011 08:20

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
all i can say is SICK!!!!! great job guys

Chris is me 25-02-2011 10:12

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
So, how well do you guys pass tubes?

It looks like between the traction drive train and the fast gripper, you guys can serve not only as scorer but as tube relay.

JesseK 25-02-2011 10:47

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
I look forward to seeing this one in person in DC!

gren737 25-02-2011 12:35

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
this is a hoax...it can't be a wpi robot since it's working before ship date....


:yikes:

Nuttyman54 25-02-2011 13:24

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by gren737 (Post 1031267)
this is a hoax...it can't be a wpi robot since it's working before ship date....


:yikes:

This is the real deal, no hoaxes here! It is a rare occurence that the robot is at this level of completion by ship, but it would not be the first time. 2007 and 2009 come to mind...;)

=Martin=Taylor= 25-02-2011 21:11

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
When I see robots like this I just have to ask the question....

why....

why.........

why would you NOT build a roller claw????


Admit it, claws have no advantage over roller claws. none.

BrendanB 25-02-2011 21:15

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by =Martin=Taylor= (Post 1031509)
When I see robots like this I just have to ask the question....

why....

why.........

why would you NOT build a roller claw????


Admit it, claws have no advantage over roller claws. none.

Depends on if someone hits you from the side and it slides out. This is one of the most effective roller claw designs I have seen this season! Offsetting the top from the bottom is really effective! Good job 190!

Chris is me 25-02-2011 22:54

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by =Martin=Taylor= (Post 1031509)
When I see robots like this I just have to ask the question....

why....

why.........

why would you NOT build a roller claw????


Admit it, claws have no advantage over roller claws. none.

Weight, grip strength, simplicity... Many reasons to go pinch right there. Rollers are great, but with non spherical game pieces that slide well, pinch works.

Stephi Rae 27-02-2011 02:25

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
This claw weighs 7lbs, including the two BB550 motors with gearboxes.

The claw is designed such that it wraps around the inside of the tube, reducing the concerns of a tube being able to be hit from the side and fall out. It is also passively compliant, in order to allow for all three tubes' shapes and sizes, including partially deflated tubes. This compliance allows for constant positive pressure on the tubes to insure a good grasp.

Additionally, we are able to pick up any tube in any orientation, at any angle. This includes spinning the robot and hitting the tube from the side, or only engaging the side of the tube with none of the claw in the center of the tube.

Each of our subsystems have small unique characteristics. In typical 190 style we cannot let all things go simply conventional.

We have very much enjoyed designing and building this robot, and are looking forward to the competitions! (And to showing off our minibot and deployment systems!)

Jstack14 27-02-2011 21:08

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Very impressive robot no doubt! My only question (and maybe i missed it in the video) is does it reach the top row? Great roller claw, wish our team had done something like that but our simple claw works perfectly fine and only lets us down on a few ocasions.

Nuttyman54 27-02-2011 21:34

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jstack14 (Post 1032357)
Very impressive robot no doubt! My only question (and maybe i missed it in the video) is does it reach the top row? Great roller claw, wish our team had done something like that but our simple claw works perfectly fine and only lets us down on a few ocasions.


You didn't miss it (there is a picture in the very beginning, but it flashes by quickly). It can reach the top row, unfortunately the practice area in the hallway has too low of a ceiling for us to do that, and we didn't have the elevator running at the scrimmage. It takes approximately 1.5 seconds for the elevator to run from ground to the top row scoring height.

Navid Shafa 28-02-2011 02:03

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Nice music choice, Love the Jurassic Park clips. Looks like an all around great robot. Love the lift design, it is strikingly similar :)

Hope to see you guys again at World Champs, tell everyone hello from the Skunks!

gren737 28-02-2011 12:46

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Nuttyman54 (Post 1031290)
This is the real deal, no hoaxes here! It is a rare occurence that the robot is at this level of completion by ship, but it would not be the first time. 2007 and 2009 come to mind...;)

I'm just kidding with you guys...I'm a WPI alum and know the O'Rourke's and Ken, Brad and everyone real well, so I was just picking a little bit. WPI's normal motto is the robot will be finished by the last off-season event!

I'll be coming down to DC to visit and check it out in person! Good luck

-Sarah

JesseK 28-02-2011 13:36

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by =Martin=Taylor= (Post 1031509)
When I see robots like this I just have to ask the question....

why....

why.........

why would you NOT build a roller claw????


Admit it, claws have no advantage over roller claws. none.

Eh, you may want to qualify this claim.
  • I don't think any of the roller claws I've seen have weighed 2.5 lbs like our simple claw does (due to motor/gearing).
  • I don't think any of the roller claws I've seen cost as little as our roller claw did to fabricate (assuming free labor) -- $30 raw, $12 actual used parts (+ 1 free Bimba cyllinder & 1 KOP solenoid valve).
  • Roller claws take much more to fabricate and maintain as well.
  • Ours is designed to have a similar amount of room for driver error that a skinny roller claw does.
  • If it gets ripped off, we have another one since 2.5 lbs is easy to fit in the withholding allowance.
  • In the worst case where 2 get ripped up, we could build another one in under half an hour.

So if you're naive to always fall for 'THE best' type claims about any one design in FRC, sure roller claws would win for fastest & flashiest I suppose. Yet there is plenty of anecdotal evidence that it doesn't matter on the FRC field (330 in 2007, 217 in 2008) as much as strategy & driver practice does. So to me, holistically, roller claws and pinchy claws (or inverse-pinchy in our case) are pretty much the same for the majority of teams out there (including those who have never heard of CD) -- so long as they grab the tube in a reasonable amount of time with a reasonable room for error, then hold on to the tube, then let it go, it doesn't really matter which design is chosen.

Jared Russell 28-02-2011 13:44

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by JesseK (Post 1032665)
  • If it gets ripped off, we have another one since 2.5 lbs is easy to fit in the withholding allowance.

Spare parts do not count against the witholding allowance.

Vikesrock 28-02-2011 13:51

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Jared341 (Post 1032672)
Spare parts do not count against the witholding allowance.

You may want to look again. If the spare parts are fabricated they absolutely do count against the 30lbs as they are not one of the 3 exceptions in R33.

Nuttyman54 28-02-2011 14:34

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by =Martin=Taylor= (Post 1031509)
Admit it, claws have no advantage over roller claws. none.


To jump in to the roller claw vs standard claw debate, it depends on what advantage you're talking about. From a pure performance standpoint, disregarding all design consequences such as weight complexity, etc., a well-built roller claw will typically outperform a well-built piston claw.

Unfortunately, as with most things in life, it's not that simple. 190's 2007 robot can attest to a non-roller claw being an advantage, as the gripper on that robot weighed only 2 lbs, and thus allowed us to have a gripper. We chose a roller claw for this game because we had the weight and resources available, and were able to prototype enough iterations to drill down the design you see in the video. As JesseK points out, however, just because it's the best solution for one team doesn't mean it's the best solution for every team.

As far as spare parts go, this claw has plenty of spare parts, since it's mostly COTS items. The fabricated plastic parts weigh probably 1-2 lbs each, so they don't eat much into those 30 lbs.

davepowers 14-03-2011 00:08

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
I watched you guys at WPI over the past weekend, outstanding minibot. By far one of the best ones at the competition. That intake rollers were also awesome, it was fun going up against you guys. Good luck in St.Louis!

Nuttyman54 14-03-2011 00:13

Re: Team 190 Promo Video
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by davepowers (Post 1039026)
I watched you guys at WPI over the past weekend, outstanding minibot. By far one of the best ones at the competition. That intake rollers were also awesome, it was fun going up against you guys. Good luck in St.Louis!

Thanks! What most people don't know is that our minibot was running the entire event with smoked tetrix motors. We burned them the day before the regional in testing, but since it still worked well and reliably, we made the decision not to change it and risk compromising the reliability. We're building V2 for DC, so we should be even faster there.

Congrats on the Chairman's, see you in St. Louis!


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 09:53.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi