Chief Delphi

Chief Delphi (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/index.php)
-   FRC Control System (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/forumdisplay.php?f=176)
-   -   cRIO FRC2 (http://www.chiefdelphi.com/forums/showthread.php?t=94889)

MagiChau 01-05-2011 11:49

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by reuven (Post 1057635)
did they say when the new cRIO will be sold to veteran teams?
its important to us (shipping time, customs etc....) in this side of the world

Bill says he was told sometime in the fall, otherwise than that I do not know.

Zholl 01-05-2011 12:38

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Zholl (Post 1057562)
By my understanding it's the same microcontroller with fewer ports and more memory. That extra storage will probably be the only real performance boost you see

I just wanted to correct myself here, as I did go and talk to an NI rep on Saturday after I posted this just to get it straight from the horses mouth. The differences we'll for those who don't want to read the specs are basically the smaller form factor, a smaller 2-pin power cable instead of that 4-pin we've been using, we lose the second network port and the DIP switches, more memory and flash, and a new chipset, which, while not exactly more powerful will still be faster than the old one

RyanCahoon 01-05-2011 12:51

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by EricVanWyk (Post 1057491)
Any mention of the processor?

According to the FRC Live session it's a newer processor (Freescale 5125), but still at the same 400MHz clockspeed. Someone would probably have to go digging through manuals to find if there's any kind of performance benefit, i.e. between the ISAs.

--Ryan

Alan Anderson 01-05-2011 15:59

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
They removed the physical DIP switches and one Ethernet connector. That cuts down on the number of places debris can find its way inside, and apparently a lot of teams have been breaking switches by using inappropriate tools (e.g. a large screwdriver) to flip them. The equivalent of "virtual DIP switches" can be set using software (the MAX tool, I think). Holding down the reset button for the right time will boot the cRIO in safe mode.

The FPGA is a newer one with the possibility of DSP features being used.

The power connector is the same size, but it only has two pins instead of four. The new cRIO will function down to 9 volts (the old one dropped out at 19), so prototyping and development power options are less limited.

The types of modules supported in each slot is still defined by the FPGA image. The fourth slot isn't yet set; they'll be using team input such as results from the Kit of Parts survey to decide what to do with it.

It sounded like teams are eligible this fall to buy both a full system (~$550) and a bare chassis (~$300).

ratdude747 01-05-2011 17:43

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
must be soon; they already had 2 samples at the NI area in the pits.

I wonder if the crio will be wired like the old IFI controllers with a 20A run from the distribution board or if the 24v connector will continue to be used.

I like the new 2c connector and the wire shell it provides. that is a nice feature since the existing 4c connectors tend to lose their wires a lot.

jhersh 01-05-2011 17:47

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Joe Ross (Post 1057629)
It looks like the same form factor, but the cRIO FRC2 has the same FPGA as the current cRIO, and not a virtex like the 9075/6.

The FPGA in the cRIO-FRC2 is the same Xilinx Spartan 6 LX45 that is in the cRIO-9076.

-Joe

jhersh 01-05-2011 18:00

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by ratdude747 (Post 1057786)
I wonder if the crio will be wired like the old IFI controllers with a 20A run from the distribution board or if the 24v connector will continue to be used.

You should still connect it to the 24V connector for competition so you are taking advantage of the regulation on the PD that will keep your cRIO operating even if the battery drops to 5V.

jhersh 01-05-2011 18:01

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by RyanCahoon (Post 1057663)
According to the FRC Live session it's a newer processor (Freescale 5125), but still at the same 400MHz clockspeed. Someone would probably have to go digging through manuals to find if there's any kind of performance benefit, i.e. between the ISAs.

--Ryan

Bigger cache and higher memory bandwidth.

artdutra04 02-05-2011 19:25

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Since the photo posted earlier in the thread is now a broken link, here's another photo of the cRio FRC2:


Alan Anderson 02-05-2011 19:37

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
One more pair of factoids: the mounting holes through the base are smaller, and there are only two holes at the end of the chassis instead of three.

Trent B 02-05-2011 20:01

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Alan Anderson (Post 1057734)
It sounded like teams are eligible this fall to buy both a full system (~$550) and a bare chassis (~$300).

So in other words if our team has one compact rio now we could, for 850 dollars have 3 chassis (1 old, 2 new) with one of each of the 3 modules if what you believe you heard was correct.

slijin 03-05-2011 01:44

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by Trent B (Post 1058365)
So in other words if our team has one compact rio now we could, for 850 dollars have 3 chassis (1 old, 2 new) with one of each of the 3 modules if what you believe you heard was correct.

The bare chassis alone will cost $300; the bare chassis with the Analog Breakout, Digital Sidecar, and Solenoid Breakout modules will cost $550.

I personally doubt that you will be able to purchase both packages for the lump sum of $850 because it is likely that some sort of discount for the first purchase of the year will be instituted, and then a full price will be charged for all the other purchases (as has been the system with cRIOs for the past 2 years).

artdutra04 03-05-2011 04:22

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by slijin (Post 1058540)
I personally doubt that you will be able to purchase both packages for the lump sum of $850 because it is likely that some sort of discount for the first purchase of the year will be instituted, and then a full price will be charged for all the other purchases (as has been the system with cRIOs for the past 2 years).

It was mentioned at FRC Live that the bare chassis would be considered an "upgrade" cRIO, whereas the full chassis with modules would be an "extra" cRIO. Thus, for the first year they are available, a team would be able to purchase both one upgrade and one extra for a total of $850.

thefro526 03-05-2011 10:59

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by jhersh (Post 1057805)
You should still connect it to the 24V connector for competition so you are taking advantage of the regulation on the PD that will keep your cRIO operating even if the battery drops to 5V.

After speaking with one of the NI Reps at the Championship, the impression that I got was that the New CRio was being designed so that it could run on 12V, eliminating the need for 24V power from the PD board. But, I may have been wrong in my interpretation.

Overall, I'm happy with the idea of a newer smaller CRio, considering that we've never used more than 4 of the slots in the original CRio - and I'm happy that someone somewhere is listening to the feedback teams have been giving over the last few years in respect to the CRio.

Jared Russell 03-05-2011 11:55

Re: cRIO FRC2
 
Quote:

Originally Posted by thefro526 (Post 1058633)
After speaking with one of the NI Reps at the Championship, the impression that I got was that the New CRio was being designed so that it could run on 12V, eliminating the need for 24V power from the PD board. But, I may have been wrong in my interpretation.

Considering that my team as well as a few others were able to brown out the cRIO when under heavy load (6+ CIMs + RS775s near stall at once) at various points this year, I certainly intend on using the 24V regulated supply if it is still allowed. You could probably run on an unregulated 12V supply for a benchtop test, but I wouldn't trust it when traction wheels meet carpet.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 02:44.

Powered by vBulletin® Version 3.6.4
Copyright ©2000 - 2017, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.
Copyright © Chief Delphi