Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   Rules/Strategy (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=6)
-   -   autonomus score question (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=93497)

yarden.saa 12-03-2011 12:17

autonomus score question
 
Do we get autonomus score if at the end of the 15 sec the robot is still in contact with the uber tube

MagiChau 12-03-2011 12:21

Re: autonomus score question
 
I saw refeeres allow the score at competitions. I am not sure if it has to look like the arm is just touching or the tube will be supported if the arm wasn't there.

EricH 12-03-2011 12:22

Re: autonomus score question
 
That would depend on how you were in contact with the tube. I would suggest ensuring that your autonomous mode drops the tube at the end of autonomous.

You may also wish to look at the definition of HANGING for exactly how it is determined whether a tube counts--if the Ubertube isn't Hanging, it doesn't score.

IKE 12-03-2011 12:26

Re: autonomus score question
 
During our first Double at Kettering, the robot still grasp the tube. When Teleop started, they released the claw and left the tube. This was deemed that not only was the tube not hung (no points), but a penalty was assigned for hanging a ubertube in tele-op (penalty). We fixed that for the next match.

Brian Ha 12-03-2011 12:53

Re: autonomus score question
 
If your still in contact with the tube at the end of autonomous it doesnt count. But if you let go, get caught on a peg or something lift your hand in tele op and say knock that tube off, it still counts. This happened to us and we thought we werent going to get the points because it got knocked off but they gave us the points. So as long as you hang it and stop touching it in autonomous you should be fine.

GCentola 12-03-2011 21:00

Re: autonomus score question
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IKE (Post 1038194)
During our first Double at Kettering, the robot still grasp the tube. When Teleop started, they released the claw and left the tube. This was deemed that not only was the tube not hung (no points), but a penalty was assigned for hanging a ubertube in tele-op (penalty). We fixed that for the next match.

That would seem like a perfect example, and the same thing happened to us.

<G16> UBERTUBES may not be HUNG. Violation: PENALTY

This means, you can grab it all you want throughout the match, but if you don't let go at the beggining of Tele-op, then you may (and we did) get penalized for hanging the tube after autonomous period. Best suggestion: hang it, let go and back out.

StevenB 12-03-2011 23:17

Re: autonomus score question
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian Ha (Post 1038201)
If your still in contact with the tube at the end of autonomous it doesnt count.

That's the easiest way to interpret the rule, but that's not actually what it says:
Quote:

Originally Posted by FRC Game Manual
HANGING – a GAME PIECE is HANGING when it is fully supported by a PEG through its center hole and released by the POSSESSING ROBOT. If a GAME PIECE on the floor is preventing a GAME PIECE that has been hung on a bottom PEG from becoming fully supported (that is, if the floor GAME PIECE was not there, the hung GAME PIECE would be scored) then that GAME PIECE will still be counted as scored.

The robot can be touching the ubertube, as long as it has released the tube and isn't supporting it.

Quote:

Originally Posted by Brian Ha (Post 1038201)
But if you let go, get caught on a peg or something lift your hand in tele op and say knock that tube off, it still counts. This happened to us and we thought we werent going to get the points because it got knocked off but they gave us the points. So as long as you hang it and stop touching it in autonomous you should be fine.

You still get the AUTONOMOUS SCORE for the ubertube, because it was scored at the end of the autonomous period. I don't see anywhere in the manual that you get the doubler for the PEG SCORE if the tube comes off after that.

ayeckley 13-03-2011 09:09

Re: autonomus score question
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by IKE (Post 1038194)
During our first Double at Kettering, the robot still grasp the tube. When Teleop started, they released the claw and left the tube. This was deemed that not only was the tube not hung (no points), but a penalty was assigned for hanging a ubertube in tele-op (penalty). We fixed that for the next match.

Same thing happened to us. At the end of autonomous the ubertube was touching both the peg and our open gripper. Moved the arm down first thing in teleop and received a penalty (3 points) for hanging an ubertube in teleop. Not sure how to avoid that (descoring ourselves?). I'd have to go back and analyze the score to see if we got credit for hanging in autonomous or not and if the multiplier credit was granted. - I suspect it was.

Brian Ha 16-03-2011 11:55

Re: autonomus score question
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by StevenB (Post 1038374)

You still get the AUTONOMOUS SCORE for the ubertube, because it was scored at the end of the autonomous period. I don't see anywhere in the manual that you get the doubler for the PEG SCORE if the tube comes off after that.

Oh well idk they still gave it to us so all the better right?

pfreivald 16-03-2011 12:11

Re: autonomus score question
 
In a practice game at FLR we were blocked by a regular tube pressed against an ubertube, so we couldn't get to the feeder slot. We just drove at them hard, and the ubertube popped over the lane, bounced once, and landed on the bottom rung of our opponent's rack.

PENALTY for hanging an UBERTUBE in TELEOP.
RED CARD for scoring on our opponent's RACK.

The flagging ref said that if we could do it again, he'd buy us a pizza.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 06:55.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi