Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   General Forum (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=16)
-   -   Is a paintball headsheild.... (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=93220)

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 20:45

Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Okay, so I was told to check to make sure that a paint-ball head shield are allowed to be used as safety glasses. keep in mind that paint-ball masks will stop a quarter sized slug that is travelling a couple hundred feet per second. I was told to double check if I can wear it in the pit?

Lil' Lavery 04-03-2011 20:49

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
I would not let my students wear a paintball mask in the pits. I do not know their safety rating, but it's not the strength of the plastic that concerns me. It's the reduction to peripheral vision and the high probability that it could fog up that does.

paragon 04-03-2011 20:53

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
I would probably go with the safety glasses. That way no one would talk to you about appropriate safety wear.

EricH 04-03-2011 20:53

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Are paintball headshields ANSI-approved, as required by the Administrative Manual Section 4.3.1? If they are, and you can show that, you should be OK.

If not, however, then you will need to wear ANSI-approved safety glasses along with the headshield if you're going to wear the headshield at all.

Also see this, from the FRC Team Safety Manual:
Quote:

Eye and Face Protection
There are several forms of eye/face protection available to provide protection from these hazards, including safety glasses with side shields, goggles, and face shields. Inspect equipment for damage each time it is worn. If you wear prescription glasses, and they are not approved safety glasses, you must wear approved safety goggles over them to achieve
adequate protection.
Eye and face protection is required when there is a risk of exposure to the following:
 Flying particles
 Chemical exposure (such as splashes, splatters, and sprays)
Wear non-shaded, ANSI-approved eye protection in the following areas:
 When doing any work on the robot including, grinding, drilling, soldering, cutting, welding, etc.
 at FIRST events:
 Anywhere in the pit area, including walk ways and pit stations
 On the Playing Field
 On the Practice Field
 Any area posted with signs requiring the use of eye protection

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 21:04

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
http://www.google.com/products/catal...d=0CE0Q8wIwAA#
i have this one and it has a pretty good all around vision and i have anti fog spray i paint ball so the site is all good
pointing out that a paintball at 300 FPS is moving at roughly 204 MPH
The lens is shot from a distance of 1.5 meters or below at 300 FPS. The second test finds if the lens cracks or breaks under heavy stresses. The lens is shot at 400 FPS at a distance of 1.5 meters and below. The lens is shot with 4 paintballs at 3 second intervals in 4 places on the lens.
just some facts about paint ball goggles shop glasses break when hit with a paint ball round with the same test done above so wouldn't it be safe enough for the pit ?

EricH 04-03-2011 21:09

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
It's not a question of whether it can stop a paintball. It's not a question of whether you can see through it well enough. It's not a question of whether it can take a hit with a paintball better than safety glasses can.

It's a question of whether or not it meets FIRST requirements. FIRST requirements happen to include ANSI approval. You find something that tells me (and your safety judges) that it's ANSI-approved, you can wear it. If you can't find that, you have to wear safety glasses along with it. That's what the FIRST manuals (plural in this case--Administrative and Safety) say.

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 21:10

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
http://www.airsoftohio.com/forums/sh...d.php?p=117960

the second post says so. should i have a paper or something saying my googles are ansi approved?
astm also has higher standards so what if it was astm approved?

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 21:11

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by EricH (Post 1034715)
It's not a question of whether it can stop a paintball. It's not a question of whether you can see through it well enough. It's not a question of whether it can take a hit with a paintball better than safety glasses can.

It's a question of whether or not it meets FIRST requirements. FIRST requirements happen to include ANSI approval. You find something that tells me (and your safety judges) that it's ANSI-approved, you can wear it. If you can't find that, you have to wear safety glasses along with it. That's what the FIRST manuals (plural in this case--Administrative and Safety) say.

ok ill check it out

EricH 04-03-2011 21:29

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Honestly, I would hope that an ASTM rating would be enough. If FIRST won't take ASTM because it isn't ANSI...

You would want to have papers or something--often it'll be marked on the lens. A package would be ideal, but often not available. A forum post probably wouldn't be enough--not enough authority/weight behind it; unless, of course, it came from a known manufacturer. A website spec sheet would probably work.

As an example, I have a pair of safety glasses marked with a bunch of numbers in various non-see-through places. Some of those may be model numbers; others could be standard numbers that it's tested to; I'm not exactly certain which is which.

MrForbes 04-03-2011 21:37

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
1 Attachment(s)
The Z87 thing is what you're looking for (ANSI standard number)....the D1.5 is something for old men like me, mine are bifocal

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 21:39

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by squirrel (Post 1034732)
The Z87 thing is what you're looking for (ANSI standard number)....the D1.5 is something for old men like me, mine are bifocal

Thanks so now i know what to look for....

Camren 04-03-2011 21:42

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
i dont see why they wouldnt on they protect ur eyes and face from shrapnels and an 69 caliber slug two they show great spirit if your team was known for wearing them

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 21:44

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
yeah that was kind of my idea as well i am going to paint a shark mouth decal on it

EricH 04-03-2011 21:47

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
FIRST doesn't allow non-side-shielded glasses, even if those glasses are safety-rated prescription glasses.

If they are not safety rated (see discussion above), you can expect to be asked to wear safety glasses under them. And with paintball masks not looking like standard safety glasses, you can expect the safety judges to ask. If you can point them to the rating, you'll be just fine. If you can't, you will be wearing an extra set of eyewear.

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 21:52

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by EricH (Post 1034742)
FIRST doesn't allow non-side-shielded glasses, even if those glasses are safety-rated prescription glasses.

If they are not safety rated (see discussion above), you can expect to be asked to wear safety glasses under them. And with paintball masks not looking like standard safety glasses, you can expect the safety judges to ask. If you can point them to the rating, you'll be just fine. If you can't, you will be wearing an extra set of eyewear.

fair enough

Matt Krass 04-03-2011 21:55

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
I have to ask this.

Why?

I mean seriously, even if you carry the documentation around, it's gonna be a pain every time someone asks (and they will) and it seems like a lot of silly trouble to go through, just get a pair of safety glasses.

Yours may not fog up often, but they still might, and still may cause vision obstruction, plus its clunky and its going to make you sweat like a waterfall I'd bet.

I'm all for creativity, and having fun, but one thing I don't like playing games with is safety. Doesn't matter if they can stop a speeding tank, if they're obstructing your vision and becoming uncomfortable they're a safety risk in themselves and you shouldn't wear them.

These will work nicely: http://www.amazon.com/DPG54-1C-Perfo...9293568&sr=8-1 they're only $3 + shipping and they're fully rated to the ANSI approval spec.

I'm sorry if I seem rude, I've just had a long season of butting heads with people over just wearing safety glasses, and I don't think this an area that deserves any flexibility, not even the slightest!

Compete safe,
Matt

Tytus Gerrish 04-03-2011 21:55

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
full seal ANSI rated eye protection is required for paintball and airsoft. my Spartan armor has an ANSI rated motorcycle visor and its allowed at events. there is no logical reason anyone would say you are not adequately protected wearing a paintball mask.

my helmet has a 12v fan in it and i use anti-fog spray to keep it clear. but if your not huffing and puffing running around the arena you will be fine as far as fog is concerned.

ttldomination 04-03-2011 21:56

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
I mean...why would you WANT to wear these in the pits? At times it can be hard to breathe through those. It can get hot in the pits, and instead of cooling down, these helmets will only heat you up.

If you're going for the BA team look, build a good robot, don't wear a mask.

- Sunny

Tytus Gerrish 04-03-2011 21:59

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ttldomination (Post 1034750)
I mean...why would you WANT to wear these in the pits? At times it can be hard to breathe through those. It can get hot in the pits, and instead of cooling down, these helmets will only heat you up.

If you're going for the BA team look, build a good robot, don't wear a mask.

- Sunny

i would wear my armor... but its to garish and attracts too much attention

Al Skierkiewicz 04-03-2011 22:01

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Hey Doc,
I tried to do a search for JT USA and found lot's of people selling their products but no one had a link to JT USA. There was no place to find ratings or testing. Most companies that meet ANSI or UL for that matter, want everyone to know. You need to ask this question of the Q&A for a definitive answer, but I'll go out on a limb here. If asked if this headgear could be used in the pit, I would say without hesitation the answer would be NO. I wouldn't want one of my students working close in on a robot with head gear like this. One of the things that the safety rules stress is not only using devices that are safe for you, but safe for all around you. There are a variety of times when you want maximum peripheral vision and this design limits that vision. Not just to your sides but down where you are walking over objects and above to prevent standing up into someone or something. If the pit is a dangerous place for this mask, think about in the queue where it is usually dark, walking over cables, field borders, scoring devices, and other participants.
Sorry.

Tytus Gerrish 04-03-2011 22:04

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
legitimate paintball and airsoft equipment has an ANSI rating and documentation. don't buy inferior equipment.

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 22:07

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ttldomination (Post 1034750)
I mean...why would you WANT to wear these in the pits? At times it can be hard to breathe through those. It can get hot in the pits, and instead of cooling down, these helmets will only heat you up.

If you're going for the BA team look, build a good robot, don't wear a mask.

- Sunny

I'm not going for the BA look I just want to have fun just like everyone else. my team captain said have spirit and our colours are red white and black

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 22:09

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Tytus Gerrish (Post 1034753)
i would wear my armor... but its to garish and attracts too much attention

i would hug you

Dr Fritz 04-03-2011 22:13

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Matt Krass (Post 1034748)
I have to ask this.

Why?

I mean seriously, even if you carry the documentation around, it's gonna be a pain every time someone asks (and they will) and it seems like a lot of silly trouble to go through, just get a pair of safety glasses.

Yours may not fog up often, but they still might, and still may cause vision obstruction, plus its clunky and its going to make you sweat like a waterfall I'd bet.

I'm all for creativity, and having fun, but one thing I don't like playing games with is safety. Doesn't matter if they can stop a speeding tank, if they're obstructing your vision and becoming uncomfortable they're a safety risk in themselves and you shouldn't wear them.

These will work nicely: http://www.amazon.com/DPG54-1C-Perfo...9293568&sr=8-1 they're only $3 + shipping and they're fully rated to the ANSI approval spec.

I'm sorry if I seem rude, I've just had a long season of butting heads with people over just wearing safety glasses, and I don't think this an area that deserves any flexibility, not even the slightest!

Compete safe,
Matt

I see where your going and I am doing it for spirit I always use eye protection when needed and I am an observant person i can watch where i am going and really if you have gone Paint-balling before the masks don't take much of the eyesight away barely any or none at all

Matt Krass 04-03-2011 22:16

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Dr Fritz (Post 1034775)
I see where your going and I am doing it for spirit I always use eye protection when needed and I am an observant person i can watch where i am going and really if you have gone Paint-balling before the masks don't take much of the eyesight away barely any or none at all

I have gone paintballing, quite a bit actually, and that's just not true, at least not of any of the protective gear that actually... you know, protects.

Safety is more important than spirit, your team (and everyone else at the event) would rather you cheer them on with bland safety glasses from the stands instead of by phone from the emergency room.

That gear is not meant for the kind of close quarters environment you're dealing with here, just because it can take the same amount of blunt force doesn't make it necessarily safe in this environment. Nobody here wants to see the safety rules get any more complicated so please exercise common sense and don't make them spell it out for you.

MrForbes 04-03-2011 22:16

Re: Is a paintball headsheild....
 
Listen to Al. He knows whereof he speaks.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 16:04.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi